Madhya Pradesh High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Disciplinary and appellate penalty orders are quasi-judicial and must be speaking; non-speaking orders are unsustainable.

Jeevan Mala Ramtekev.The State Of Madhya Pradesh

Disciplinary and appellate penalty orders are quasi-judicial and must be speaking; non-speaking orders are unsustainable.. Jeevan Mala Ramteke vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh. Madhya Pradesh High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the punishment order dated 20.12.2007 of the disciplinary authority is sustainable in law when it contains no reasons and does not consider the petitioner's explanation and objections.

The court held

The Court answered both issues in the negative: the disciplinary order (20.12.2007) and the appellate order (26.09.2008) are non-speaking, unreasoned, and unsustainable in law.

It also directed

Both orders are set aside. The respondents must extend all consequential benefits within three months of receiving a certified copy of the order, failing which they must pay interest at 6% per annum from the date of the petitioner's retirement (30.11.2024) until actual payment. No liberty is granted to the respondents to initiate further disciplinary action in respect of the same matter, given the petitioner's retirement. The writ petition is disposed of.

01Facts

The petitioner was posted as Assistant Grade-II in the office of respondent No. 5. A charge-sheet dated 16.01.2003 alleged four charges relating to illegal appointments and regularisation of employees during the tenure of the then Assistant Commissioner, S.K. Sharma.

p. 2 / para. 2

The petitioner denied the charges. The disciplinary authority rejected his reply, and a regular departmental enquiry followed.

p. 2 / para. 2

After the enquiry report was supplied, the petitioner submitted an explanation dated 10.10.2006 raising objections and seeking documents, which were not supplied.

p. 2 / para. 2

By order dated 20.12.2007, the disciplinary authority imposed the penalty of reduction to the minimum of the time scale under Rule 10(1)(ii) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1966 (described as "reduction to a lower time scale"), with withholding of five annual increments with cumulative effect.

pp. 2–3 / para. 2 · p. 4 / para. 5

The disciplinary order records only that the explanation was examined and "not found satisfactory".

p. 4 / para. 5

The petitioner's appeal was partly allowed by the appellate order dated 26.09.2008: the withholding of increments was set aside, and the reduction in time scale was upheld.

pp. 4–5 / para. 7

The respondents conceded before the Court that, while concurring with the disciplinary authority's findings, no reasoning was assigned.

pp. 3–4 / para. 3

The petitioner retired on 30.11.2024.

p. 7 / para. 13

The Court notes the disciplinary order as "20.12.2017" at one point, but the order is dated 20.12.2007.

p. 4 / para. 6

02Issues

i.1. Whether the punishment order dated 20.12.2007 of the disciplinary authority is sustainable in law when it contains no reasons and does not consider the petitioner's explanation and objections.

p. 4 / para. 6 · p. 5 / para. 9

ii.2. Whether the appellate order dated 26.09.2008, which upheld the penalty without independent reasons, is sustainable in law.

p. 5 / para. 8 · p. 5 / para. 9

03Law Applied

The Court treated the disciplinary and appellate authorities as exercising quasi-judicial powers, so their orders must be speaking orders that apply the mind to all facts and record valid and justifiable reasons.

p. 4 / para. 6 · p. 5 / para. 8

The Court relied on the settled principle that discretionary power must be exercised with due diligence and in a reasonable and rational manner, and that the affected party must know how its case or defence was considered.

p. 5 / para. 9

The Court applied State of Punjab v. Bandip Singh (2016) 1 SCC 724, which requires an administrative or executive decision to be composite and self-sustaining, containing all reasons that led to the conclusion, and holds that a decision must be "informed and impregnated with reasons" and not capricious, arbitrary, or prejudiced.

pp. 5–6 / paras. 10–11

The Court relied on Kranti Associates Pvt. Ltd. v. Masood Ahmed Khan (2010) 9 SCC 496, which holds that an order affecting rights must speak and "must not be like the inscrutable face of a sphinx".

p. 6 / para. 12

Reasons are an indispensable component of decision-making, forming part of the doctrine of fairness and human rights.

pp. 6–7 / para. 12

04Reasoning

The Court did not examine the merits of the charges. It tested the two impugned orders only on their face.

p. 4 / para. 5 · p. 2 / para. 2

The disciplinary order disposed of the petitioner's detailed explanation by a single statement that it was not satisfactory, with no discussion of the objections or the request for documents. Applying Kranti Associates and Bandip Singh, the Court held that such an order does not show that the relevant factors were considered, and so it is not a speaking order.

p. 4 / para. 5 · p. 2 / para. 2 · p. 4 / para. 6

The appellate order fared no better. It affirmed the penalty on the basis of the disciplinary order and the Collector's reasoning, without its own analysis of the grounds of appeal.

pp. 4–5 / para. 7 · p. 5 / para. 8

The respondents' concession that no reasoning was given on concurrence reinforced the finding that the appellate authority had not applied its own mind.

pp. 3–4 / para. 3

Because both orders failed the reasoned-decision requirement, the Court did not need to decide the substantive challenge to the charges.

05Holding

The Court answered both issues in the negative: the disciplinary order (20.12.2007) and the appellate order (26.09.2008) are non-speaking, unreasoned, and unsustainable in law.

pp. 4–5 / paras. 6, 8, 9

Both orders are set aside. The respondents must extend all consequential benefits within three months of receiving a certified copy of the order, failing which they must pay interest at 6% per annum from the date of the petitioner's retirement (30.11.2024) until actual payment. No liberty is granted to the respondents to initiate further disciplinary action in respect of the same matter, given the petitioner's retirement. The writ petition is disposed of.

p. 7 / para. 13 · p. 8 / para. 14
Madhya Pradesh High Court

Original Court PDF

Jeevan Mala RamtekevsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh

Madhya Pradesh High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment