CAT - ['Delhi']Employment and Labour LawSocial Security and Pensions

Delhi Police Constable Held Up By Administrative Delay Wins Notional Pay Parity With Batchmates

VINOD KUMARv.COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

Delhi Police Constable Held Up By Administrative Delay Wins Notional Pay Parity With Batchmates. VINOD KUMAR vs COMMISSIONER OF POLICE. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether an applicant who is granted seniority from a notional date of appointment (01.05.2010) is entitled to notional pay fixation, increments, and benefits at par with batchmates from that date, despite actual joining at a later date.

The court held

The Tribunal held that the present OA is squarely covered by OA No. 1329/2025 and Krishna Kumari and is disposed of in those terms.

It also directed

The respondents are directed to take the decision accordingly. The order does not itself set out separate operative directions. Those incorporated by reference from OA No. 1329/2025 include: quashing of the impugned remarks; pay re-fixation at par with batchmates on a notional basis; consequential benefits from the date of actual joining; MACP from 01.05.2020 with notional service counted; NPS contribution for the notional period with difference amounts; no interest on arrears; and compliance within 90 days of receipt of a certified copy. Pending MAs stand disposed of, and there is no order as to costs.

01Facts

The applicant, a Head Constable (Driver) in Delhi Police, applied in 2009 under an advertisement for temporary Constable (Driver) recruitment.

¶ 2

Due to administrative delays, he could not join with the first batch on 01.05.2010 and joined only on 02.01.2012.

¶ 2

The respondents published an Inter-Se Seniority List on 12.01.2018, assigning him seniority from 01.05.2010 on the basis of his 2009 merit position, at par with his batchmates.

¶ 2

He was denied notional pay fixation, increments, and first MACP benefits.

¶ 2

His representation dated 15.09.2026 seeking pay re-fixation at par with batchmates was rejected on 29.09.2026 with a remark directing that the judgment copy be supplied for "further necessary action".

¶ 2

The applicant challenged the rejection and sought quashing of the remarks; treatment of 01.05.2010 as the notional date of appointment; MACP from 01.05.2020 with notional service counted; NPS contribution for the notional period with statutory interest; and release of arrears with 12% interest.

¶ 1

Learned counsel relied on OA No. 1329/2025 (decided 21.11.2025), which followed OA No. 3318/2018 (decided 15.04.2023) and the Delhi High Court's decision in Director of Education v. Smt. Krishna Kumari.

¶ 3

Counsel for the respondents did not dispute that the present OA is identical to OA No. 1329/2025.

¶ 4

02Issues

i.1. Whether an applicant who is granted seniority from a notional date of appointment (01.05.2010) is entitled to notional pay fixation, increments, and benefits at par with batchmates from that date, despite actual joining at a later date.

¶ 3 · ¶ 5 (as quoted from OA No. 1329/2025, paras 15–16)

ii.2. Whether the applicant is entitled to MACP from 01.05.2020, NPS contribution for the notional period, and consequential arrears on that basis.

¶ 3 (as quoted from OA No. 1329/2025 · ¶ 18(v)–(vi))

03Law Applied

The Tribunal's reasoning rests on judicial precedent rather than a statutory provision quoted in the order. It relied on the Delhi High Court's decision in Director of Education v. Smt. Krishna Kumari, WP(C) No. 13987/2009 (21.12.2009), which held that once notional seniority is granted from an earlier date, that fiction must be given full effect, including for pay fixation, so that pay is fixed as if the employee had joined on the notional date, with increments, wage revisions, and Assured Progression Scheme benefits.

¶ 3 · ¶ 16 of OA No. 1329/2025 as quoted

The Tribunal followed its own decisions in OA No. 3318/2018 (15.04.2023) and OA No. 1329/2025 (21.11.2025), which applied that ratio to identical facts.

¶ 3 · ¶ 17 of OA No. 1329/2025 as quoted

The order does not expressly cite the MACP or NPS rules; it relies on the consequential-benefit directions in OA No. 1329/2025.

¶ 3 · ¶ 18(v)–(vi) of OA No. 1329/2025 as quoted

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19

04Reasoning

The Tribunal noted that the applicant's delayed joining was caused solely by administrative delay, and that the respondents had already granted him seniority from 01.05.2010 at par with batchmates.

¶ 2

Having conferred that notional seniority, the respondents could not deny the corresponding pay fixation, as this would create the anomaly the applicant complained of: service counted from 2010 for seniority, but pay effective only from actual joining.

¶ 2

Applying the Krishna Kumari principle, the notional fiction must be carried through to pay.

¶ 16 of OA No. 1329/2025 as quoted in para. 3

The Tribunal found that the applicant had participated in the same selection process as the applicant in OA No. 1329/2025 and that the issues were identical. It therefore held that the present OA is governed by OA No. 1329/2025 and should be disposed of on the same terms.

¶ 5 · ¶ 6

05Holding

The Tribunal held that the present OA is squarely covered by OA No. 1329/2025 and Krishna Kumari and is disposed of in those terms.

¶ 5–6

The respondents are directed to take the decision accordingly. The order does not itself set out separate operative directions. Those incorporated by reference from OA No. 1329/2025 include: quashing of the impugned remarks; pay re-fixation at par with batchmates on a notional basis; consequential benefits from the date of actual joining; MACP from 01.05.2020 with notional service counted; NPS contribution for the notional period with difference amounts; no interest on arrears; and compliance within 90 days of receipt of a certified copy. Pending MAs stand disposed of, and there is no order as to costs.

¶ 6 · ¶ 3 (quoting paras. 18(i)–(viii) of OA No. 1329/2025) · ¶ 7
CAT - ['Delhi']

Original Court PDF

VINOD KUMARvsCOMMISSIONER OF POLICE

CAT - ['Delhi'] · October 27, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment