01Facts
Junaid Ebrahim Khan and three brothers were introduced to Abis Rizvi (Accused No. 5), a director of Rizvi Land Development Pvt. Ltd. (Accused No. 1), for purchasing commercial premises.
¶ 4.1Four MOUs dated 22.04.2013 were executed by Abis Rizvi on the Company's behalf, under which each brother paid Rs. 70 lakhs.
¶ 4.1 · ¶ 10Abis Rizvi was not authorised by a board resolution, and the other directors were unaware of the MOUs.
¶ 4.1Abis Rizvi died on 01.01.2017.
¶ 4.2Thereafter the brothers negotiated allotment of four 3 BHK residential flats with the petitioner, Dr. Akhtar Hasan Rizvi (Accused No. 2, father of Abis), and the flats were allotted.
¶ 4.2The complainant filed complaints at Bandra and Vakola Police Stations and with DCP Zone VIII (2017–2018), and a MahaRERA complaint (15.11.2017) that was withdrawn on 11.01.2018.
¶ 4.2–4.3Vakola Police consigned the complaint to record on 31.05.2018 for non-pursuit.
¶ 4.3The brothers filed commercial suits in this Court on 01.07.2022 seeking refund; ad-interim relief was refused.
¶ 4.4, 10An FIR (CR No. 786/2022, Vakola PS, later EOW CR No. 121/2022) was registered on 28.07.2022, 27 days later, against the Company and directors, including the petitioners.
¶ 4, 11Dr. Rizvi deposited Rs. 3 crores each on 11.08.2023 and 13.08.2023 (total Rs. 6 crores) in the anticipatory bail proceedings.
¶ 4.5, 11Chargesheet was filed on 16.10.2023 under IPC ss. 409, 420, 34 and MOFA ss. 3, 4, 8, 13 (CC No. 769/PW/2023).
¶ 4.5Writ Petition 502/2024 concerns Reshma Rizvi and Meena Rizvi, who are charged merely as directors; Meena Rizvi resided in the US for about 20 years and Reshma Rizvi is an 84-year-old homemaker.
¶ 3, 14The EOW took up the matter although the claim appeared below its Rs. 10 crore threshold.
¶ 1202Issues
i.1. Whether the FIR and chargesheet for cheating and criminal breach of trust (IPC ss. 409, 420, 34; MOFA) can be sustained against directors who did not execute the MOUs and against whom no specific role is attributed.
¶ 5 · ¶ 14 · ¶ 17ii.2. Whether the dispute is essentially civil in nature, with the criminal complaint an abuse of process and a means of coercing settlement of pending civil suits.
¶ 11, 13, 15, 18–19iii.3. Whether the criminal proceedings are mala fide or instituted for ulterior motive, such that they should be quashed under Section 482 CrPC and Article 226.
¶ 12, 13, 1903Law Applied
IPC s. 405/409 (criminal breach of trust) and s. 420 (cheating) require, respectively, entrustment of property with dominion and dishonest misappropriation, and a dishonest or fraudulent inducement existing at inception.
¶ 5, as argued · ¶ 16IPC s. 34 requires a prior meeting of minds and participation in the criminal act.
¶ 17A director may be prosecuted only where incriminating material shows his own active role coupled with criminal intent; mere directorship does not attract vicarious criminal liability under the IPC.
¶ 16 · ¶ 5, as argued · no citationThe Bhajan Lal guidelines (State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, 1992 SCC (Cri) 4226), specifically categories (1) (allegations, even if accepted, do not constitute an offence), (3) (uncontroverted allegations and collected evidence disclose no offence), and (7) (proceedings manifestly mala fide or instituted for private vengeance).
¶ 19Civil remedies under the MOU and MOFA, and the pending suits, are the appropriate forum for a money claim.
¶ 15, 19The respondent's authorities, Shivkumar Jatia v. State of NCT of Delhi (2019) 17 SCC 193 (alter-ego liability) and State of Rajasthan v. Vidyawati, AIR 1962 SC 933, were argued but not discussed in the reasoning.
¶ 7.5, 7.6Provisions in the judgment · 10 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482Section 156Section 155
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 409Section 420Section 34
Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the promotion of construction, sale, management and transfer) Act, 1963 Section 3Section 4Section 8Section 13
04Reasoning
The court held that the petitioners had no role in the MOU transactions, which were executed solely by the deceased Abis Rizvi for the Company, and that no inducement, representation, or entrustment of money to them was alleged or shown.
¶ 10, 14, 16, 17Bank records and statements of the three other brothers were absent, and no money was shown to have reached the petitioners personally.
¶ 12Mere directorship and family relationship were held insufficient for criminal liability absent an active role and criminal intent.
¶ 14, 16The court treated the chronology as indicative of mala fides: the complainant pursued multiple forums over five years without obtaining orders, then filed the FIR within 27 days of commercial suits seeking the same money, while the petitioners had offered a refund and deposited Rs. 6 crores.
¶ 11, 13, 17The court therefore concluded the FIR was a counterblast to force settlement of a civil money claim, bringing it within Bhajan Lal categories (1), (3) and (7).
¶ 13, 15, 19The court noted that the civil suits, which are pending, would decide the money claim on evidence, and that the complainant was not precluded from pursuing them.
¶ 19Continuing prosecution would therefore be a travesty of justice and harassment.
¶ 2005Holding
No prima facie offence of cheating or criminal breach of trust is made out against the three petitioners; the dispute is civil in nature and the FIR is mala fide.
¶ 15–20Both writ petitions were allowed. In WP 1489/2024, FIR No. 786/2022 (EOW CR No. 121/2022), the chargesheet, and CC No. 769/PW/2023 (47th Metropolitan Magistrate's Court, Esplanade) were quashed as against the petitioner. In WP 502/2024, FIR No. 915/2022 and CC No. 769/PW/2023 were quashed as against Reshma and Meena Rizvi. The Rs. 6 crore deposit stands, and withdrawal is left to be sought in accordance with law. Pending civil suits are to be tried on evidence.
¶ 19, 21–22 · ¶ 21(a) · ¶ 21(b)Original Court PDF
Reshma Rizvi And AnrvsState Of Maharashtra And Anr
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
