Bombay High CourtIntellectual Property LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Bombay HC Rejects Mafatlal Grandson's Trademark Challenge As Time-Barred, But Starts Suo Motu Action Over Dead Applicant's Registration

Varun Atulya Mafatlalv.Shree Vallabh Chandak

Bombay HC Rejects Mafatlal Grandson's Trademark Challenge As Time-Barred, But Starts Suo Motu Action Over Dead Applicant's Registration. Varun Atulya Mafatlal vs Shree Vallabh Chandak. Bombay High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether Varun is a "person aggrieved" under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.

The court held

The Court held that Varun is a "person aggrieved"

It also directed

However, the petition is barred by limitation. Varun cannot restart the period through Atulya's inaction, and the Condonation IA fails because sufficient cause under Section 5 is not made out

The Court held that the integrity of the Register is suspect and initiated suo motu rectification under Section 57(4), including consideration of deleting Madhuri's name

Notice was directed to Chandak, Malavika and the estate of Madhuri (through the executors), to show cause by January 15, 2027, why the registration should not be cancelled, why its statutory effect should not be stayed, and how the Class 25 Mark could vest in Ajay and Malavika

The Court did not decide the validity of the Wills under the Succession Act

The Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks was directed to have an independent senior officer examine the Registry's files and file an affidavit, including statistics on registrations granted in the names of deceased persons over ten years, by January 15, 2027

The suo motu petition is listed for directions on January 20, 2027

Varun's interim injunction was not granted, and the stay question is reserved for the Noticees' response

01Facts

Madhuri Mafatlal applied to register the device marks "SUNGRACE MAFATLAL" in Class 24 (January 7, 2011) and Class 25 (July 19, 2011)

¶ 2(A) · p. 2

Madhuri died on July 15, 2013 and left a purported will dated February 6, 2012 ("Madhuri Will")

¶ 2(C) · p. 3

Her son Ajay died on August 22, 2015, leaving a purported will dated August 5, 2013 ("Ajay Will")

¶ 2(C) · p. 3

Neither will has been probated

¶ 2(C) · p. 3 · ¶ 57 · p. 42

Madhuri's other son, Atulya, died in September 2022

¶ 2(C) · p. 3

The petitioner, Varun, is Atulya's son

¶ 2(D) · p. 3

On December 11, 2015, Malavika filed two Form TM-16 applications ("2015 Applications") seeking to be recorded as successor. She produced the Madhuri Will and a Gayatri Undertaking, but not the Ajay Will

¶ 2(E) · pp. 3–4

The 2015 Applications remain undecided

¶ 2(F) · p. 4

Suit No. 685 of 2016, concerning Ajay's estate, is pending before this Court and does not mention the Marks

¶ 2(G) · p. 4 · ¶ 17 · p. 17

The Registrar advertised the applications in December 2016 and March 2017

¶ 35 · p. 30

Registration certificates issued in Madhuri's name on May 5, 2017 (Class 24) and August 4, 2017 (Class 25)

¶ 2(H) · p. 4

On May 11, 2018, Malavika filed Form TM-P, producing a photocopy of the Ajay Will

¶ 2(I) · pp. 4–5

The Registrar recorded Malavika as subsequent proprietor on July 5, 2018, without notice to relatives

¶ 2(J) · p. 5

Malavika assigned the Marks to Chandak on July 6, 2018 for Rs. 9,00,000 per mark

¶ 2(J) · p. 5

The Registrar recorded Chandak as proprietor on September 17, 2018

¶ 2(K) · p. 5

The Marks were renewed in Chandak's name in 2020 after advertisement

¶ 36 · p. 31

Mafatlal Industries (the Arvind Mafatlal branch) issued a legal notice to Chandak in February 2015 regarding use of the Marks

¶ 18 · p. 17 · ¶ 34 · pp. 29–30

Varun says he learnt of Chandak's registration in August 2023, filed the petition on December 13, 2023, and filed the Condonation IA on July 2, 2025 seeking condonation of 557 days' delay

¶ 2(L) · pp. 5–6 · ¶ 1 · p. 2

Varun seeks expungement of the entries in favour of Malavika and Chandak, restoration of Madhuri's name, and an interim injunction

¶ 4–5 · pp. 6–7

The Registrar did not appear or file pleadings

¶ 3 · p. 6

02Issues

i.1. Whether Varun is a "person aggrieved" under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.

¶ 11–14 · pp. 13–15 · ¶ 59(A) · pp. 42–43

ii.2. Whether the petition is barred by limitation and whether the delay can be condoned under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, given Atulya's inaction, the alleged fraud and concealment, and Section 17 of the Limitation Act.

¶ 15–38 · pp. 15–32 · ¶ 59(B)–(C) · pp. 43–45

iii.3. Whether the entries of May/August 2017 (Madhuri), July 5, 2018 (Malavika) and September 17, 2018 (Chandak) were made without due process and affect the integrity of the Register.

¶ 41–57 · pp. 33–42 · ¶ 59(D)–(E) · pp. 45–46

iv.4. Whether a case is made out for the Court to initiate suo motu rectification under Section 57(4) of the Trade Marks Act.

