Bombay High CourtArbitration and MediationContract Law

Bombay HC Refuses To Secure USD 700,000 Metro Claim Against Turkish Firm, Says Foreign Incorporation Alone Is No Ground

Amay Technosystems Private Limitedv.Asis Elektronik Ve Biliim Sistemleri A

Bombay HC Refuses To Secure USD 700,000 Metro Claim Against Turkish Firm, Says Foreign Incorporation Alone Is No Ground. Amay Technosystems Private Limited vs Asis Elektronik Ve Biliim Sistemleri A. Bombay High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Petitioner has shown sufficient grounds under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 to direct Respondent No. 1 to deposit USD 700,000 or furnish a bank guarantee for that amount.

The court held

The Petitioner has a claim that can be pursued before the Arbitral Tribunal, but it has not shown the necessity required for interim protection under Section 9.

It also directed

Whether USD 700,000 is unconditionally payable, whether the Minutes bind Respondent No. 1 and are authorised, and the effect of Clause 3 are for the Tribunal.

The Petition was dismissed. The prayers for deposit of USD 700,000, bank guarantee, restraint on dealing with assets, disclosure of accounts and money sent abroad, and disclosure by Respondent No. 4 were refused. There was no order as to costs.

Dismissal does not bar the Petitioner from pursuing its money claim in arbitration under Clause 10.

01Facts

The Petitioner, an Indian software vendor, and Respondent No. 1, a Turkish company, entered into a Software Development Agreement dated 14 December 2022 for the Mumbai Metro Line-3 AFC Project.

Clause 3 provided "Back-to-Back as per project milestone and receipt of payment as per agreement between Texmaco & ASIS".

¶ 20

Clauses 4 and 5 contained similar back-to-back payment terms.

¶ 21

Clause 10 provided for amicable settlement followed by ICC arbitration seated in India.

¶ 3, 14

On 19 July 2024, Respondent No. 1 emailed that it would complete the project alone and that its decision was "final and irrevocable".

¶ 23

Meetings were held in Istanbul on 8–9 August 2024, and Minutes of Meeting dated 9 August 2024 (Exhibit-J) recorded that Respondent No. 1 "will pay USD 700,000" for development work done, while the Petitioner would keep its team on site till 31 December 2024.

¶ 25–26

The Petitioner says it performed; Respondent No. 1 denies full performance but identified no specific omitted work.

¶ 38

Respondent No. 1 disputes the signature of Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel, questions his authority, and alleges the document is unstamped.

¶ 12, 28

Payment was not made. Email exchanges between 2024 and 2025 show the matter remained under discussion.

¶ 39–44

The Petitioner issued a legal notice on 17 February 2026 alleging transfer of about USD 1,000,000 from Respondent No. 1's Bhopal office, and invoked arbitration on 15 September 2026.

¶ 4–5, 45

The Agra Metro contract (terminated) and the Bhopal-Indore contract (ended on national-security grounds) were affected in 2025.

¶ 46–47

The Petitioner sought deposit or bank guarantee of USD 700,000, restraint on dealing with assets, disclosure of bank accounts, and disclosure by Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. (Respondent No. 4).

¶ 16, 50

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Petitioner has shown sufficient grounds under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 to direct Respondent No. 1 to deposit USD 700,000 or furnish a bank guarantee for that amount.

¶ 16–17, 51–52

ii.2. Whether there is material justifying restraint on Respondent No. 1's dealing with its assets and bank accounts, and disclosure orders against Respondent No. 1 and Respondent No. 4.

¶ 16, 49–50, 58

iii.3. Whether the back-to-back payment condition in the 2022 Agreement ceased upon termination on 19 July 2024, or was altered by the Minutes of 9 August 2024.

¶ 23–24, 25–32

iv.4. Whether the Minutes of 9 August 2024 constitute an admission of an unconditional, immediately payable liability of USD 700,000.

¶ 34–36, 54

03Law Applied

Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, under which interim protection is available pending arbitration, but the applicant must show necessity for protection to prevent an award becoming ineffective.

¶ 17, 56

A Section 9 power is wide but is not a means to convert an ordinary disputed money claim into a secured claim; relief is granted only where a proper case, necessity, balance of convenience, and risk of serious irreparable loss are shown, though the technical requirements of attachment before judgment under the CPC need not be applied rigidly.

¶ 51

A foreign incorporation or the loss of projects alone does not justify security absent conduct creating a real risk of award frustration.

¶ 47

Clause 11.3 requires changes to be in writing and signed by authorised representatives of both parties, and Clause 11.1 makes the Agreement the entire agreement.

¶ 30, 32

Tata Advanced Materials Ltd. v. Tooltech Global Engineering Pvt. Ltd., 2013 SCC OnLine Bom 1922 (Division Bench) held that a back-to-back condition backed by an unconditional undertaking and balance confirmations, with a 45-day fallback, did not allow a non-bona fide dispute to be raised; the Court followed it but distinguished it on those facts.

¶ 33–37

The Respondent's Kompetenz-Kompetenz argument under Section 16 was noted, with the merits left to the Tribunal.

¶ 14, 57

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 9Section 16

04Reasoning

Termination by email did not automatically extinguish the back-to-back condition. Accrued rights survived, and whether the condition continued or was replaced depends on reading the Agreement with the Minutes.

¶ 24

The Minutes record a payment obligation, but they contain no payment date, do not expressly remove Clause 3, and their signatory's authority is disputed.

¶ 25–31

Unlike Tata, there is no unconditional undertaking, no balance confirmation, and no admission by an undisputed authorised officer, so the Division Bench's findings could not be applied.

¶ 35

The later emails show that the parties treated USD 700,000 as part of a wider accounts reconciliation, and Respondent No. 1 did not unconditionally accept it.

¶ 41–44

On the protective relief, the Court found that the Petitioner had a genuine claim but no material of asset dissipation, sham transactions, or intent to defeat an award. The legal notice's USD 1,000,000 transfer allegation was unsupported by any bank record.

¶ 45, 48, 54

The Agra and Bhopal-Indore terminations did not establish insolvency or flight of assets.

¶ 47

The Petitioner gave no convincing reason for waiting from 2025 until September 2026 to seek urgent relief, which weakened the claim of immediate danger.

¶ 53

Respondent No. 4 was not shown to hold money belonging to Respondent No. 1, as its contract with the Joint Venture was separate and Texmaco's interests may be involved.

¶ 49

The wide orders sought would effectively secure the whole claim, affecting working capital and banking limits.

¶ 50–51, 55

05Holding

The Petitioner has a claim that can be pursued before the Arbitral Tribunal, but it has not shown the necessity required for interim protection under Section 9.

¶ 56

Whether USD 700,000 is unconditionally payable, whether the Minutes bind Respondent No. 1 and are authorised, and the effect of Clause 3 are for the Tribunal.

¶ 34, 57

The Petition was dismissed. The prayers for deposit of USD 700,000, bank guarantee, restraint on dealing with assets, disclosure of accounts and money sent abroad, and disclosure by Respondent No. 4 were refused. There was no order as to costs.

¶ 58–59

Dismissal does not bar the Petitioner from pursuing its money claim in arbitration under Clause 10.

¶ 60–61
Bombay High Court

Original Court PDF

Amay Technosystems Private LimitedvsAsis Elektronik Ve Biliim Sistemleri A

Bombay High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment