01Facts
The Petitioner was the Managing Director and CEO of ICICI Bank.
The CBI registered an FIR in January 2019 under the IPC and Sections 7, 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 ("PC Act") in connection with loans sanctioned to the Videocon Group.
¶ 3The Petitioner was arrested under the PMLA in February 2021 and later arrested by the CBI in December 2022. This Court granted interim bail in January 2023.
¶ 4On 27.03.2023 the CBI wrote to ICICI Bank seeking sanction under Section 19 of the PC Act. The Board of Directors granted sanction on 15.05.2023, and the chargesheet was filed on 28.03.2023.
¶ 4The Special Court took cognizance on 12.07.2023.
The Petitioner filed the present writ petition on 04.12.2023, before framing of charge.
¶ 11The Petitioner contended that the Board was not the competent authority, that the Reserve Bank of India ("RBI") alone could act under Sections 36-AA and 36-AC of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 ("BR Act"), and that the sanction reflected non-application of mind.
¶ 5.1–5.9The CBI contended that the petition was not maintainable, that the Board was competent under the Articles and Companies Act, that validity of sanction is a question for trial, and that the Petitioner's stance was estopped by her own pleading.
¶ 6.1–6.12The Petitioner's Additional Affidavit dated 04.09.2024 was filed with leave of Court.
¶ 1202Issues
i.1. Whether this Court has jurisdiction under Article 226 and Section 482 CrPC to examine the validity of sanction under Section 19 of the PC Act, given Section 19(3)–(4), and whether the Petitioner was precluded from raising the ground of competence in her Additional Affidavit.
¶ 8, 10, 12–13ii.2. Whether the Board of Directors of ICICI Bank was the "authority competent to remove" the Petitioner under Section 19(1)(c) of the PC Act, and therefore competent to grant sanction.
¶ 8, 15–28iii.3. Whether the absence of a valid sanction, as distinct from an irregular sanction, can be decided at the threshold rather than at trial.
¶ 29–34iv.4. Whether the impugned sanction is vitiated for non-application of mind, because the material collected by the CBI was not placed before the sanctioning authority.
¶ 35–4403Law Applied
Section 19 of the PC Act bars cognizance of offences under Sections 7, 11, 13 and 15 without previous sanction from the authority competent to remove the public servant.
¶ 9, s.19(1)(c)Under Section 19(3)–(4), a court in appeal, confirmation or revision cannot reverse a conviction for sanction defects unless a failure of justice is shown, and "error" includes competency of the authority.
¶ 9 · ¶ 10Sections 5-A, 35-B(1)(b), 36-AA and 36-AC of the BR Act override the Companies Act and the Articles and make RBI approval and RBI removal powers prevail over Board action on banking company officers.
¶ 15–25K. Veeraswami v. Union of India holds that "authority competent to remove" means the authority without whose order the public servant cannot be removed.
¶ 27Parkash Singh Badal v. State of Punjab and State of Karnataka v. C. Nagarajaswamy distinguish absence of sanction (raisable at the threshold) from non-application of mind (ordinarily for trial).
¶ 29Nanjappa v. State of Karnataka, Abdul Wahab Ansari v. State of Bihar, Shankar Moitra v. Sadhna Das and State of Goa v. Babu Thomas hold that absence of valid sanction goes to jurisdiction.
¶ 30, 33CBI v. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal and State of Karnataka v. Ameerjan require the entire relevant record to be placed before the sanctioning authority and the order to show application of mind.
¶ 15–16 · ¶ 40, 43Baij Nath Prasad Tripathi v. State of Bhopal holds that cognizance without legal sanction renders the trial null.
¶ 45Provisions in the judgment · 21 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 190Section 191Section 192Section 203Section 482Section 529Section 530
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 Section 7Section 11Section 13Section 15Section 19
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 420
Banking Regulation Act, 1949 Section 2Section 5
Companies Act, 2013 Section 2Section 149Section 163Section 169Section 203Section 242
04Reasoning
Section 19(3)–(4) does not oust writ jurisdiction, because the High Court was not sitting in appeal, confirmation or revision.
¶ 10–13The Petitioner had raised the competence ground in Ground K and in the Additional Affidavit filed with leave, and cognizance was taken before charge was framed, so the objection was taken at the first available stage.
¶ 10–13The Companies Act provisions cited by the CBI cannot prevail because Section 5-A(a)–(b) and Section 36-AC override conflicting provisions, and reading the Companies Act as the CBI urged would make those provisions otiose.
¶ 16–18Under Section 35-B(1)(b) the appointment and termination of a managing director require RBI's prior approval. Section 36-AA vests the power of removal in RBI, and it requires reasons and a hearing, neither of which occurred.
¶ 19–21The Board's power under Clause 151(a) of the Articles was therefore subordinate to the BR Act.
¶ 21–25The Court rejected the estoppel argument based on the Petitioner's paragraph 1 averment, holding that no party can be estopped against a statute.
¶ 26Because the Board was not the competent authority, the sanction was held to be absent in law and not merely defective. The Court therefore treated the defect as jurisdictional and suitable for threshold determination, rejecting the CBI's reliance on Parkash Singh Badal and Dinesh Kumar for relegation to trial.
¶ 30–34, 36–37Independently, the sanction showed no application of mind. The Board resolution and sanction letter recorded only the CBI's letter and report, gave no reasons, and recorded the Bank's own position that no wrongful loss was caused. The CBI's material was not placed before the Board, so the Ameerjan and Aggarwal requirements were not met.
¶ 35–4405Holding
This Court has jurisdiction to decide the validity of sanction at the threshold.
¶ 13The Board of Directors of ICICI Bank was not the competent authority under Section 19(1)(c) of the PC Act, the power of removal of the Managing Director vesting exclusively in RBI under Section 36-AA BR Act.
¶ 28, 37, 45The sanction also disclosed no application of mind.
¶ 41–44The cognizance taken on the defective sanction is illegal.
¶ 39, 46The Writ Petition is allowed. The sanction dated 15.05.2023 is quashed and set aside under prayer clauses (a) and (b), including consequential actions in CBI Special Case No. 874 of 2023.
¶ 47–48The CBI's oral request for an eight-week stay to challenge the judgment was declined.
¶ 49Original Court PDF
Chanda KochharvsCentral Bureau Of Investigation And Anr
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
