01Facts
The Petitioner, an Indian software vendor, and Respondent No. 1, a Turkish company, entered into a Software Development Agreement dated 14 December 2022 for the Mumbai Metro Line-3 AFC Project.
Clause 3 provided "Back-to-Back as per project milestone and receipt of payment as per agreement between Texmaco & ASIS".
¶ 20Clauses 4 and 5 contained similar back-to-back payment terms.
¶ 21Clause 10 provided for amicable settlement followed by ICC arbitration seated in India.
¶ 3, 14On 19 July 2024, Respondent No. 1 emailed that it would complete the project alone and that its decision was "final and irrevocable".
¶ 23Meetings were held in Istanbul on 8–9 August 2024, and Minutes of Meeting dated 9 August 2024 (Exhibit-J) recorded that Respondent No. 1 "will pay USD 700,000" for development work done, while the Petitioner would keep its team on site till 31 December 2024.
¶ 25–26The Petitioner says it performed; Respondent No. 1 denies full performance but identified no specific omitted work.
¶ 38Respondent No. 1 disputes the signature of Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel, questions his authority, and alleges the document is unstamped.
¶ 12, 28Payment was not made. Email exchanges between 2024 and 2025 show the matter remained under discussion.
¶ 39–44The Petitioner issued a legal notice on 17 February 2026 alleging transfer of about USD 1,000,000 from Respondent No. 1's Bhopal office, and invoked arbitration on 15 September 2026.
¶ 4–5, 45The Agra Metro contract (terminated) and the Bhopal-Indore contract (ended on national-security grounds) were affected in 2025.
¶ 46–47The Petitioner sought deposit or bank guarantee of USD 700,000, restraint on dealing with assets, disclosure of bank accounts, and disclosure by Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. (Respondent No. 4).
¶ 16, 5002Issues
i.1. Whether the Petitioner has shown sufficient grounds under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 to direct Respondent No. 1 to deposit USD 700,000 or furnish a bank guarantee for that amount.
¶ 16–17, 51–52ii.2. Whether there is material justifying restraint on Respondent No. 1's dealing with its assets and bank accounts, and disclosure orders against Respondent No. 1 and Respondent No. 4.
¶ 16, 49–50, 58iii.3. Whether the back-to-back payment condition in the 2022 Agreement ceased upon termination on 19 July 2024, or was altered by the Minutes of 9 August 2024.
¶ 23–24, 25–32iv.4. Whether the Minutes of 9 August 2024 constitute an admission of an unconditional, immediately payable liability of USD 700,000.
¶ 34–36, 5403Law Applied
Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, under which interim protection is available pending arbitration, but the applicant must show necessity for protection to prevent an award becoming ineffective.
¶ 17, 56A Section 9 power is wide but is not a means to convert an ordinary disputed money claim into a secured claim; relief is granted only where a proper case, necessity, balance of convenience, and risk of serious irreparable loss are shown, though the technical requirements of attachment before judgment under the CPC need not be applied rigidly.
¶ 51A foreign incorporation or the loss of projects alone does not justify security absent conduct creating a real risk of award frustration.
¶ 47Clause 11.3 requires changes to be in writing and signed by authorised representatives of both parties, and Clause 11.1 makes the Agreement the entire agreement.
¶ 30, 32Tata Advanced Materials Ltd. v. Tooltech Global Engineering Pvt. Ltd., 2013 SCC OnLine Bom 1922 (Division Bench) held that a back-to-back condition backed by an unconditional undertaking and balance confirmations, with a 45-day fallback, did not allow a non-bona fide dispute to be raised; the Court followed it but distinguished it on those facts.
¶ 33–37The Respondent's Kompetenz-Kompetenz argument under Section 16 was noted, with the merits left to the Tribunal.
¶ 14, 57Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 9Section 16
04Reasoning
Termination by email did not automatically extinguish the back-to-back condition. Accrued rights survived, and whether the condition continued or was replaced depends on reading the Agreement with the Minutes.
¶ 24The Minutes record a payment obligation, but they contain no payment date, do not expressly remove Clause 3, and their signatory's authority is disputed.
¶ 25–31Unlike Tata, there is no unconditional undertaking, no balance confirmation, and no admission by an undisputed authorised officer, so the Division Bench's findings could not be applied.
¶ 35The later emails show that the parties treated USD 700,000 as part of a wider accounts reconciliation, and Respondent No. 1 did not unconditionally accept it.
¶ 41–44On the protective relief, the Court found that the Petitioner had a genuine claim but no material of asset dissipation, sham transactions, or intent to defeat an award. The legal notice's USD 1,000,000 transfer allegation was unsupported by any bank record.
¶ 45, 48, 54The Agra and Bhopal-Indore terminations did not establish insolvency or flight of assets.
¶ 47The Petitioner gave no convincing reason for waiting from 2025 until September 2026 to seek urgent relief, which weakened the claim of immediate danger.
¶ 53Respondent No. 4 was not shown to hold money belonging to Respondent No. 1, as its contract with the Joint Venture was separate and Texmaco's interests may be involved.
¶ 49The wide orders sought would effectively secure the whole claim, affecting working capital and banking limits.
¶ 50–51, 5505Holding
The Petitioner has a claim that can be pursued before the Arbitral Tribunal, but it has not shown the necessity required for interim protection under Section 9.
¶ 56Whether USD 700,000 is unconditionally payable, whether the Minutes bind Respondent No. 1 and are authorised, and the effect of Clause 3 are for the Tribunal.
¶ 34, 57The Petition was dismissed. The prayers for deposit of USD 700,000, bank guarantee, restraint on dealing with assets, disclosure of accounts and money sent abroad, and disclosure by Respondent No. 4 were refused. There was no order as to costs.
¶ 58–59Dismissal does not bar the Petitioner from pursuing its money claim in arbitration under Clause 10.
¶ 60–61Original Court PDF
Amay Technosystems Private LimitedvsAsis Elektronik Ve Biliim Sistemleri A
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
