01Facts
The petitioner sought a writ of mandamus or certiorari under Article 226 directing Respondent No. 1, Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd., to de-freeze his bank account bearing No. 9148642691.
¶ 1Counsel for the petitioner contended that the case was squarely covered by Malcolm Murayis & Ors. v. State Bank of India & Others, W.P. No. 1100 of 2024 (decided 26.04.2024).
¶ 2In Malcolm Murayis, accounts were frozen on requests from police cyber cells alleging cyber fraud. The court there disposed of the petitions by directing that the disputed amounts be kept in fixed deposits, liquidable only on a Magistrate's order within three months, and permitted limited monthly withdrawals pending the hearing.
Malcolm Murayis · ¶ 3, 7, 9After that judgment, the Ministry of Home Affairs issued a Standard Operating Procedure dated 10.04.2026 (SOP) governing grievance redressal for accounts held through the NCRP-CFCFRMS, and the Principal Seat at Jabalpur dealt with the SOP in Archana v. State of Madhya Pradesh (order dated 27.07.2026).
¶ 4The present order does not record the specific freezing particulars of the petitioner's account beyond the disputed entries, which the court later identified as two entries of Rs. 12,000 each.
¶ 602Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner's case is covered by the principles laid down in Malcolm Murayis and Archana, such that the same relief may be granted mutatis mutandis.
¶ 2 · ¶ 5ii.2. Whether the disputed amount may be secured through fixed deposit while the remaining balance of a frozen account is released, consistent with proportionality and the SOP dated 10.04.2026.
¶ 4 · ¶ 603Law Applied
The court relied on Article 226 of the Constitution as the basis for writ jurisdiction.
¶ 1The court applied the principles in Malcolm Murayis v. State Bank of India, W.P. No. 1100 of 2024, under which the disputed amount is retained in fixed deposits and released only upon a Magistrate's order within three months, failing which the petitioner may withdraw it.
Malcolm Murayis · ¶ 9The court relied on Archana v. State of Madhya Pradesh (27.07.2026), which holds that police powers to freeze accounts must be exercised reasonably and proportionately, that a lien or debit freeze limited to the suspected amount is preferred over freezing an entire account, that the Investigating Officer must inform the Magistrate of any freezing, and that grievance timelines under the MHA SOP dated 10.04.2026 apply.
Archana · ¶ 12–17, guidelines I–XVIIIArchana recognises the balance to be struck between Article 19(1)(g) and Article 300-A and statutory investigative powers, and the Bank's role as first point of contact.
Archana · ¶ 12, 14The Magistrate-intimation requirement derives from Section 102 of the Cr.P.C., and the BNSS is referenced as the operative procedural framework.
Malcolm Murayis · ¶ 4 · ¶ 6Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 102
04Reasoning
The court held that Malcolm Murayis and Archana apply mutatis mutandis to the present petition.
¶ 5Applying the Archana guidelines, which require that only the disputed amount be secured where it is clearly identifiable, the court directed that the two disputed entries of Rs. 12,000 be kept in fixed deposit.
¶ 6This reflects the proportionality principle: a negligible suspicious sum does not justify freezing the entire account.
Archana · ¶ 13Because the disputed sum was secured, the court held that the balance account could be unfrozen and the petitioner permitted to operate it.
¶ 6The court preserved the Bank's ability to act on any further complaint regarding other entries, provided it follows the SOP and Archana guidelines.
¶ 6The order also ties liquidation of the fixed deposit to a Magistrate's order within three months, so that the investigating agency must proceed under the BNSS, failing which the petitioner may withdraw the amount.
¶ 6 · Malcolm Murayis · ¶ 9The judgment does not separately examine the petitioner's business, source of funds or grievance history; its reasoning rests on the adoption of the precedents.
05Holding
The court held that the principles in Malcolm Murayis and Archana apply to the present case.
¶ 5The court directed that the disputed amount of Rs. 12,000 (two entries) be kept in fixed deposit, to be liquidated only upon a competent Judicial Magistrate's order within three months, failing which the petitioner may withdraw it on intimation to the police agency, and further directed that the petitioner's bank account be unfrozen and that the petitioner be permitted to operate it, with any future complaints about other entries to be addressed by the Bank in accordance with law and the SOP.
¶ 6The writ petition was disposed of accordingly.
¶ 7Original Court PDF
Pappu JadhavvsKotak Mahindra Bank Ltd.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
