01Facts
The petitioner, a Self Help Group, was entrusted by order dated 29.10.2009 with providing meals under the Sanjha Chulha Scheme at four Anganwadi Centres: three at village Karahi and one at village Dudhapura.
p. 1Within a few days of commencing work, the respondents cancelled the allotment by order dated 09.11.2009 (Annexure P/1).
p. 1The petitioner alleged that this was done without proper opportunity of hearing and that the order was non-speaking, recording no specific reasons for cancellation.
pp. 1–2The State contended that complaints of irregularities in meal distribution were received, including a complaint with a Panchnama submitted by the local MLA.
p. 2The State further stated that a show-cause notice dated 07.11.2009 was issued, to which the petitioner did not reply, and the agreement was then cancelled.
p. 2The impugned order merely refers to complaints by villagers and discloses no specific irregularity or finding.
p. 2The material on record did not establish that an effective opportunity of hearing was afforded before the adverse action.
p. 202Issues
i.1. Whether the impugned cancellation order dated 09.11.2009, which refers only to villagers' complaints without stating specific reasons or findings, is sustainable as a reasoned order.
pp. 2–3ii.2. Whether the cancellation of the allotment without an effective and meaningful opportunity of hearing, and despite the issuance of a show-cause notice, violates the principles of natural justice.
pp. 2–303Law Applied
The court proceeded under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
p. 1An administrative or quasi-judicial order having civil consequences must be supported by reasons and passed in compliance with natural justice.
p. 3M/s. Kranti Associates Pvt. Ltd. Anr. v. Masood Ahmed Khan Ors., (2010) 9 SCC 496, holds that recording reasons is an essential requirement of decision-making that ensures fairness, prevents arbitrariness and facilitates judicial review, and that reasons must be cogent, clear and succinct.
p. 3Issuance of a show-cause notice does not, by itself, dispense with the requirement of a reasoned order passed after due consideration.
p. 3No specific statute or scheme guideline governing the Sanjha Chulha Scheme is cited in the judgment.
04Reasoning
The court began from the undisputed facts: the allotment order of 29.10.2009 and its cancellation on 09.11.2009.
p. 2Although the State justified the cancellation by reference to complaints and a Panchnama, the court found that the impugned order itself identified no specific irregularity, finding or reason and merely recited villagers' complaints.
p. 2Applying Kranti Associates, the court held that the absence of reasons deprived the order of the fairness and reviewability that Kranti requires.
p. 3The court found that the record did not show an effective hearing before adverse action.
p. 2The State's reliance on the show-cause notice did not cure the defect, because a notice does not replace the duty to give a reasoned decision after considering the matter.
p. 3The order was therefore non-speaking and passed without an effective opportunity of hearing.
p. 3The court expressly declined to examine the merits of the allegations.
p. 405Holding
The impugned order dated 09.11.2009 is non-speaking and was passed without ensuring an effective opportunity of hearing, and therefore cannot be sustained.
p. 3The petition was allowed and Annexure P/1 quashed. The matter was remitted to the competent authority to decide afresh in accordance with law. Before deciding, the authority must furnish the petitioner with particulars of the allegations and afford an effective hearing. It must then pass a reasoned and speaking order after considering the petitioner's explanation, within 60 days of receipt of a certified copy of the order. The court made clear that it has expressed no opinion on the merits of the allegations and that the authority must take an independent decision.
pp. 3–4Original Court PDF
Maa Imli Wali Self Help Group,KarahivsState Of M.P.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
