01Facts
The petitioner sought a writ of mandamus or certiorari under Article 226 directing the first respondent bank to de-freeze his account bearing No. 201007291686.
¶ 1Counsel contended that the case was squarely covered by Malcolm Murayis and Ors. v. State Bank of India (W.P. No. 1100 of 2024, decided 26.04.2024).
¶ 2In Malcolm Murayis, the court had considered accounts frozen on instructions from cyber cell police stations, with the disputed amounts identified, and had directed that the disputed sums be kept in fixed deposits, liquidable only after a Judicial Magistrate's order within three months, failing which the petitioners could withdraw them.
¶ 3 (quoting Malcolm Murayis · ¶ 3–9) (pp. 1–3)The court further noted that the Ministry of Home Affairs issued an SOP dated 10.04.2026 governing grievance redressal for accounts held through the NCRP-CFCFRMS, and that the co-ordinate Bench in Archana v. State of Madhya Pradesh (order dated 27.07.2026) had framed detailed guidelines under that SOP.
¶ 4 (pp. 3–7)02Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner's entire bank account, frozen on police instructions in a cyber fraud matter, should be de-frozen in light of the Malcolm Murayis and Archana decisions.
¶ 2, 5 (pp. 1, 8)ii.2. Whether the disputed amount should be retained in a fixed deposit, with the balance released, pending the investigating agency's action under the BNSS.
¶ 6 (p. 8)03Law Applied
The court relied on the precedent in Malcolm Murayis (W.P. No. 1100 of 2024), which held that disputed amounts identified by investigating agencies may be retained in fixed deposits, liquidable only on a Magistrate's order within three months, failing which the account holder may withdraw them.
¶ 3 (Malcolm Murayis · ¶ 9)The court also applied Archana (order dated 27.07.2026), which holds that police powers to freeze bank accounts must be exercised reasonably and proportionately under Articles 19(1)(g) and 300-A, so that only the suspected proceeds of crime are restrained, with entire-account freezes permitted only in exceptional cases for recorded reasons.
¶ 4 (Archana · ¶ 12–13, 15(I))Archana requires investigating officers to inform the Magistrate of freezing "forthwith", requires banks to act as first point of contact and to process grievances under the SOP's timelines, and provides that writ petitions for de-freezing ordinarily lie only after the SOP's 90-day period expires, subject to exceptional circumstances.
¶ 4 (Archana · ¶ 14, 15(II), 17, 15(XVIII))The court's own order also relied on the principle that the SOP timelines are outer limits, not ordinary periods.
¶ 4 (Archana · ¶ 17)Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 102
04Reasoning
Counsel's submission that the petitioner's case is covered by Malcolm Murayis was accepted. The petitioner's challenge concerns the freezing of an entire account in a matter where, as in Malcolm Murayis, the disputed amount is a small sum relative to the account balance. Applying Archana's proportionality framework, the court held that a freeze of the entire account is not warranted where the disputed amount can be secured by a fixed deposit. The court therefore applied the Malcolm Murayis mechanism mutatis mutandis.
¶ 2, 5–6 (p. 8)The court fixed the disputed amount stated in the petition at Rs. 2,000 and directed that it be kept in an FD. The court left room for the bank to act on any other complaint in accordance with law and the SOP. The order does not separately discuss whether the writ was maintainable before the SOP's 90-day period expired, nor does it record any exceptional circumstance justifying early intervention. The decision therefore proceeds on the substantive proportionality principle rather than on maintainability.
¶ 6 (p. 8) · no citation05Holding
The court held that the Malcolm Murayis and Archana decisions apply mutatis mutandis to the present case.
¶ 5The writ petition is disposed of with the following directions: (i) the disputed amount of Rs. 2,000 is to be kept in a fixed deposit; (ii) the FD may be liquidated only after a competent Judicial Magistrate passes orders within three months, as the police are expected to proceed under the relevant BNSS provisions, failing which the petitioner may withdraw the amount under intimation to the police agency; and (iii) the petitioner's bank account is to be unfrozen and the petitioner permitted to operate it. The petition stands disposed of.
¶ 6–7Original Court PDF
BarunvsIndusind Bank Ltd
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
