Bombay High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Bombay HC Upholds Woman's Possession Decree Over Mahim Room Lock Broken Open, Says Title Is Immaterial

Mohammed Salim Hajisattar Dayatar And Anr.v.Bela Avinash Mehta

Bombay HC Upholds Woman's Possession Decree Over Mahim Room Lock Broken Open, Says Title Is Immaterial. Mohammed Salim Hajisattar Dayatar And Anr. vs Bela Avinash Mehta. Bombay High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the plaintiff proved prior settled possession of the suit premises as on 21 March 2016, in the context of the alleged surrender of tenancy and the rent-receipt evidence.

The court held

The trial court did not err in finding that the plaintiff was in possession on 21 March 2016.

It also directed

The plaintiff was unlawfully dispossessed on 21 March 2016.

The findings were neither perverse nor vitiated by jurisdictional error or material irregularity, so no interference was warranted in revision.

The Court dismissed Civil Revision Application No. 88 of 2026.

The oral prayer for stay of execution and operation of the trial court's decree was rejected as unjustifiable in view of the Court's conclusions.

01Facts

The suit premises, Room No. 12B in Khimani Mansion, Mahim (West), were leased to Mrs. Lilian Fernandes. Under an agreement dated 29 July 2008, the tenancy was transferred to defendant No. 1 (Mohammed Salim) with the landlord's alleged consent. The defendants were in occupation until 2012.

¶ 2.1

The plaintiff (Bela Mehta) alleged that defendant No. 1 surrendered the tenancy to the landlord under a declaration dated 2 July 2012, after which she was inducted at ₹80 per month, and that she occupied the premises thereafter.

¶ 2.2

On 21 March 2016, defendant No. 1 and two associates allegedly broke open the door and placed the defendants' belongings inside. The plaintiff's sister-in-law, Sushma Mehta (PW3), reported the incident and FIR No. 110/2016 was lodged.

¶ 2.3

The plaintiff sued under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 for restoration of possession and mesne profits.

¶ 2.4

The defendants denied the surrender, alleged the declaration was forged, claimed continuous possession, and stated that defendant No. 1 had filed R.A.E. Suit No. 410/2016 before the Small Causes Court.

¶ 2.5

The City Civil Court (S.C. Suit No. 2426 of 2016) returned findings that the plaintiff was in settled possession before 21 March 2016 and was dispossessed without due process, and decreed possession with an inquiry into mesne profits, by judgment dated 23 December 2025.

¶ 2.6, 1

Landlord Rahim Khimani (PW5) testified that defendant No. 1 handed over possession in July 2012 and that he refused the December 2016 tender of arrears by cheque.

¶ 18

The defendants challenged the decree in revision.

¶ 3, 5–8

02Issues

i.1. Whether the plaintiff proved prior settled possession of the suit premises as on 21 March 2016, in the context of the alleged surrender of tenancy and the rent-receipt evidence.

¶ 12, 17–25

ii.2. Whether the plaintiff proved unlawful dispossession on 21 March 2016 without recourse to due process of law.

¶ 28

iii.3. Whether the genuineness of the surrender declaration (dated 2 July 2012) and its stamping can be conclusively determined in a Section 6 suit.

¶ 26

iv.4. Whether the trial court's findings are perverse or reflect a jurisdictional error or material irregularity warranting interference in revisional jurisdiction.

¶ 8–9, 29

03Law Applied

Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 provides a summary remedy to a person unlawfully dispossessed within six months before suit, where the only question is prior possession and unlawful dispossession, and title is immaterial.

¶ 14

The object of Section 6 is to bar dispossession without due process of law.

¶ 13–14

Relying on M.C. Chockalingam v. V. Manickavasagam (AIR 1974 SC 104), a landlord cannot forcibly evict a tenant, and lawful possession and the parties' civil rights are left for a regular suit.

¶ 15

S.R. Ejaz v. T.N. Handloom Weavers' Cooperative Society ((2002) 3 SCC 137) reaffirmed that the law accords legitimacy only to possession taken in due course of law.

¶ 16

Adopting Supdt. & Remembrancer of Legal Affairs, West Bengal v. Anil Kumar Bhunja ((1979) 4 SCC 274), possession is a matter of fact involving power of control and intent to control, tested by whether a person is in general control of the property.

¶ 22

Physical use of the premises as a household is not essential to establish possession.

¶ 21

On revision, the Court applies the limited test of jurisdictional error, material irregularity, or perversity, and does not re-appreciate evidence as an appellate court.

¶ 9, 29

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Specific Relief Act, 1963 Section 6

04Reasoning

The Court first identified the uncontroverted facts and the core dispute: whether the plaintiff took possession in July 2012 and was dispossessed on 21 March 2016.

¶ 12

On possession, the Court relied on the rent receipts issued by the landlord in the plaintiff's name from July 2012 to March 2016 and the landlord's testimony. It contrasted this with the defendants' lack of rent receipts after July 2012, their admitted non-payment, and their inaction until December 2016, which the Court found improbable and inadequately explained.

¶ 18–20

Cross-examination admissions about the premises' location did not defeat possession, since the plaintiff's non-residence was not determinative.

¶ 21

Defence attempts to show that Devendra Mehta took the premises in fact strengthened the plaintiff's case, since the suggestion that Sushma Mehta held a spare key implied control.

¶ 23–24

The plaintiff's custody of original rent receipts for the period when the defendants were admittedly in occupation was treated as a significant circumstance.

¶ 25

On the surrender declaration, the Court held that a Section 6 suit need not determine its genuineness definitively. That question could be addressed in R.A.E. Suit No. 410/2016, and the declaration mattered only because it marked the end of the defendants' jural relationship with the landlord.

¶ 26

On dispossession, prompt reporting to police, the contemporaneous material, and the absence of material contradiction in PW3 and PW4 made the plaintiff's account preponderantly probable.

¶ 28

The Court found no perversity, jurisdictional error, or material irregularity, and held that the findings were justifiable on the evidence.

¶ 29

05Holding

The trial court did not err in finding that the plaintiff was in possession on 21 March 2016.

¶ 27

The plaintiff was unlawfully dispossessed on 21 March 2016.

¶ 28

The findings were neither perverse nor vitiated by jurisdictional error or material irregularity, so no interference was warranted in revision.

¶ 29

The Court dismissed Civil Revision Application No. 88 of 2026.

¶ 30–31

The oral prayer for stay of execution and operation of the trial court's decree was rejected as unjustifiable in view of the Court's conclusions.

¶ 31
Bombay High Court

Original Court PDF

Mohammed Salim Hajisattar Dayatar And Anr.vsBela Avinash Mehta

Bombay High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment