01Facts
The petitioner-plaintiff sued for specific performance of a 1996 Memorandum of Understanding and a 1997 Agreement for Sale relating to about 47,356 sq. mtrs. at Malonde, Taluka Vasai, executed by the predecessors-in-title of original defendants 1 to 9.
¶ 3.1, 3.2On 30 April 2012 the plaintiff entered into Consent Terms with defendants 1 to 5 and 7 to 9. Those defendants executed conveyances of their 23/24th share between 31 December 2011 and 25 July 2012.
¶ 3.3, 3.4Defendant 2 died on 6 February 2015 without his legal representatives being brought on record in time.
¶ 3.6Defendant 1 died on 3 March 2022, and his legal representatives were likewise not brought on record.
¶ 3.13The trial court rejected defendant 6's application to dismiss the suit as abated by order dated 14 July 2022, reasoning that defendant 2 had performed his part during his lifetime.
¶ 3.8The trial court then allowed the plaintiff's amendment (Exh. 136), confining the suit to defendant 6's share and deleting defendants 1 to 5 and 7 to 9, and rejected the application to bring defendant 2's legal representatives on record.
¶ 3.9, 3.10, 13, 14Defendant 6's revision against the July 2022 order was withdrawn with liberty to seek framing of an additional issue on whole-suit abatement.
¶ 3.11, 3.12Defendant 6's application (Exh. 302) was allowed, and the trial court framed the additional issue: whether the entire suit abates as a whole.
¶ 3.14, 3.16The plaintiff challenged that order under Article 227.
¶ 2, 3.1702Issues
i.1. Whether the suit abates as a whole, or only as against the deceased defendants, when the legal representatives of deceased defendants 1 and 2 are not brought on record.
¶ 16, 17ii.2. Whether the right to sue survived against the legal representatives of deceased defendants 1 and 2, given that they executed conveyances during their lifetimes.
¶ 18, 19, 24iii.3. Whether the trial court was justified in framing the additional issue on whole-suit abatement, having regard to the pleadings and the post-amendment position of the suit.
¶ 5, 6, 15, 33, 3403Law Applied
Order XXII Rule 4(1) and (3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, under which, where one of several defendants dies and the right to sue does not survive against the surviving defendants alone, the suit abates only as against the deceased defendant if no application is made in time.
¶ 16, 17Section 306 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, under which demands and rights existing at the time of death survive to and against the legal representatives, subject to exceptions; the right to sue cannot survive in the abstract.
¶ 20, 21The second part of Section 37 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, under which promises bind the promisor's representatives on death before performance, absent a contrary intention.
¶ 22Ram Sarup v. Munshi, AIR 1963 SC 553, for the rule that a joint decree, part of which becomes final by abatement, requires the entire appeal to abate.
¶ 29Sri Chand v. Jagdish Pershad Kishan Chand, AIR 1966 SC 1427, on the limits of appellate power where one party dies.
¶ 30Shahzada Bi v. Halimabi, (2004) 7 SCC 354, on the test of contradictory decrees in appeals.
¶ 31State of Punjab v. Nathu Ram, AIR 1962 SC 89, which concerned appellate abatement and was distinguished.
¶ 28A decree for specific performance of an agreement to sell an undivided share is not barred in law, leaving the purchaser to seek partition.
¶ 27Whole-suit abatement can arise only where no effective decree is possible against the survivors.
¶ 26Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 306
Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 37
04Reasoning
The court first asked whether any right to sue survived against the legal representatives of defendants 1 and 2. Because both had executed conveyances in performance during their lifetimes, nothing remained to be enforced against their estates.
¶ 23, 24Applying Section 306 and Order XXII Rule 4, the court held that the right to sue did not survive, so there was no abatement qua those defendants. That finding removed the premise of the respondent's argument.
¶ 23, 24Whole-suit abatement depends on abatement against a deceased party, and where none occurred the rule in Ram Sarup and Sri Chand was not engaged.
¶ 26The court held that the appellate cases concerned a different situation, namely the risk of contradictory decrees on appeal, and did not govern a suit in which a co-defendant settled and was deleted.
¶ 32The indivisibility of the original cause of action did not prevent the suit from proceeding against the surviving defendant's share.
¶ 32, 27The court also rejected the argument that continuing disputes with the deleted defendants over the conveyances kept the lis alive, since those disputes were irrelevant to the present controversy.
¶ 14The court held that the additional issue would expand the scope of adjudication beyond the pivotal question of specific performance against defendant 6's share, and would conflict with this Court's time-bound directions. The trial court had already framed a maintainability issue.
¶ 33The court did not separately decide the Article 227 scope argument, and resolved the matter on the merits of the abatement question.
¶ 9, 3405Holding
The right to sue did not survive against the legal representatives of deceased defendants 1 and 2 because they performed their obligations during their lifetimes, so the suit did not abate qua them and could not abate as a whole.
¶ 24, 26, 32The additional issue of whole-suit abatement was unjustified and could not be sustained.
¶ 34The petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 23 April 2026 is quashed and set aside. The additional issue is deleted. The trial court is directed to decide the suit expeditiously in line with earlier directions. The rule is made absolute, with no costs.
¶ 35(i)–(v)Original Court PDF
Evershine Builders Private LimitedvsHiren Jaswant Rajani
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
