01Facts
The Petitioner, a tenant/occupier and legal heir of the occupant of Commercial Unit No. 16 in "Krishna Dyeing & Printing Works," Old Nagardas Road, Andheri (East), challenged a TAC Order dated 20 May 2026 classifying the building as "C-1" (dilapidated, to be vacated and demolished) and a consequential BMC Notice dated 29 May 2026 under Section 354 of the MMC Act, 1888.
¶ 4, 5, 13The TAC framework derives from the 2014 Bombay High Court order in MCGM v. State of Maharashtra and BMC guidelines of 2018.
¶ 6Following a Section 353(B) notice (24 September 2024), four conflicting structural audit reports (SARs) were submitted: Avon Consulting (C-1, owner's report, July 2025), Aarch Consultants (C-3, for units 16, 20, 21), Tech-Resurgo (C-2A, unit 17), and a further Aarch report (C-3, units 16 and 20).
¶ 7–10The matter was referred to the TAC on 25 August 2025.
¶ 10On 29 October 2025 the TAC resolved that a third-party audit be conducted.
¶ 11Two SARs dated 18 December 2025 followed: SPCE (C-1, commissioned by the owner) and B.J. Mehta (C-2A, commissioned by the Petitioner and other tenants).
¶ 12The TAC inspected the site on 17 February 2026 and, on 20 May 2026, accepted the SPCE report and declared the building C-1.
¶ 13, 33–35The Petitioner had sought a certified copy of the SPCE SAR on 20 February 2026.
¶ 14The Petitioner contended that the SPCE SAR was never supplied, breaching natural justice.
¶ 14The Petitioner contended that the B.J. Mehta SAR was rejected without reasons.
¶ 15, 17The Petitioner contended that reliance on the minority (C-1) reports was arbitrary.
¶ 16The Petitioner contended that the building was repairable and that no segregation of structurally sound portions was undertaken.
¶ 16, 18The Respondent-BMC and Respondent No. 6 (owner) relied on the TAC's expertise and on Shaha Ratanshi Khimji & Sons and Khimjibhai Patadia.
¶ 21–3102Issues
i.1. Whether non-supply of the SPCE SAR to the Petitioner, and non-consideration of the B.J. Mehta SAR, violated the principles of natural justice, rendering the TAC Order invalid.
¶ 14, 36–38ii.2. Whether the TAC Order is non-speaking and arbitrary, having failed to give reasons for rejecting the Petitioner's expert's findings and relying on minority reports.
¶ 15–17, 37–38iii.3. Whether the High Court, in exercise of its writ jurisdiction under Article 226, should substitute its own assessment of the building's structural condition for that of the TAC.
¶ 39–4503Law Applied
The Court applied Sections 353(B) and 354 of the MMC Act, 1888, under which the Corporation may order evacuation and demolition of dangerous structures.
¶ 4, 39The Court applied Section 354(5), together with the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999, which protect tenants' rights notwithstanding demolition.
¶ 29, 44The Court relied on the 2014 Co-ordinate Bench order in MCGM v. State of Maharashtra and the BMC's 2018 guidelines, which require referral of conflicting SARs to the TAC as an expert body.
¶ 6, 39–41The Court followed Shaha Ratanshi Khimji & Sons v. Kumbhar Sons Hotel Pvt. Ltd., (2014) 14 SCC 1, on tenants' rights surviving demolition.
¶ 30The Court followed Tushar Ranglidas Notaria (as summarised in Andheri Purab Paschim Cooperative Housing Society v. MCGM, 2023 SCC OnLine Bom 2522).
¶ 43–44The Court followed Khimjibhai Harjivanbhai Patadia v. MCGM, 2024 SCC OnLine Bom 3709.
¶ 30, 42A writ court will not decide whether a structure is dilapidated or prefer one expert's view over another; interference requires Wednesbury unreasonableness, perversity, fraud, or complete non-application of mind; and mala fides must be pleaded and proved with particulars.
¶ 44(a), (e)–(g)Writ review is confined to the decision-making process, not the merits of the TAC's engineering judgment.
¶ 44(19)Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act. Section 354
Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 Section 14
04Reasoning
The Court first addressed the natural justice challenge and found it misconceived, because the TAC had examined all five SARs, including the SPCE and B.J. Mehta reports, and had recorded reasoned observations on each, including the Petitioner's expert's findings.
¶ 36–38Having found that the TAC had considered the material, the Court did not accept that the non-supply of the SPCE report vitiated the decision.
¶ 38On the reasons challenge, the Court relied on the detailed "Critical Observations / Conclusions" reproduced in the Impugned Order, and treated the TAC's preference for the SPCE report as an expert determination that a writ court cannot revisit.
¶ 37, 38, 44(e)The "minority report" argument was treated as a choice between competing expert opinions, which is outside writ review.
¶ 44(e), 45The Court located the matter within the 2014 framework and the Tushar Notaria principles, holding that the TAC's role is a check against unilateral declarations of dilapidation and that the present record disclosed no fraud, gross perversity, or non-application of mind, nor any absolutist preference for repair reports.
¶ 42–45Tenants' rights were held unaffected by demolition, as they are protected under Section 354(5) and the Rent Control Act.
¶ 29, 44(b)The Court's reasoning on the non-supply of the SPCE SAR rests on the TAC's consideration of the reports rather than on an express finding on whether supply was required; the judgment does not separately address that point.
¶ 36–38On that basis the Court found the Impugned Order and Notice within the four corners of law.
¶ 45–4605Holding
The Court answered Issue 1 and Issue 2 in the negative: the TAC had duly considered all SARs, and the natural justice and non-speaking challenges were not sustained.
¶ 36–38On Issue 3, the Court held that writ interference is not warranted absent perversity, fraud, or non-application of mind, and that the TAC's expert categorization of the building as C-1 must be respected.
¶ 42–45The Court held that the TAC Order dated 20 May 2026 and the Notice dated 29 May 2026 are legal and sustainable.
¶ 46–47All three writ petitions are dismissed, the Rule is discharged, and no costs are awarded.
¶ 48Original Court PDF
Nilay Colour Industries Through Its Proprietor Nilay Jitendra Kapasi Legar Heir Of Jitendra KapasivsThe Assistant Commissioner (K/E Ward) Bmc
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
