Madras High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceConstitutional Law

Non-filing of reply to written statement is no admission; reply is not a pleading under Order VI.

P.S.Arunrajv.P.K.Subramaniam (Died)

Non-filing of reply to written statement is no admission; reply is not a pleading under Order VI.. P.S.Arunraj vs P.K.Subramaniam (Died). Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the trial court's refusal to permit the plaintiffs to file a reply statement to the written statement warranted interference under Article 227 of the Constitution, i.e., whether the order was perverse

The court held

Non-filing of a reply statement does not amount to an admission, a reply is not mandatory under Order VI Rule 1 CPC, and the plaintiffs can contest the written statement during cross-examination and final arguments

It also directed

The impugned order dated 14.08.2026 was not perverse and was sustained, and the civil revision petition was dismissed. The II Additional District Munsif, Erode, was directed to dispose of O.S. No. 86 of 2015 within four months from receipt of the order. No costs were awarded, and C.M.P. No. 30987 of 2026 was closed

01Facts

The petitioners (plaintiffs) filed O.S. No. 86 of 2015 before the II Additional District Court, Erode, seeking partition and allotment of a 2/9th share in the suit property

¶ 3

Defendants 1 and 3 filed their written statement in 2015, and issues were framed in 2016

¶ 4

The case remained pending for more than ten years without progress, and the trial had not commenced

¶ 4 · ¶ 7

The plaintiffs filed I.A. No. 5 of 2026 under Order VIII Rule 9 CPC seeking leave to file a reply statement to the written statement. The trial court dismissed the application by order dated 14.08.2026, mainly because of the long delay in the suit

¶ 3 · ¶ 4

The plaintiffs challenged that order in this revision under Article 227 of the Constitution

¶ 1

02Issues

i.1. Whether the trial court's refusal to permit the plaintiffs to file a reply statement to the written statement warranted interference under Article 227 of the Constitution, i.e., whether the order was perverse

¶ 2 · ¶ 5

ii.2. Whether the plaintiffs' failure to file a reply statement amounts to an admission of the averments in the written statement

¶ 5

iii.3. Whether the plaintiffs' right to contest the averments in the written statement is adequately protected without a reply statement

¶ 6

03Law Applied

The Court relied on Order VI Rule 1 CPC, which recognises only the plaint and the written statement as pleadings, and found no provision in Order VI treating a reply statement as part of the pleadings

¶ 5

The Court applied the principle that denial of averments under the CPC is contemplated only up to the filing of the written statement, not beyond it, so non-filing of a reply does not operate as an admission

¶ 5

The Court relied on the procedural safeguard that averments in a written statement are contested through cross-examination and final arguments

¶ 6

The scope of interference under Article 227 was addressed in terms of perversity, i.e., the impugned order must be shown to suffer from perversity before the High Court will interfere

¶ 5

The Court did not cite any precedent and did not expressly discuss Order VIII Rule 9 CPC, under which the application was filed

04Reasoning

The Court held that the pleadings stage closes with the written statement under Order VI Rule 1, so the plaintiffs had no mandatory obligation to file a reply

¶ 5

Because a reply is not a pleading, its absence cannot be treated as an admission of the defendants' averments

¶ 5

The Court considered the plaintiffs' ability to challenge the written statement through cross-examination and final arguments to be an adequate safeguard, which made a reply "not a strict necessity"

¶ 6

The Court found no perversity in the trial court's order. It also took into account that the suit was filed in 2015 and the trial had not begun

¶ 5 · ¶ 7

On this basis, the Court held that interference was unwarranted and that its observations on the safeguards would sufficiently protect the plaintiffs' interests. The trial court was directed to consider the plaintiffs' stand on the written statement's assertions while deciding the suit

¶ 6 · ¶ 7

05Holding

Non-filing of a reply statement does not amount to an admission, a reply is not mandatory under Order VI Rule 1 CPC, and the plaintiffs can contest the written statement during cross-examination and final arguments

¶ 5 · ¶ 6

The impugned order dated 14.08.2026 was not perverse and was sustained, and the civil revision petition was dismissed. The II Additional District Munsif, Erode, was directed to dispose of O.S. No. 86 of 2015 within four months from receipt of the order. No costs were awarded, and C.M.P. No. 30987 of 2026 was closed

¶ 7
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

P.S.ArunrajvsP.K.Subramaniam (Died)

Madras High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment