01Facts
The suit property originally belonged to one V.P. Venkatachala Mudali, whose second wife (Sakkubaiammal) and daughter (Santhakumari) are the plaintiffs in O.S. No. 81 of 2001.
¶ 2 · p. 4A partition suit, O.S. No. 92 of 1960, was decreed in favour of the plaintiffs' side, and possession was delivered through E.P. No. 125 of 1968 on 06.05.1968.
¶ 2 · p. 4The defendant in O.S. No. 81/2001 denied this, asserting that he purchased the property under two sale deeds dated 17.05.1968 from vendors who had obtained possession under E.P. No. 126 of 1966.
¶ 2.1 · p. 5In O.S. No. 538 of 2001, the plaintiff (the defendant's counterpart) sought a permanent injunction, claiming title and possession through the same 1968 sale deeds and alleging interference since 01.11.1999.
¶ 3 · p. 6The defendants in that suit contended that the suit item (68 cents in Old S. No. 56/2, New S. No. 1/6) was allotted to them in final decree proceedings in I.A. No. 158 of 1963.
¶ 3.1 · pp. 6-7The trial court framed issues on title, possession, adverse possession and injunction, decreed O.S. No. 81/2001 and dismissed O.S. No. 538/2001 by common judgment dated 29.09.2004.
¶ 4 · pp. 7-8 · ¶ 5 · p. 8On appeal (A.S. Nos. 1 and 3 of 2005), the First Appellate Court framed a single point, whether the appeals should be allowed.
¶ 6 · p. 8By common judgment dated 11.04.2008, the First Appellate Court granted the plaintiff in O.S. No. 81/2001 declaration for 11 cents and granted the O.S. No. 538/2001 plaintiff injunction for 56 cents, relying on an additional document, Ex.B.16 (Land Survey Register).
¶ 7 · p. 9Both sides filed second appeals.
¶ 7 · p. 902Issues
i.1. Whether the First Appellate Court's reversal of the trial court's findings, relying on the additional document Ex.B.16, is sustainable in law, particularly where Ex.B.16 does not establish possession by either party.
¶ 8(i) · p. 9ii.2. Whether the First Appellate Court failed to assign sufficient and cogent reasons while reversing the trial court, vitiating its judgment.
¶ 8(ii) · p. 9iii.3. Whether the First Appellate Court failed to appreciate the oral and documentary evidence in proper perspective.
¶ 8(iii) · p. 9iv.4. Whether the First Appellate Court framed proper points for determination as required by Order XLI Rule 31 CPC, and whether it complied with Order XLI Rules 27 and 28 CPC in admitting and acting upon Ex.B.16 without taking evidence on it.
¶ 15-16 · pp. 14-1603Law Applied
Order XLI Rule 31 CPC requires an appellate judgment to state the points for determination, the decision thereon, and the reasons for the decision.
¶ 16 · p. 15Order XLI Rule 27 CPC empowers the appellate court to receive additional documents.
¶ 16 · pp. 14-16Order XLI Rule 28 CPC requires that, upon receipt of such a document, the appellate court either take the evidence itself or direct a subordinate court to do so.
¶ 16 · pp. 14-16The Court did not cite any reported precedent; the legal principles stated are drawn directly from the statutory provisions of Order XLI Rules 27, 28 and 31 CPC.
Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
The Court found that the First Appellate Court framed only one point, whether the appeals should be allowed, which did not meet the requirement of Order XLI Rule 31.
¶ 15-16 · pp. 14-15The Court held that the First Appellate Court admitted Ex.B.16 but neither discussed it nor gave the opposite party an opportunity to dispute it, and did not take evidence on it as required by Order XLI Rule 28.
¶ 15-16 · pp. 14-15Because the reversal rested on this unexamined document, the Court held that the reasons for overturning the trial court's findings were not stated and that the judgment was not in conformity with the CPC.
¶ 16 · p. 15Having found these procedural defects, the Court did not decide the merits of title or possession. It treated the substantial questions of law (paras. 8(i)-(iii)) as subsumed within these defects.
¶ 15-16 · pp. 14-15The parties' competing claims, both traced to the 1960 partition decree, were left for determination on a proper record.
¶ 13 · p. 13 · ¶ 14 · pp. 13-1405Holding
The Court answered the substantial questions in the affirmative to the extent that the First Appellate Court's judgment is vitiated for non-compliance with Order XLI Rules 28 and 31 CPC.
¶ 15-16 · pp. 14-16The second appeals are allowed. The common judgment and decrees dated 11.04.2008 in A.S. Nos. 1 and 3 of 2005 (Subordinate Judge, Tiruvallur) are set aside, and the matter is remanded to the First Appellate Court to frame proper points for determination, afford both parties an opportunity to address Ex.B.16, and decide the appeals afresh in accordance with law.
¶ 17 · pp. 16-17The First Appellate Court is directed to dispose of the appeals within four months of receipt of the judgment, and no order as to costs is made.
¶ 17 · pp. 16-17Original Court PDF
V.SHANTHA KUMARI(died)vsE.BALARAMAN(Died)
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
