Madras High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceConstitutional Law

Defendant may plead inconsistent defences, but an additional written statement under Order VIII Rule 9 cannot completely retract the original stand.

Elamuruganv.Rani

Defendant may plead inconsistent defences, but an additional written statement under Order VIII Rule 9 cannot completely retract the original stand.. Elamurugan vs Rani. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the trial court erred in dismissing the defendant's application under Order VIII Rule 9 CPC for filing an additional written statement that takes a plea completely different from, and virtually disowns, the original written statement.

The court held

The Court held that a defendant may raise inconsistent pleas but cannot, through an additional written statement, completely change or retract the original stand.

It also directed

Applying this principle, the additional plea in I.A. No. 4 of 2026 was mutually destructive of the original written statement, so the trial court rightly dismissed the application.

No interference under Article 227 was warranted.

The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed, the order dated 19.9.2026 in I.A. No. 4 of 2026 in O.S. No. 147 of 2021 is sustained, and the connected CMP No. 31132 of 2026 is dismissed.

01Facts

The petitioner (defendant) and the respondent (plaintiff) are siblings.

¶ 4 · p. 2

The respondent filed O.S. No. 147 of 2021 in the Additional District Court, Tiruvannamalai, seeking recovery of money with interest on the basis of a promissory note.

¶ 5 · pp. 2–3

The defendant filed a written statement taking a stand reproduced as a scanned image in the judgment; content not reproduced in the text.

¶ 6 · p. 3

Issues were framed.

At the stage of cross-examination of PW1, the defendant filed I.A. No. 4 of 2026 under Order VIII Rule 9 CPC to file an additional written statement, which took a different stand, also reproduced as a scanned image; content not reproduced in the text.

¶ 7 · pp. 3–4

By order dated 19.9.2026, the trial court dismissed the application on the ground that the additional written statement completely disowned the original plea.

¶ 8 · p. 4

The defendant challenged that order under Article 227 of the Constitution.

¶ 1, 8 · pp. 1–2, 4

02Issues

i.1. Whether the trial court erred in dismissing the defendant's application under Order VIII Rule 9 CPC for filing an additional written statement that takes a plea completely different from, and virtually disowns, the original written statement.

¶ 8 · p. 4 · ¶ 11 · p. 5

ii.2. Whether a defendant may raise inconsistent pleas in an additional written statement, or whether such inconsistency is impermissible where it amounts to retracting the earlier stand.

¶ 9 · p. 4

03Law Applied

The Court applied Order VIII Rule 9 CPC, under which a defendant seeks leave to file an additional written statement, as the procedural vehicle for the application.

¶ 2 · p. 2 · ¶ 7 · p. 3

A defendant is entitled to raise inconsistent pleas, but may not, under the guise of an additional written statement, completely change the stand or retract from the earlier stand.

¶ 9 · p. 4

The Court made a reference to the Supreme Court's decision in Mondira Ghosh v. Chaitali Ghosh, 2026 (4) MLJ 244, as a "useful reference," without extracting its ratio in the order.

¶ 10 · p. 5

The petition was entertained under the supervisory jurisdiction of Article 227 of the Constitution, which was used to test the correctness of the impugned order.

¶ 1 · p. 2 · ¶ 11 · p. 5

04Reasoning

The Court distinguished between permissible inconsistent pleading and impermissible retraction. It accepted that a defendant may plead inconsistent positions, but found that the defendant here did not merely add an alternative plea.

¶ 11 · p. 5

The stand in the additional written statement was "mutually destructive" of the stand in the original written statement.

¶ 11 · p. 5

Because the amendment sought to replace the original defence rather than supplement it, the trial court's dismissal of the Order VIII Rule 9 application was held to be correct.

¶ 11 · p. 5

The Court did not revisit the factual content of either pleading, and its reasoning rests on the characterisation of the two stands as irreconcilable.

05Holding

The Court held that a defendant may raise inconsistent pleas but cannot, through an additional written statement, completely change or retract the original stand.

¶ 9 · p. 4

Applying this principle, the additional plea in I.A. No. 4 of 2026 was mutually destructive of the original written statement, so the trial court rightly dismissed the application.

¶ 11 · p. 5

No interference under Article 227 was warranted.

¶ 11 · p. 5

The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed, the order dated 19.9.2026 in I.A. No. 4 of 2026 in O.S. No. 147 of 2021 is sustained, and the connected CMP No. 31132 of 2026 is dismissed.

¶ 12 · p. 5
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

ElamuruganvsRani

Madras High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment