01Facts
The plaintiff, a proprietor of a construction and interior firm, sued the defendant, the Principal of Maitri English School, for ₹45,01,317 with 18% interest.
¶ 1The plaintiff relied on a construction agreement dated 28.09.2020 for a school building on Site No. 33/1, Narayanapura, K.R. Puram, and a final bill dated 20.03.2021.
¶ 3–4The plaintiff alleged that he completed the work in March 2021, that the defendant postponed payment, and that she issued and then retrieved three cheques.
¶ 4–5The plaintiff also sought an injunction against dispossession.
¶ 6The defendant denied executing the agreement and her signature on it, asserting an oral arrangement instead.
¶ 7–10The defendant admitted payments but said the plaintiff abandoned the Western Block in November 2020 and never began the Eastern Block.
¶ 7–10The Commercial Court found that the plaintiff admitted receiving ₹80,00,000 as of 01.03.2021 without disclosing it in the plaint or evidence affidavit.
¶ 13, 17The Commercial Court found that the agreement was unregistered and insufficiently stamped, that the attestation evidence was deficient, and that the Eastern Block was incomplete.
¶ 14–16The suit was dismissed with costs.
¶ 13–19The appellant's grounds refer to a payment of ₹83,00,000 and a claimed work value of ₹2,57,54,800 against completed work of ₹1,28,01,317 (Ex. P.30).
¶ 2202Issues
i.1. Whether the appellant-plaintiff has made out any ground warranting interference with the judgment and decree dated 07.11.2024 passed by the Commercial Court in Com.O.S. No. 1148/2024.
¶ 23ii.2. Whether the plaintiff established the due execution of the construction agreement dated 28.09.2020.
¶ 24–25iii.3. Whether the plaintiff established the completion and valuation of the work and the amount remaining due, based on the final bill and ledger entries.
¶ 26–29iv.4. Whether the plaintiff's suppression of the ₹80,00,000 receipt disentitles him to relief.
¶ 3003Law Applied
The court applied the appellate jurisdiction under Section 13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015.
p. 1The plaintiff bore the burden to prove the contractual basis of the claim, the work actually executed, and the balance payable.
¶ 24Entries in books of account, even if regularly maintained, cannot alone fasten liability and must be supported by evidence of the underlying transaction, as laid down in Chandradhar Goswami v. Gauhati Bank Ltd. (1966 SCC OnLine SC 255).
¶ 28Sections 33 and 34 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 apply to impounding insufficiently stamped instruments.
¶ 11, Issue (iv)An unregistered and insufficiently stamped agreement is a relevant defect.
¶ 19A litigant seeking equitable relief must approach the court with clean hands.
¶ 30No statutory provision governing proof of disputed signatures is cited; the failure to obtain an expert comparison was treated as significant.
¶ 15, 25Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Section 13
KARNATAKA STAMP ACT, 1957 Section 33Section 34
04Reasoning
The plaintiff failed to prove due execution of the agreement. The defendant specifically denied her signature, and the attesting witness PW-2 admitted that the other attesting witness was absent when he signed. The plaintiff also did not seek an expert comparison with an admitted signature. Because execution was not proved, the contractual basis of the claim failed.
¶ 25Even if the agreement were accepted, the plaintiff's own evidence undermined the claim. The final bill included Eastern Block work, but PW-1 admitted that this block was incomplete, and photographs corroborated this.
¶ 26Bills and ledger entries cannot themselves prove that work was executed, consistent with Chandradhar Goswami.
¶ 27–28No measurements or valuation evidence was produced, so the ₹45,01,317 claim could not be quantified.
¶ 28–29The alleged stock of materials worth over ₹25,00,000 was unsupported by evidence and could not prove the work done or the sum due.
¶ 31–32The plaintiff admitted receiving ₹80,00,000 but omitted it from the plaint and affidavit without explanation. This was treated as material suppression bearing directly on the claim, and the plaintiff was held not to have approached the court with clean hands.
¶ 30The Commercial Court's appreciation of evidence was found sound and free from perversity.
¶ 3205Holding
The appellate court answered the sole point in the negative. The plaintiff failed to establish the execution of the construction agreement, the completion and valuation of the work, or any balance due.
¶ 32–33The Commercial Court's findings were not perverse and did not warrant interference. The appeal is dismissed. The judgment and decree dated 07.11.2024 in Com.O.S. No. 1148/2024 are affirmed, pending I.As. are disposed of, and no order as to costs is made.
¶ 33 · Order (i)–(iii)Original Court PDF
MR. VENKATA RAMANA CvsMRS. RAJALAKSHMI,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
