CAT - ['Delhi']Employment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

Delayed Delhi Police Recruits Get Notional Pay Parity With 2010 Batchmates, Arrears Only From 2011 Joining

MOHIT SHARMAv.COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

Delayed Delhi Police Recruits Get Notional Pay Parity With 2010 Batchmates, Arrears Only From 2011 Joining. MOHIT SHARMA vs COMMISSIONER OF POLICE. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether applicants, granted notional seniority from 10.05.2010 on account of administrative delay in joining, are entitled to notional pay fixation, increments, and MACP benefits from that date at par with their batchmates

The court held

The Tribunal held that the present OA is squarely covered by Anil Kumar (O.A. No. 1329/2025) and is disposed of in those terms, directing the respondents to take a decision accordingly

It also directed

The directions incorporated by reference from Anil Kumar include: quashing of the impugned remarks and any order inapplicable to the applicant; notional pay re-fixation at par with batchmates; arrears calculated from actual joining; MACP from 01.05.2020 after counting notional service; NPS contribution for the notional period; and no interest on arrears. Compliance is required within 90 days of receipt of a certified copy. The M.A. for a single OA was allowed. Pending MAs stand disposed of and there is no order as to costs.

01Facts

Eight Head Constables (Exe.) applied under the Delhi Police Constable (Exe.) Male 2009 (Phase-II) recruitment. Due to administrative delays, they could not join with the first batch on 10.05.2010 and joined only on 10.10.2011

¶ 4

The respondents published an Inter-Se Seniority List on 03.06.2015, fixing the applicants' seniority from 10.05.2010 at par with their batchmates

¶ 4

However, the respondents denied notional pay fixation, increments, and first MACP benefits from that date

¶ 4

Applicant No. 1's representation dated 21.09.2026 was rejected by order dated 07.10.2026, relying on PHQ Letter dated 10.03.2026, MHA Letter dated 15.01.2026, and DOPT Letter dated 29.12.2025

¶ 3(IV) · ¶ 4

The applicants sought quashing of these communications, notional pay fixation and consequential benefits from 10.05.2010, MACP from 01.05.2020, NPS contribution, and interest at 12%

¶ 3(I)–(V)

Applicants relied on O.A. No. 1329/2025 (Anil Kumar, decided 21.11.2025), which followed O.A. No. 3371/2018 (decided 15.04.2023) and the Delhi High Court's decision in Director of Education v. Smt. Krishna Kumari, WP(C) No. 13987/2009

¶ 5

The respondents' counsel did not dispute that the present OA is identical to Anil Kumar

¶ 6

The judgment does not reproduce the contents of the PHQ, MHA, or DOPT letters.

02Issues

i.1. Whether applicants, granted notional seniority from 10.05.2010 on account of administrative delay in joining, are entitled to notional pay fixation, increments, and MACP benefits from that date at par with their batchmates

¶ 4 · ¶ 7

ii.2. Whether the PHQ Letter dated 10.03.2026, MHA Letter dated 15.01.2026, and DOPT Letter dated 29.12.2025 are applicable so as to bar such notional benefits

¶ 3(V) · ¶ 4

03Law Applied

The Tribunal relied principally on the Delhi High Court's ruling in Director of Education v. Smt. Krishna Kumari, WP(C) No. 13987/2009, which holds that once notional seniority is granted from a past date, that fiction must be given full effect, including for pay fixation, so that pay is fixed as if the employee had joined on that date, with entitlement to increments, wage revisions, and Assured Progression benefits

¶ 16

The Tribunal also applied the consistent approach in O.A. No. 1329/2025 (Anil Kumar) and O.A. No. 3371/2018, which treated the same principle as governing identically placed Delhi Police recruits

¶ 5 · ¶ 7

The Tribunal further relied on the principle that a case identical in facts and issues to a previously decided case should be disposed of in terms of that decision

¶ 8

The PHQ, MHA, and DOPT letters are referenced as the respondents' basis for denial but their legal content is not analysed in the judgment

¶ 4

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19

04Reasoning

The Tribunal found the applicants were similarly situated to the applicant in Anil Kumar, that the issue was identical, and that the respondents did not contest this

¶ 6 · ¶ 7

Since the respondents had conceded retrospective seniority from 10.05.2010, the Krishna Kumari principle required that the same date be given effect for pay fixation, as the respondents' position created the anomaly of service counted for seniority but not for pay

¶ 4 · ¶ 16

Having aligned the present case with Anil Kumar, the Tribunal did not independently assess whether the PHQ, MHA, or DOPT letters validly restricted such benefits; it effectively treated them as inapplicable to the present claim by following the earlier decision

¶ 8

The reasoning is therefore precedent-driven rather than based on an analysis of the impugned clarifications.

05Holding

The Tribunal held that the present OA is squarely covered by Anil Kumar (O.A. No. 1329/2025) and is disposed of in those terms, directing the respondents to take a decision accordingly

¶ 8

The directions incorporated by reference from Anil Kumar include: quashing of the impugned remarks and any order inapplicable to the applicant; notional pay re-fixation at par with batchmates; arrears calculated from actual joining; MACP from 01.05.2020 after counting notional service; NPS contribution for the notional period; and no interest on arrears. Compliance is required within 90 days of receipt of a certified copy. The M.A. for a single OA was allowed. Pending MAs stand disposed of and there is no order as to costs.

¶ 2 · ¶ 5(i)–(viii) · ¶ 9
CAT - ['Delhi']

Original Court PDF

MOHIT SHARMAvsCOMMISSIONER OF POLICE

CAT - ['Delhi'] · October 21, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment