Delhi High CourtArbitration and MediationContract Law

Delhi HC Denies Post-Award Protection for Rs 38.9 Crore Deposits Despite Strong Case, Citing 'Rare And Compelling' Test

Mr Kimti Lall Jainv.Suez Water Technologies And Solutions & Ors.

Delhi HC Denies Post-Award Protection for Rs 38.9 Crore Deposits Despite Strong Case, Citing 'Rare And Compelling' Test. Mr Kimti Lall Jain vs Suez Water Technologies And Solutions   & Ors.. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether an unsuccessful party to arbitration may invoke Section 9 of the Act post-award, and whether the petitioner has established the "rare and compelling" circumstances required for such relief.

The court held

The petition is maintainable under Section 9 for an unsuccessful party, and the petitioner established a strong prima facie case, favourable balance of convenience and risk of irreparable injury concerning the four deposits (₹38,91,62,075 in court, relating to Projects 323, 707, 195 and 222), which constitute PRM.

It also directed

The petitioner failed to demonstrate a "rare and compelling" case under Home Care Retail and Thor Ventures so as to warrant interim protection.

The interim prayer is denied.

Respondents are granted three weeks to file a reply, with rejoinder before the next date, and the matter is listed on 14.12.2026 along with O.M.P.(COMM) 355/2026.

01Facts

The petitioner and his family promoted Driplex Water Engineering Pvt. Ltd. (Respondent No. 3) and Driplex Water Engineering International Pvt. Ltd. (Respondent No. 4).

¶ 2

Under the Share Purchase Agreements, Framework Agreement and Shareholder Agreements dated 04.12.2015, the Suez group acquired these companies in two tranches: CD-1 (76%) on 01.03.2016 and CD-2 (24%) on 01.03.2019.

¶ 2–4

Past Retention Money ("PRM") owed to the target companies was to be recovered by the Final Completion Date, failing which Clause 10.6 of the Framework Agreement applied.

¶ 3

On 01.03.2019, PRM remained unrecovered, and the parties executed a Supplementary Framework Agreement ("SFA") providing a 49-month recovery term (Clause 2.3.1), an obligation on the Suez entities to issue powers of attorney ("PoA") (Clause 2.3.2), and a profit-sharing ratio (Clause 2.3.2A).

¶ 5–6, 39

A General Agreement dated 17.05.2021 provided for one-year PoAs, renewable while PRM remained unrecovered. PoAs were issued on 01.08.2021, expired on 31.03.2023, and were not renewed.

¶ 6

The petitioner obtained favourable awards in Projects 707, 195, 222, 323 and 212, and third parties deposited ₹38,91,62,075 in court under Section 34/36 proceedings, of which one deposit (Project 195) was made on 22.05.2023.

¶ 7, 41, 46

Arbitral proceedings followed; the Tribunal rejected Claim Nos. 1, 2 and 8 and partly allowed others by award dated 18.04.2026, corrected on 08.06.2026.

¶ 8

The petitioner's Section 34 challenge is pending as O.M.P.(COMM) 355/2026.

¶ 8

The petitioner sought, under Section 9, deposit or bank guarantee of ₹1,28,79,98,675 (deposits with interest), a restraint on alienation to the extent of ₹156,46,04,632 (Claim No. 1), restraint on dilution, and disclosure on oath.

¶ 1, 10

Respondents contended that the Tribunal found entitlement to PRM expired on 31.03.2023, that Claim No. 1 was contingent and speculative, and that no rare and compelling case existed.

¶ 27–31

02Issues

i.1. Whether an unsuccessful party to arbitration may invoke Section 9 of the Act post-award, and whether the petitioner has established the "rare and compelling" circumstances required for such relief.

¶ 12, 27, 52–53

ii.2. Whether the petitioner has established a strong prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable prejudice for interim protection over the four deposits.

¶ 37, 45, 51

iii.3. Whether the four deposits constitute PRM in which the petitioner is entitled to a share, notwithstanding the Tribunal's findings on expiry of the arrangement.

¶ 44, 46–47, 49

03Law Applied

Section 9(1)(ii) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, read with the Supreme Court's decision in Home Care Retail Marts Pvt. Ltd. v. Haresh N. Sanghavi (2026 SCC OnLine SC 670), holds that an unsuccessful party may seek Section 9 relief post-award, but only in "rare and compelling circumstances" to prevent irreparable prejudice and preserve the efficacy of the Section 34 challenge.

¶ 12, 52

Essar House (P) Ltd. v. Arcelor Mittal Nippon Steel India Ltd. (2022) 20 SCC 178 sets out the triple test of prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable injury, and requires a higher threshold for unsuccessful parties.

¶ 52, 59–60

Thor Ventures (OPC) Pvt. Ltd. v. Nyeq Technologies Pvt. Ltd. (2026 SCC OnLine Del 8483) applies these tests in the post-award Section 9 context.

¶ 52

Clauses 2.3.1, 2.3.2 and 2.3.2A of the SFA and the General Agreement govern the contractual regime for recovery of PRM, PoAs and profit-sharing.

¶ 39, 47

Oral submissions cannot override written agreements.

¶ 39, 47

Swiber (Bombay HC) and Afcons (Bombay HC) were cited on the scope of post-award relief.

¶ 26, 30

Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 9Section 34Section 36

Specific Relief Act, 1963 Section 14Section 16

04Reasoning

The petition is maintainable, since an unsuccessful party may invoke Section 9 post-award.

¶ 52

The inquiry is confined to PRM not recovered by 01.03.2019, and the questions of whether the 29-month PoA delay extended the Term, and whether the unrecovered PRM formed part of the sale consideration, are left to the Section 34 proceedings.

¶ 37, 41, 44

On the prima facie case, the four deposits were undisputed, were made in proceedings arising from awards obtained through the petitioner's efforts, and fall within PRM under the SPA, FA, SFA and GA.

¶ 46–47

The respondents' "top-up payment" characterisation is rejected for want of any supporting document.

¶ 46–47

On the undenied Director's Reports and financial statements, Respondents 3 and 4 face precarious finances, creating a real risk of dissipation or restructuring.

¶ 50

The petitioner's submissions are essentially a challenge to the merits of the award, and the Section 34 remedy is not compromised because the Holding Company has been arrayed as a party.

¶ 53

Although preservation of the deposits "may be a good ground," the threshold of "rare and compelling" circumstances, as framed in Home Care Retail and Thor Ventures, is not met.

¶ 53

05Holding

The petition is maintainable under Section 9 for an unsuccessful party, and the petitioner established a strong prima facie case, favourable balance of convenience and risk of irreparable injury concerning the four deposits (₹38,91,62,075 in court, relating to Projects 323, 707, 195 and 222), which constitute PRM.

¶ 46–47, 51

The petitioner failed to demonstrate a "rare and compelling" case under Home Care Retail and Thor Ventures so as to warrant interim protection.

¶ 53–54

The interim prayer is denied.

¶ 55

Respondents are granted three weeks to file a reply, with rejoinder before the next date, and the matter is listed on 14.12.2026 along with O.M.P.(COMM) 355/2026.

¶ 56–57
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Mr Kimti Lall JainvsSuez Water Technologies And Solutions & Ors.

Delhi High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment