01Facts
The petitioners are accused in the Bhopal Gas Tragedy prosecution arising from the escape of MIC gas from Union Carbide India Ltd.'s plant.
Charges were initially framed under Section 304(II) IPC, then, following the Supreme Court's order of 13.09.1996, under Section 304-A IPC on 29.08.1997.
¶ 3After a trial in which 178 witnesses were examined and about 3,000 documents exhibited, the Chief Judicial Magistrate convicted the petitioners on 07.06.2010.
¶ 4Their appeals (Criminal Appeal Nos. 364-366/2010) are pending before the Sessions Court, Bhopal.
¶ 4On 25.04.2022, the petitioners filed applications under Section 464 CrPC alleging that the charges were vague, general and defective, causing failure of justice; the CBI and other assisting parties opposed them.
¶ 5After several changes of Presiding Officer and about 36 days of hearing, the Sessions Court by order dated 28.11.2025 declined to decide the applications independently and held that they must be considered along with the final hearing of the appeals.
¶ 6 · ¶ 11The petitioners challenged that order under Section 482 CrPC, seeking a direction for merits adjudication before the appeal is heard.
¶ 2 · ¶ 1302Issues
i.1. Whether an application under Section 464 CrPC, filed during the pendency of a criminal appeal, must be adjudicated independently and before commencement of the final hearing of the appeal.
¶ 16ii.2. Whether the appellate court may consider objections regarding omission, error or irregularity in the charge while deciding the appeal itself.
¶ 1603Law Applied
The Court applied Section 464(1) and (2) CrPC, which provide that no conviction is invalid merely for a defect in the charge unless the appellate court finds a failure of justice in fact, and that the proviso requires conviction to be quashed where no valid charge could be framed on the proved facts.
¶ 17Following State of Andhra Pradesh v. Thakkidiram Reddy, (1998) 6 SCC 554, the controlling test is actual failure of justice, assessed with a broad vision as to whether the accused had a fair trial and knew the case against him, drawing on Willie (William) Slaney v. State of M.P., AIR 1956 SC 116.
¶ 21Kamil v. State of U.P. (Cr. A. No. 1568/2015, decided 31.10.2018) holds that absence of charge does not vitiate conviction absent proved prejudice.
¶ 22Kalicharan v. State of U.P., (2023) 2 SCC 583, is read as recognising appellate jurisdiction to grant Section 464 relief but not as laying down an inflexible rule that such applications must be decided separately.
¶ 23Asim @ Munmun v. State of Gujarat (Cr. A. No. 184/2020, decided 28.01.2020), which favoured immediate hearing of Section 391 CrPC applications, is distinguishable because Section 464 requires assessment of prejudice on the evidence.
¶ 24Section 313 CrPC examinations are relevant to the failure-of-justice inquiry.
¶ 14Provisions in the judgment · 9 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482Section 464Section 391Section 313Section 465
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 304Section 148Section 302Section 149
04Reasoning
Section 464 neither mandates separate, prior adjudication nor prohibits it, so no absolute right to a preliminary decision exists.
¶ 19 · ¶ 30The inquiry under Section 464 requires examining the evidence, the defence taken and the trial findings, which substantially overlap with the appeal.
¶ 20 · ¶ 27The petitioners' grounds, namely that the charges were defective and that the trial court considered extraneous matters, are intertwined with the appeal grounds and the trial record.
¶ 33The 36-day hearing and the risk of transfer or elevation of the Presiding Officer do not compel separate adjudication, since these are case-management factors and do not create a statutory right.
¶ 25 · ¶ 28The charge issue had already reached the Supreme Court and repeated reopening could delay disposal.
¶ 34Separate adjudication may be appropriate in narrow cases with demonstrable defects, and the Court set out six discretionary factors for the appellate court.
¶ 29 · ¶ 31 · ¶ 3205Holding
The petitioners have no legal right to an independent, preliminary adjudication of their Section 464 CrPC applications before the final hearing of the appeals.
¶ 36The impugned order does not warrant interference under Section 482 CrPC, and the petitions were dismissed.
¶ 36The Sessions Court is directed to decide the criminal appeals expeditiously, preferably within 30 days of receiving the order, and to consider all Section 464 grounds on their merits in light of the record while deciding the appeals, avoiding unnecessary adjournments.
¶ 37The Registry is directed to communicate the order to the appellate court. The Court has not examined the merits of the charges, prejudice, or the conviction.
¶ 35 · ¶ 38Original Court PDF
Kishor S KamdarvsUnion Of India
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
