Facts
The Anand Niketan Cooperative Housing Society Ltd. ("Society"), registered in 1956, provides "Watch and Ward" (security) services to its members, funded through subscriptions approved in various Annual General Meetings (AGMs) since 1993
Source reference: p.2-3In 2016, following complaints by certain residents alleging financial irregularities and illegal security charges, the Registrar of Co-operative Societies (RCS) issued a Show Cause Notice and appointed an Inquiry Officer
Source reference: p.3, para 5The Society's challenge to these proceedings led to a revision before the Financial Commissioner, which remained pending for years without an order
Source reference: p.4, para 6Despite this, a subsequent order dated October 30, 2017, appointed a new Inquiry Officer to investigate security services, club accounts, and bye-law violations
Source reference: p.5, para 8Cross-petitions were filed: the Society sought to quash the inquiry order
Source reference: p.2, para 3residents sought the winding up of the Managing Committee and fresh elections
Source reference: p.2, para 4During proceedings, the Anand Niketan Residents Welfare Association (ANRWA) passed a resolution in 2025 stating it lacked the infrastructure and funds to manage security and requested the Society to continue providing those services
Source reference: p.9-10, para 21Issues
1. Whether the appointment of an Inquiry Officer to investigate "Watch and Ward" services and Society accounts was valid given the RWA’s inability to provide such services and the Society’s Bye-laws
Source reference: p.5, 9-102. Whether the "Watch and Ward" charges constitute valid Society dues under the regulatory framework
Source reference: p.7, para 123. Whether the Managing Committee should be wound up based on the complaints of irregularities
Source reference: p.2, 5Law Applied
The Court applied the Delhi Co-operative Societies Act, 2003, specifically Section 61 regarding the Registrar’s power to order inspection and inquiry
Source reference: p.8, para 15It interpreted the Society’s Bye-laws, specifically Bye-law 3(iv) (welfare activities) and Bye-law 10(e) (maintenance of "Watch and Ward" funds)
Source reference: p.6, para 11The Court also relied on the Delhi Co-operative Societies Rules, 2007 regarding the requirement for independent auditors
Source reference: p.11, para 26Reasoning
The Court observed that the Society’s Bye-laws explicitly permit the collection of funds for "Watch and Ward" services and welfare activities
Source reference: p.6, para 11It noted that the RCS had clarified as early as 2000 that such charges constitute "Society’s dues"
Source reference: p.7, para 12The Court emphasized that the ANRWA had formally resolved its inability to handle colony security due to financial and infrastructural constraints, requesting the Society to continue its services
Source reference: p.10, para 21The Court reasoned that the impugned inquiry order was practically unimplementable and would cause "serious prejudice" to residents by disturbing a long-standing arrangement supported by the majority and the RWA
Source reference: p.10-11, para 23It held that the complaints of a few members should not disrupt the functioning of the entire colony
Source reference: p.10, para 23However, the Court mandated that the RCS must continue to monitor audit reports to ensure transparency and that the Society must employ independent auditors as per the 2007 Rules
Source reference: p.11, para 25-26Holding
The Court allowed W.P.(C) 927/2018 and disposed of W.P.(C) 7396/2021. It quashed the inquiry order dated October 30, 2017, and set aside the recommendations of the inquiry officer
The Court held that the Society shall continue managing "Watch and Ward" services in collaboration with the ANRWA
Source reference: p.11, para 24The RCS was directed to supervise the Society’s functioning and audit reports in accordance with law, but prohibited from taking action based on the 2017 inquiry report
Source reference: p.11, para 25, 27Additionally, the Court ordered the RWA to reinstate the membership of resident Mr. W.S. Chona as a full member without further payment, conditional upon maintaining peace and harmony
Source reference: p.11, para 28Original Court PDF
Shri Nar Singh Awatar & Ors.vsThe Registrar Of Co-Operative Societies & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in