01Facts
The petitioner (defendant) and the respondent (plaintiff) are siblings.
¶ 4 · p. 2The respondent filed O.S. No. 147 of 2021 in the Additional District Court, Tiruvannamalai, seeking recovery of money with interest on the basis of a promissory note.
¶ 5 · pp. 2–3The defendant filed a written statement taking a stand reproduced as a scanned image in the judgment; content not reproduced in the text.
¶ 6 · p. 3Issues were framed.
At the stage of cross-examination of PW1, the defendant filed I.A. No. 4 of 2026 under Order VIII Rule 9 CPC to file an additional written statement, which took a different stand, also reproduced as a scanned image; content not reproduced in the text.
¶ 7 · pp. 3–4By order dated 19.9.2026, the trial court dismissed the application on the ground that the additional written statement completely disowned the original plea.
¶ 8 · p. 4The defendant challenged that order under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 1, 8 · pp. 1–2, 402Issues
i.1. Whether the trial court erred in dismissing the defendant's application under Order VIII Rule 9 CPC for filing an additional written statement that takes a plea completely different from, and virtually disowns, the original written statement.
¶ 8 · p. 4 · ¶ 11 · p. 5ii.2. Whether a defendant may raise inconsistent pleas in an additional written statement, or whether such inconsistency is impermissible where it amounts to retracting the earlier stand.
¶ 9 · p. 403Law Applied
The Court applied Order VIII Rule 9 CPC, under which a defendant seeks leave to file an additional written statement, as the procedural vehicle for the application.
¶ 2 · p. 2 · ¶ 7 · p. 3A defendant is entitled to raise inconsistent pleas, but may not, under the guise of an additional written statement, completely change the stand or retract from the earlier stand.
¶ 9 · p. 4The Court made a reference to the Supreme Court's decision in Mondira Ghosh v. Chaitali Ghosh, 2026 (4) MLJ 244, as a "useful reference," without extracting its ratio in the order.
¶ 10 · p. 5The petition was entertained under the supervisory jurisdiction of Article 227 of the Constitution, which was used to test the correctness of the impugned order.
¶ 1 · p. 2 · ¶ 11 · p. 504Reasoning
The Court distinguished between permissible inconsistent pleading and impermissible retraction. It accepted that a defendant may plead inconsistent positions, but found that the defendant here did not merely add an alternative plea.
¶ 11 · p. 5The stand in the additional written statement was "mutually destructive" of the stand in the original written statement.
¶ 11 · p. 5Because the amendment sought to replace the original defence rather than supplement it, the trial court's dismissal of the Order VIII Rule 9 application was held to be correct.
¶ 11 · p. 5The Court did not revisit the factual content of either pleading, and its reasoning rests on the characterisation of the two stands as irreconcilable.
05Holding
The Court held that a defendant may raise inconsistent pleas but cannot, through an additional written statement, completely change or retract the original stand.
¶ 9 · p. 4Applying this principle, the additional plea in I.A. No. 4 of 2026 was mutually destructive of the original written statement, so the trial court rightly dismissed the application.
¶ 11 · p. 5No interference under Article 227 was warranted.
¶ 11 · p. 5The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed, the order dated 19.9.2026 in I.A. No. 4 of 2026 in O.S. No. 147 of 2021 is sustained, and the connected CMP No. 31132 of 2026 is dismissed.
¶ 12 · p. 5Original Court PDF
ElamuruganvsRani
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
