Madhya Pradesh High CourtEmployment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

Treating an employee differently from juniors regularized from initial appointment date requires cogent reasons.

Chandra Shekhar Shrivastavav.The State Of Madhya Pradesh

Treating an employee differently from juniors regularized from initial appointment date requires cogent reasons.. Chandra Shekhar Shrivastava vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh. Madhya Pradesh High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to regularization of his services from the date of his initial appointment in 1990, rather than from 2005/2006, when his junior employees, appointed later, were regularized from their initial dates of appointment.

The court held

The court did not finally answer whether the petitioner is entitled to regularization from 1990. It held that the respondents must consider his representation and Annexure P-3 and pass a reasoned order.

It also directed

Any refusal must give cogent reasons for differential treatment from juniors. The respondents were directed to complete this exercise within 60 days from receipt of a certified copy of the order, and the petition was disposed of with these observations.

The prayers for arrears with 18% interest and for costs were not separately adjudicated.

01Facts

The petitioner, a person with more than 40% disability, was appointed as a daily-wager under work-charge contingency on 13.04.1990.

¶ 3

Junior employees were regularized in 1999, but the petitioner was not given the same benefit.

¶ 3 · Annexure P/3

The petitioner approached the High Court through W.P. No. 1249/1999, W.P. No. 2783/2004, Contempt Petition No. 191/2005 and W.P. No. 3841/2008 to enforce his claim.

¶ 3

The Selection Committee resolved on 10.05.2006 to regularize his services as Safai Daroga against a vacant post.

¶ 3 · Annexure P/7

He was later promoted as Health Inspector on 12.07.2019 and as Chief Health Inspector on 15.07.2026.

¶ 4 · Annexure P/8 · Annexure P/9

His services were regularized only from 01.01.2005.

¶ 4

Annexure P-3 (dated 31.07.2001) shows that persons appointed after him were regularized from their initial dates of appointment.

¶ 5-6

The petitioner filed a representation dated 02.11.2026 (Annexure P-1), which the respondents acknowledged but had not decided.

¶ 6

02Issues

i.1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to regularization of his services from the date of his initial appointment in 1990, rather than from 2005/2006, when his junior employees, appointed later, were regularized from their initial dates of appointment.

¶ 5-6, 8

ii.2. Whether the respondents must consider the petitioner's pending representation and, if they decline the same benefit, must give cogent reasons for treating his case differently from that of his juniors.

¶ 7, 9

03Law Applied

The court exercised its writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

¶ 2

The executive must consider a pending representation and decide it by a reasoned order.

¶ 7

An authority treating a litigant differently from similarly situated juniors must assign cogent reasons for the differential treatment.

¶ 9

The petitioner's earlier writs and contempt proceedings (W.P. No. 1249/1999, W.P. No. 2783/2004 decided 03.11.2004, Contempt Petition No. 191/2005, W.P. No. 3841/2008) form the procedural background.

¶ 3

No binding precedent on regularization from the initial date of appointment is cited.

04Reasoning

The court did not adjudicate the merits of the petitioner's claim. It noted that the petitioner had already sought redress through a representation dated 02.11.2026.

¶ 6

The court directed the respondents to consider that representation and decide whether the petitioner should be regularized from his initial date of appointment, as had been done for junior employees appointed after him.

¶ 7

Annexure P-3 was identified as the key document for that consideration, since it showed juniors regularized from their initial dates of appointment.

¶ 8

The court left open the possibility of refusal. If the respondents found a legal impediment, they were required to state cogent reasons for denying the benefit and for treating the petitioner differently from his juniors.

¶ 9

The court's reasoning focused on procedural fairness and reasoned decision-making rather than on the substantive entitlement.

05Holding

The court did not finally answer whether the petitioner is entitled to regularization from 1990. It held that the respondents must consider his representation and Annexure P-3 and pass a reasoned order.

¶ 7-8

Any refusal must give cogent reasons for differential treatment from juniors. The respondents were directed to complete this exercise within 60 days from receipt of a certified copy of the order, and the petition was disposed of with these observations.

¶ 9-11

The prayers for arrears with 18% interest and for costs were not separately adjudicated.

Madhya Pradesh High Court

Original Court PDF

Chandra Shekhar ShrivastavavsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh

Madhya Pradesh High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment