01Facts
The petitioner is the widow of Anand Kumar Tyagi, who with his brother Naresh Kumar Tyagi jointly bought a flat in Greater Noida.
¶ 2They took a home loan of Rs. 50,00,000 from HDFC Ergo's lender-linked account, repayable in 240 EMIs of Rs. 45,309.
¶ 4A "Home Credit Assure" policy (No. 2999202171789000000, term 18.07.2018 to 18.07.2023) was taken on both lives to secure the loan. The husband alone paid the EMIs and a premium of Rs. 5,94,890.
¶ 5–6The husband died of cardiac arrest on 20.04.2021.
¶ 7The petitioner claimed the sum insured on 29.06.2021, contending that cardiac arrest is "Myocardial Infarction", a listed Major Medical Illness.
¶ 8The insurer repudiated the claim on 03.07.2021, stating that death from cardiac arrest, respiratory failure and bilateral pneumonitis was not a covered critical illness.
¶ 9This Court, in W.P.(C) 8320/2023 by order dated 14.07.2023, relegated the petitioner to the Insurance Ombudsman.
¶ 10The Ombudsman dismissed the petitioner's complaint by Award dated 26.09.2023 after a virtual hearing, on the ground that she refused to sign a mediation form. She contends she was given only a blank settlement form and was not heard on the merits.
¶ 11–12, 23–27The petitioner has continued paying the EMIs.
¶ 7The insurer contended that it is a private entity, not "State" under Article 12, and that cardiac arrest is distinct from myocardial infarction, relying on a medical opinion of Dr. Basant Kumar.
¶ 28–3102Issues
i.1. Whether a writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable against a private general insurer whose repudiation and the Ombudsman's award are challenged.
¶ 35–44ii.2. Whether cardiac arrest falls within the policy's definition of "Myocardial Infarction", such that the repudiation on the ground of non-coverage is sustainable.
¶ 45–61iii.3. Whether the Ombudsman's Award dated 26.09.2023 is vitiated by breach of the principles of natural justice.
¶ 62–66iv.4. What relief, including the quantum of the insured sum and interest, the petitioner is entitled to.
¶ 67–7103Law Applied
Article 226 of the Constitution permits writs against "any person or authority" performing public duties, as construed in Andi Mukta Sadguru Shree Muktajee Vandas Swami Suvarna Jayanti Mahotsav Smarak Trust v. V.R. Rudani (1989) 2 SCC 691, and Ajay Vijh v. Indian Banks Assn. (2026) SCC OnLine SC 1295.
¶ 38, 41Under LIC v. Asha Goel (2001) 2 SCC 160, writ jurisdiction over insurance claims is discretionary and depends on whether the dispute turns on contractual rights or raises questions of law or constitutional import.
¶ 36–37National Insurance Co. v. Vedic Resorts & Hotels (2023) 12 SCC 823 places the burden on the insurer to prove that an exclusion applies.
¶ 52–54Under the contra proferentem rule from General Assurance Society v. Chandmull Jain, United India Insurance v. Pushpalaya Printers (2004) 3 SCC 694, and Sangrur Sales Corporation (2020) 16 SCC 292, ambiguity in an insurance contract is construed in favour of the insured.
¶ 52–54Contra proferentem cannot manufacture ambiguity where none exists, as cautioned in United India Insurance v. Harchand Rai Chandan Lal (2004) 8 SCC 644 and Oriental Insurance v. Sony Cherian (1999) 6 SCC 451.
¶ 55Canara Bank v. V.K. Awasthy (2005) 6 SCC 321 requires audi alteram partem for quasi-judicial bodies whose decisions carry civil consequences.
¶ 62Rules 13 and 17 of the Insurance Ombudsman Rules, 2017 require the Ombudsman to adjudicate complaints on pleadings and evidence and to pass a reasoned award where mediation fails.
¶ 65–66Mohit Kumar v. Insurance Ombudsman (2023 SCC OnLine Del 7437) and Jasmine Ebenezer Arthur v. HDFC Ergo (2019 SCC OnLine Mad 2246), affirmed in W.A. No. 4035/2019, are followed as persuasive authority.
¶ 42, 57, 60Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Consumer Protection Act, 2019 Section 2
04Reasoning
On maintainability, the Court held that the dispute was a pure question of policy construction on admitted facts, not a contractual claim requiring evidence. The petitioner had also exhausted the alternative forum to which this Court had relegated her.
¶ 37The insurer's status as a private entity did not bar review, because insurers perform quasi-public functions and hold a position of unequal bargaining power.
¶ 40–41, 44On coverage, the Court accepted the insurer's own pleaded position that myocardial infarction results from impaired blood supply to the heart and cardiac arrest from cessation of normal blood supply. Both are "heart attacks" in common parlance, and the policy's definition itself uses that term.
¶ 50–51The insurer had not discharged its burden of showing that cardiac arrest falls outside the coverage. The differences in Dr. Basant Kumar's opinion were not enough to exclude it.
¶ 52–53Under contra proferentem, the Court construed the term in favour of the insured. It stressed that the policy was a loan-protection cover taken to protect the family against the loss of the property on death, and that a narrow reading excluding cardiac arrest, a frequent mode of fatal coronary events, would defeat that purpose.
¶ 54–56The Court declined to treat the lack of a court-appointed expert or a doctor's certificate as fatal to the claim. Expert evidence in Jasmine Ebenezer Arthur was obtained by the court in its discretion, not as a precondition, and the record already sufficed.
¶ 58–60On the Award, the Court held that the Ombudsman, deciding a complaint with civil consequences, had to hear the petitioner on the merits. Her refusal to sign a mediation form did not relieve the Ombudsman of its duty to adjudicate under Rule 17.
¶ 62–66On relief, the Court held that the petitioner, as nominee, was entitled to her late husband's 50% insured interest, Rs. 27,97,445, with interest from the repudiation date. Interest paid on the loan corresponding to that half share was also held recoverable as a direct consequence of the wrongful repudiation.
¶ 68–7105Holding
The writ petition is maintainable against the private insurer under Article 226, and the Court rejected the respondents' objections.
¶ 44, 72Cardiac arrest falls within "Myocardial Infarction" as defined in the policy, so the repudiation letter dated 03.07.2021 is quashed.
¶ 61, 73The Ombudsman's Award dated 26.09.2023 is quashed for breach of natural justice.
¶ 66, 73The insurer (R-1) is directed to pay the petitioner Rs. 27,97,445, being 50% of the insured sum, with 9% per annum interest from 03.07.2021 until payment, and Rs. 5,08,176 as the loan interest component, together with the interest component paid on that portion thereafter until actual payment.
¶ 69, 71, 74The petition and pending applications are disposed of in these terms.
¶ 75Original Court PDF
Smt. Sushma TyagivsM/S Hdfc Ergo General Insurance Company Limited, Thrugh Its Director & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