¶ 59(E) · p. 46 · ¶ 60–67 · pp. 46–49

03Law Applied

The Court applied Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, which permits any "person aggrieved" to seek rectification and empowers the High Court to act suo motu under Section 57(4) after notice and hearing

¶ 9–10 · pp. 12–13

"Person aggrieved" is to be construed liberally, with locus assessed under Hardie Trading, Infosys, V.R. Holdings and Toshiba

¶ 12–13 · pp. 14–15

Under the Limitation Act, 1963, an "applicant" includes a person through whom the applicant derives the right to apply (Section 2(a)(ii))

¶ 23 · p. 20

Section 3 bars applications after the prescribed period, and Section 5 permits condonation on sufficient cause

¶ 25–26 · pp. 21–25

Article 137 of the Schedule prescribes three years from accrual of the right to apply

¶ 38 · p. 32

Section 9 provides that once time has begun to run, no subsequent disability stops it

¶ 26 · p. 25

Section 16 defers time only where the right accrues on death, and Section 17 postpones time for fraud or concealment only where the applicant could not, with reasonable diligence, have discovered it

¶ 27–28 · pp. 25–26 · ¶ 33 · pp. 28–29

On the substantive side, Rule 61 of the Trade Marks Rules, 2002 and Rule 55 of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017 require the Registrar, on proof of an applicant's death and of transmission of interest, to substitute the successor in interest before the application proceeds

¶ 43–46 · pp. 34–36

Section 45 of the Act and Rule 77 empower the Registrar to seek further proof where reasonable doubt arises

¶ 50 · p. 38 · ¶ 54 · pp. 40–41

The Court also relied on the principle that the integrity of the Register is paramount

¶ 41 · p. 33 · ¶ 53 · pp. 39–40

The Succession Act, 1925, including Section 213, was noted but expressly not decided

¶ 62 · p. 47

04Reasoning

The Court held that Varun has locus as a member of the Mafatlal family whose name the Marks bear, and that the "person aggrieved" question should not be decided against him at the threshold

¶ 14 · p. 15

On limitation, the Court held that Varun derives his right only through Atulya and cannot start a fresh limitation period on his own discovery in 2023

¶ 30–31 · pp. 27–28

Atulya was alive when the entries of July and September 2018 were made in a public register open to search, and he took no step

¶ 59(C) · pp. 43–44

Section 16 did not help because time had already run before Atulya's death in 2022

¶ 59(C) · p. 44

The Court treated Atulya as having constructive notice of the register. It relied on the sibling litigation, the Registrar's advertisements in 2016–2017 and 2020, and the Mafatlal Industries notice of 2015

¶ 22 · pp. 19–20 · ¶ 34–36 · pp. 29–31

The Court found Section 17 inapplicable because Atulya could, with reasonable diligence, have discovered the entries

¶ 33 · pp. 28–29 · ¶ 37 · pp. 31–32

Varun's claim could not "ever-green" limitation across generations

¶ 33 · p. 29

On the merits of the Register, the Court found that an application made by a natural person in 2011 was granted in 2017 in the name of a person known to be dead since 2013, and that the 2015 Applications were never adjudicated

¶ 42–46 · pp. 33–36 · ¶ 51–52 · pp. 38–39

The Registrar did not substitute the successor under Rule 55/Rule 61 and did not seek proof of succession, despite the Gayatri Undertaking's blank-dated reference to the Ajay Will and the fact that Gayatri is an executor

¶ 50 · p. 38 · ¶ 54–55 · pp. 40–41

The Madhuri Will does not refer to the Class 25 Mark

¶ 56 · pp. 41–42

This led the Court to find the registration in Madhuri's name "suspect" and the Register's integrity in doubt

¶ 59(D) · p. 45

Because the power under Section 57(4) exists to protect the Register, the Court held that it could act suo motu even though Varun's petition failed

¶ 53 · pp. 39–40 · ¶ 58 · p. 42

05Holding

The Court held that Varun is a "person aggrieved"

¶ 59(A) · pp. 42–43

However, the petition is barred by limitation. Varun cannot restart the period through Atulya's inaction, and the Condonation IA fails because sufficient cause under Section 5 is not made out

¶ 59(C) · pp. 43–45 · ¶ 66 · p. 48

The Court held that the integrity of the Register is suspect and initiated suo motu rectification under Section 57(4), including consideration of deleting Madhuri's name

¶ 59(D)–(E) · pp. 45–46 · ¶ 67 · p. 49

Notice was directed to Chandak, Malavika and the estate of Madhuri (through the executors), to show cause by January 15, 2027, why the registration should not be cancelled, why its statutory effect should not be stayed, and how the Class 25 Mark could vest in Ajay and Malavika

¶ 60–63 · pp. 46–47

The Court did not decide the validity of the Wills under the Succession Act

¶ 62 · p. 47

The Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks was directed to have an independent senior officer examine the Registry's files and file an affidavit, including statistics on registrations granted in the names of deceased persons over ten years, by January 15, 2027

¶ 64–65 · pp. 48–49

The suo motu petition is listed for directions on January 20, 2027

¶ 67 · p. 49

Varun's interim injunction was not granted, and the stay question is reserved for the Noticees' response

¶ 61 · p. 47
Bombay High Court

Original Court PDF

Varun Atulya MafatlalvsShree Vallabh Chandak

Bombay High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment