01Facts
The petitioner was appointed as a Constable on 29.08.1990.
¶ 2On 16.11.1996, while on security duty at Tili Hospital, he allegedly abused and assaulted Prakash Valmiki, a sweeper posted there.
¶ 2A charge-sheet was issued. The petitioner filed no reply and did not attend the inquiry, so the Inquiry Officer proceeded ex parte and held both charges proved.
¶ 2After a copy of the report was supplied and the petitioner replied to the show-cause notice, the disciplinary authority terminated his services by order dated 27.09.1997.
¶ 3The appellate authority dismissed his appeal on 14.12.2006.
¶ 3His mercy petition was rejected on 29.05.2017.
¶ 3The petitioner argued that the charges were not grave, that dismissal was disproportionate, and that a minor penalty should have been considered first under Police Regulation 226.
¶ 4The respondents stated that the petitioner had faced 11 earlier minor penalties (8 for unauthorised absence, and one withholding of an annual increment), and that he was censured 11 times in seven years.
¶ 6, 802Issues
i.1. Whether the High Court, exercising writ jurisdiction under Article 226, may interfere with the findings and punishment imposed in a departmental inquiry.
¶ 10ii.2. Whether the punishment of termination/dismissal from service was disproportionate to the charges, such that a minor penalty should have been imposed first.
¶ 4, 5, 10, 11iii.3. Whether the disciplinary proceedings complied with natural justice and Police Regulation 226, notwithstanding the petitioner's non-participation in the inquiry.
¶ 8, 1003Law Applied
The Court applied the settled limits of judicial review in disciplinary matters, drawing on State of Karnataka v. N. Gangraj (2020) 3 SCC 423, which in turn relies on State of A.P. v. S. Sree Rama Rao, B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India, High Court of Bombay v. Shashikant S. Patil, State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur v. Nemi Chand Nalwaya, and Union of India v. P. Gunasekaran.
¶ 10Under these authorities, the writ court is not an appellate forum. It may interfere only where the inquiry violates natural justice or statutory procedure, or where the findings are perverse or based on no evidence.
¶ 10Proportionality of punishment is reviewable only if it shocks the conscience of the court.
¶ 10, citing GunasekaranThe High Court must not reappreciate evidence, as held in State Bank of India v. Ramesh Dinkar Punde (2006) 7 SCC 212.
¶ 10Police Regulation 226 governs the imposition of penalties on police personnel, and the Court found that it was complied with.
¶ 10Serious misconduct and repeated indiscipline justify severe punishment, and the petitioner's earlier penalty history is relevant to that assessment.
¶ 10, 1104Reasoning
The Court first set out the limited scope of judicial review, which bars re-evaluation of evidence and a merits-based review of the penalty.
¶ 10The petitioner had not replied to the charge-sheet and had not participated in the inquiry, so he could not complain of procedural lapses that he had himself caused.
¶ 10The Court accepted that the inquiry and the disciplinary authority's compliance with Police Regulation 226 had been established on the record.
¶ 10On proportionality, the Court weighed the gravity of the charges (abuse and assault of a fellow government employee on duty) against the petitioner's record: 11 earlier minor penalties, one of which was withholding of an increment, and recurrence of similar misconduct after those penalties.
¶ 10, 11The Court reasoned that repeated misconduct despite prior disciplinary action removed the premise of the petitioner's argument that a minor penalty should have been imposed first. On that basis, the authorities he relied on were held distinguishable on their facts.
¶ 11The Court did not separately analyse whether the punishment shocked its conscience. Its treatment of proportionality largely rests on the respondents' submissions, which the order reproduces nearly verbatim.
¶ 6–8, 1005Holding
No case for interference under Article 226 was made out, since the inquiry was conducted in accordance with natural justice and Police Regulation 226, and the penalty was not disproportionate in light of the charges and the petitioner's repeated misconduct.
¶ 10, 11The writ petition is dismissed as being without merit, and the order of termination dated 27.09.1997, the appellate order dated 14.12.2006, and the mercy-rejection order dated 29.05.2017 stand.
¶ 12, 13No reinstatement, back wages, or costs were granted.
¶ 13Original Court PDF
Vashist KumarvsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
