Bombay High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Oral Promise Of Half A House Fails For Sister's Family; Bombay HC Upholds Order To Return Flat To Owner

Kiran Santosh Soni And Anr.v.Ramchandra Waman Erande And Anr.

Oral Promise Of Half A House Fails For Sister's Family; Bombay HC Upholds Order To Return Flat To Owner. Kiran Santosh Soni And Anr. vs Ramchandra Waman Erande And Anr.. Bombay High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the concurrent findings that the plaintiffs failed to prove the oral agreement for joint acquisition and construction raise a substantial question of law in second appeal (SA/12/2026).

The court held

No substantial question of law arises in SA/12/2026, and the rejection of the Order XLI Rule 27 application was not shown to be unsustainable.

It also directed

In SA/136/2026, the defendant company, as licensee, was obliged to re-deliver possession after the licence ended, and the courts below were justified in decreeing possession. Both second appeals are dismissed with costs, and IA No. 2083 of 2026 is dismissed as not surviving.

01Facts

The suit property is Municipal House No. 13/103, Survey No. 97, Hissa No. 2B, NA Plot No. 4, admeasuring 217 sq. m., with two residential units.

¶ 3

The plaintiffs (Kiran and her husband Santosh) claimed that, under oral agreements with their brother-in-law Ramchandra (defendant No. 1) and sister Rekha (defendant No. 2), the parties would jointly buy the plot and build houses, with half to be transferred to the plaintiffs by sale deed.

¶ 4

The plot was bought in Ramchandra's name in August 2004 under a registered sale deed, and the plaintiffs claimed to have paid Rs. 3,06,989/- towards the purchase and construction.

¶ 5–6

The defendants denied any such agreement, asserting that they funded the construction and that the northern unit was leased to H. and R. Johnson (India) under a leave and licence agreement dated 23 January 2006. Santosh, an employee of the licensee, occupied the unit as an allottee, and the licence expired on 30 November 2007.

¶ 7

The Civil Judge dismissed the specific performance suit (SCS No. 15/2010).

¶ 8

The District Judge dismissed the appeal (RCA No. 10/2013) and rejected the plaintiffs' application for additional evidence under Order XLI Rule 27 CPC.

¶ 9

In the parallel RCS No. 28/2010, the Civil Judge decreed Ramchandra's suit for possession against the licensee and for arrears of licence fee of Rs. 67,500/- with 8% interest.

¶ 11–13

The Principal District Judge dismissed the licensee's appeal on 10 April 2025.

¶ 14

02Issues

i.1. Whether the concurrent findings that the plaintiffs failed to prove the oral agreement for joint acquisition and construction raise a substantial question of law in second appeal (SA/12/2026).

¶ 17, 19–22, 27

ii.2. Whether the First Appellate Court erred in rejecting the plaintiffs' application to adduce additional evidence under Order XLI Rule 27 CPC (SA/12/2026).

¶ 18, 24–26

iii.3. Whether the licensee defendant company, having failed to re-deliver possession on expiry of the licence, can avoid the decree for possession and arrears on the ground that Santosh occupied the unit as a co-owner (SA/136/2026).

¶ 28–34

03Law Applied

The court applied the principle that a second appeal lies only on a substantial question of law, so concurrent findings of fact are not disturbed absent perversity or misreading of evidence.

¶ 17, 19, 27

The court relied on Order XLI Rule 27 CPC, under which additional evidence is generally not permitted to fill a lacuna, but may be admitted under clause (b) where the appellate court itself requires it to pronounce judgment, as laid down in Wadi v. Amilal, (2015) 1 SCC 677.

¶ 25

A licensee who obtained possession under a licence must re-deliver possession once the licence and the jural relationship end, and a change in that relationship is ineffective without the licensor's participation.

¶ 31, 34

04Reasoning

The courts below concurrently found that the plaint's averments of the oral agreement were vague and unsupported by cogent evidence, and the court held that the relationship between the parties alone could not establish the agreement.

¶ 20–21

The electricity connection in the plaintiffs' name and the entries of payments to Ramchandra's loan account did not advance the case, because Santosh entered the unit as an employee of the licensee, which undercut the claim of co-ownership from inception.

¶ 23

The court found that the District Judge had not erred, because the plaintiffs were not shown to be lacking the documents, and the Appellate Court's decision that additional evidence was not necessary for a satisfactory disposal was reasonable in light of the concurrent findings.

¶ 24, 26

The court held that the letter dated 28 November 2007 (Exh. 69) could not alter the licence relationship. It was signed only by Santosh, not by the licensor, and its contents were improbable, since Ramchandra was said to have accompanied Santosh while making a representation against his own interest. Nor was there any evidence that the company informed Santosh that his occupation had changed.

¶ 31–33

The uncontested facts (letting, expiry of licence, non-delivery of possession, non-payment of fees, and repeated demands) established the defendants' obligation to re-deliver possession.

¶ 30

05Holding

No substantial question of law arises in SA/12/2026, and the rejection of the Order XLI Rule 27 application was not shown to be unsustainable.

¶ 26–27

In SA/136/2026, the defendant company, as licensee, was obliged to re-deliver possession after the licence ended, and the courts below were justified in decreeing possession. Both second appeals are dismissed with costs, and IA No. 2083 of 2026 is dismissed as not surviving.

¶ 34, 36(i)–(iii)
Bombay High Court

Original Court PDF

Kiran Santosh Soni And Anr.vsRamchandra Waman Erande And Anr.

Bombay High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment