Bombay High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Bombay HC Quashes Abetment Case Against Four Men Named in Father's Suicide Note, Citing Six-Month Gap

Nenuram Hiraram Fulwariya And Orsv.State Of Maharashtra And Anr

Bombay HC Quashes Abetment Case Against Four Men Named in Father's Suicide Note, Citing Six-Month Gap. Nenuram Hiraram Fulwariya And Ors vs State Of Maharashtra And Anr. Bombay High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the continuation of proceedings under Sections 306 r/w 34 IPC against the applicants, in the absence of a prima facie case of abetment, amounts to an abuse of process warranting quashing under the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court.

The court held

Continuation of proceedings against the four applicants would amount to an abuse of process, as no prima facie case under Section 306 r/w 34 IPC was made out.

It also directed

The Criminal Application is allowed. The investigation and proceedings in Sessions Case No. 149 of 2024 (C.R. No. 226 of 2019) are quashed and set aside as against the four applicants, along with all consequential proceedings. The order is confined to the applicants and does not affect the remaining accused. The High Court Legal Aid Services Authority is directed to pay the fees of the appointed advocate for Respondent No. 2.

01Facts

The four applicants (Accused Nos. 2–5) sought quashing of proceedings in Sessions Case No. 149 of 2024, arising from C.R. No. 226 of 2019 (C.R. No. 355 of 2019, Nehru Nagar P.S.), for offences under Sections 306 r/w 34 IPC.

¶ 2

The prosecution case is that the deceased's minor daughter went missing on 30.03.2019. He lodged C.R. No. 131 of 2019 on 25.04.2019 against Accused No. 3 under Section 363 IPC for enticing her.

¶ 3

On 13.10.2019 he died by suicide before a train, and five chits recovered from his pocket attributed his decision to the accused persons' conduct.

¶ 3

Respondent No. 2 (wife) lodged a complaint on 14.10.2019 at Wadala Railway P.S., leading to the charge-sheet against the applicants and Accused No. 1, who is not before the Court.

¶ 3

Applicant No. 1 furnished details of Applicant No. 2 to police and facilitated a video call; Applicant No. 2 attended the police station on the police's direction.

¶ 4, 9

Subsequent investigation revealed that the minor had died by suicide on 30.03.2019 and had not eloped.

¶ 4.1, 8

By order dated 23.06.2025 in C.C. No. 875/PW/2019, the ACJM, Esplanade, on a C-Summary report, discharged all accused for Sections 363 and 368 r/w 34 IPC.

¶ 4.2, 10

The applicants also disputed the chits' recovery and custody, the delayed production of the deceased's damaged mobile phone, and the lack of investigation into allegations against a Senior Police Inspector.

¶ 4.3–4.4, 11–13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the continuation of proceedings under Sections 306 r/w 34 IPC against the applicants, in the absence of a prima facie case of abetment, amounts to an abuse of process warranting quashing under the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court.

¶ 17

ii.2. Whether the subsequent investigation and the discharge order dated 23.06.2025 in C.C. No. 875/PW/2019 are relevant to assessing the applicants' liability under Section 306 IPC.

¶ 10

iii.3. Whether the circumstances surrounding the five chits and the mobile phone create doubt sufficient to be considered at the quashing stage.

¶ 11–13

iv.4. Whether the High Court may quash proceedings against only some of the accused, leaving the remaining accused to face trial.

¶ 16

03Law Applied

Section 306 IPC requires abetment under Section 107 IPC, and the prosecution must show instigation, intentional aid, or conspiracy, and a "proximate and live link" between the accused's acts and the suicide.

¶ 14–15

Section 34 IPC on common intention was applied.

The discharge order under Sections 363 and 368 IPC is relevant, though not determinative, of Section 306 liability.

¶ 10

A suicide note referring to persons is not, by itself, sufficient to establish abetment.

¶ 14

Lovely Salhotra v. State of NCT Delhi (Cr. A. No. 670 of 2017, 10 April 2017), Supreme Court: neither Section 482 CrPC nor Section 528 BNSS bars partial quashing in favour of certain accused.

¶ 16

Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 306Section 34Section 363Section 368Section 107

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 528

04Reasoning

The prosecution's foundation was substantially displaced. The deceased's suicide note and complaint rested on the belief that his daughter had been abducted, but investigation showed she had died by suicide on 30.03.2019.

¶ 8, 10

There was a gap of over six months between the alleged enticement and the suicide, during which the applicants cooperated with police and no fresh overt act of instigation or aid was alleged.

¶ 9, 15

Although the discharge order concerned different offences and did not decide Section 306 liability, the Court treated the subsequent findings and the wife's non-objection as relevant circumstances.

¶ 10

The individually insufficient discrepancies in the chits' recovery and custody, the delayed and damaged mobile phone, and the unexamined allegations against a police officer cumulatively raised serious doubt about the investigation.

¶ 11–13

This was not a finding on the chits' authenticity but a basis to find no prima facie case.

¶ 17

The Section 306 ingredients were not met on the material, and trial would serve no purpose.

¶ 15, 17

Under Lovely Salhotra, partial quashing was permissible.

¶ 16

05Holding

Continuation of proceedings against the four applicants would amount to an abuse of process, as no prima facie case under Section 306 r/w 34 IPC was made out.

¶ 17

The Criminal Application is allowed. The investigation and proceedings in Sessions Case No. 149 of 2024 (C.R. No. 226 of 2019) are quashed and set aside as against the four applicants, along with all consequential proceedings. The order is confined to the applicants and does not affect the remaining accused. The High Court Legal Aid Services Authority is directed to pay the fees of the appointed advocate for Respondent No. 2.

¶ 18, 19, 20, 21
Bombay High Court

Original Court PDF

Nenuram Hiraram Fulwariya And OrsvsState Of Maharashtra And Anr

Bombay High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment