Bombay High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawAdministrative and Public Law

Bombay HC Denies Anklesaria Trust Possession of Pune Cantonment Land Over Unproven Absolute Title

The Union Of Indiav.T.S.Anklesaria ,A Private Trust

Bombay HC Denies Anklesaria Trust Possession of Pune Cantonment Land Over Unproven Absolute Title. The Union Of India vs T.S.Anklesaria ,A Private Trust. Bombay High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the suit should be brought under the Bombay Rent Act or under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

The court held

The Rent Act is inapplicable to the Government-leased cantonment premises. The TP Act provisions on notice do not apply to the land, which is held under old grant and is subject to the Government's resumption right.

It also directed

The notice dated 5 June 1980 is invalid because it was issued before the lease's six-month notice period expired.

The plaintiffs are not entitled to possession of the land and structure. Their right to seek possession of the bungalow under the lease agreements is expressly kept open.

The arrears claim and set-off were correctly decided, and no question of law was framed on them.

Orders: the decree for possession is set aside and an inquiry into mesne profits is directed. The remaining decree is modified accordingly, with no order as to costs.

01Facts

The suit property is Survey No. 742 (0.85 acres) in Pune Cantonment, with a bungalow standing on it.

¶ 4

The plaintiffs' predecessor-in-title acquired the bungalow by a registered sale deed dated 6 September 1918 (Exh. 137).

¶ 31, 53

The defendants (Union of India and the Military Estate Officer) took the bungalow on lease: a 1929 lease executed under the Cantonments (House-Accommodation) Act, 1923 (Exh. 127), a 1935 monthly agreement, and a "Repairing Lease" dated 19 April 1940 (Exh. 62).

¶ 5, 48–49, 70

The Repairing Lease contained a six-month termination notice clause and a clause preserving the Government's right of resumption.

¶ 70, 74

A resumption notice dated 29 January 1972 was issued and compensation of Rs. 29,596/- was paid under protest.

¶ 6

A Division Bench of this Court declared the resumption notice unlawful (5 February 1979) without formally quashing it.

¶ 14

The Supreme Court, by order dated 20 July 1988, retransferred the appeals and directed that they be decided uninfluenced by the Division Bench's observations, with liberty to lead additional evidence.

¶ 15

The plaintiffs' notice dated 5 June 1980 (Exh. 59) terminated the tenancy, and the suit (filed 1 December 1980) sought possession, arrears of rent and damages.

¶ 7, 73, 75

The Trial Court decreed possession and Rs. 8,000/- damages. The First Appellate Court partly modified the decree, holding the suit maintainable under the TP Act and granting set-off against the compensation.

¶ 11–12

02Issues

i.1. Whether the suit should be brought under the Bombay Rent Act or under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

¶ 47, 52, 72

ii.2. Whether the plaintiffs served a valid notice on the defendants to determine the tenancy.

¶ 52, 73–75

iii.3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to possession of the suit property.

¶ 52, 79

03Law Applied

The Cantonments (House-Accommodation) Act, 1923, ss. 5–7, govern appropriation of houses by lease.

¶ 48

The Cantonments (Extension of Rent Control Laws) Act, 1957 and the notification of 27 December 1969 substituted s. 4(1) of the Bombay Rent Act to exclude tenancies in cantonment premises taken on lease by the Government.

¶ 50–51

Sections 106 and 111(g) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 apply to notice and determination of tenancy.

¶ 72–73

The Government Grants Act, 1895, ss. 2–3, provide that Government grants take effect according to their tenor, and the TP Act does not apply to them.

¶ 21, 68

The General Lands Order of 6 January 1827 (Exh. 226) and the Military Lands Manual, Rule 8 (Class B-3 land) establish that Government retains proprietary rights and that a grantee's occupancy right is resumable.

¶ 54–56

Union of India v. Dinshaw Shapoorji Anklesari (2014) 14 SCC 204 is binding authority holding that the Union of India is not a tenant of such land, that the occupant holds only the structure, and that the Government has a right of resumption.

¶ 69–71

Chief Executive Officer v. Surendra Kumar Vakil (1999) 3 SCC 555 recognises that old-grant lands form a self-contained regime.

¶ 61–62, 68

Kaikhoshrou (Chick) Kavasji Framji v. Union of India (2019) 20 SCC 705 and State of A.P. v. D. Raghukul Pershad (2012) 8 SCC 584 were distinguished.

¶ 43, 76–77

Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (2001) 3 SCC 179 governs the scope of re-appreciation of evidence.

¶ 39, 78

Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 106Section 111

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 80

Cantonments (Extension of Rent Control Laws) Act, 1957 Section 3

04Reasoning

The Rent Act did not apply because the Repairing Lease falls within the substituted s. 4(1) exemption for Government-leased cantonment premises.

¶ 50–51

Under the 1929 lease, the Cantonments Act procedure was followed. The later agreements were private but were still tied to the same premises, so the Court treated them as part of one tenancy relationship.

¶ 48–49

Applying Dinshaw Shapoorji, the Court held that the land belonged to the Union of India, that the Union could not be treated as a tenant, and that a TP Act notice under s. 106 read with s. 111(g) was therefore inapplicable to the land.

¶ 71–72

The Court then examined the notice on its own terms. Clause 5 of the lease required six months' written notice before determination and preserved the resumption right. The plaintiffs issued only a 15-day notice and filed suit before the six-month period expired. The notice was therefore invalid.

¶ 74–75

The sale deed of 1918 recited only the vendor's apparent ownership and so conferred no better title than the vendor held. The GLR entries (Class B-3, old grant), the 1885 permission letter (Exh. 139), and the additional evidence (the 1918 correspondence and release deed) all showed occupancy rights only.

¶ 53–60

Construction by the grantee created a right in the structure, not absolute title to the land.

¶ 79

Kaikhoshrou did not apply because it turned on the Union's abandonment of summary proceedings after the Supreme Court's 1998 order, which had not been recorded here.

¶ 76

D. Raghukul Pershad did not apply because the plaintiffs' suit rested on a claim of absolute ownership, and the appellants' resumption right is protected under the lease.

¶ 77

Because the plaintiffs sought possession without a declaration of title and without establishing title, they were not entitled to possession.

¶ 79

05Holding

The Rent Act is inapplicable to the Government-leased cantonment premises. The TP Act provisions on notice do not apply to the land, which is held under old grant and is subject to the Government's resumption right.

¶ 51, 72

The notice dated 5 June 1980 is invalid because it was issued before the lease's six-month notice period expired.

¶ 75

The plaintiffs are not entitled to possession of the land and structure. Their right to seek possession of the bungalow under the lease agreements is expressly kept open.

¶ 79–80

The arrears claim and set-off were correctly decided, and no question of law was framed on them.

¶ 81

Orders: the decree for possession is set aside and an inquiry into mesne profits is directed. The remaining decree is modified accordingly, with no order as to costs.

¶ 82
Bombay High Court

Original Court PDF

The Union Of IndiavsT.S.Anklesaria ,A Private Trust

Bombay High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment