01Facts
Sixteen applicants are, or were, Hindi Pradhyapaks (Group 'B') at the Central Hindi Training Institute, Department of Official Language, Ministry of Home Affairs
¶ 1Similarly placed Hindi Pradhyapaks first challenged their pay parity before the Madras Bench in OA No. 610/2003, which was dismissed on 09.03.2004 on the ground that pay fixation is an executive function
¶ 2On writ petition (W.P. No. 14005/2004), the Madras High Court, by judgment dated 09.04.2009, set aside the Tribunal's order, held the anomaly "shocking to our judicial conscience," and directed that the post of Hindi Pradhyapak be equated with Assistant Director (Hindi Typing and Shorthand) and Assistant Director (Hindi Language), with Deputy Director as the next promotional post, effective from the date of the order
¶ 2, 15The Union's Civil Appeal Nos. 7540–7541/2012 were dismissed by the Supreme Court on 06.04.2022
¶ 3After inter-departmental consultation in April–May 2023, the Department of Expenditure and the Department of Legal Affairs advised that the benefit be confined to the original petitioners
¶ 4In Contempt Petition No. 1236/2023, the High Court recorded compliance for the petitioners before it but left other aggrieved persons free to agitate their rights in accordance with law
¶ 4By order dated 12.02.2024, the respondents restricted the equation and pay benefit to the writ petitioners alone; the applicants challenged this order
¶ 4The respondents contended that pay scales and equation of posts are executive matters and that a 2020 Cadre Review was being implemented
¶ 6–802Issues
i.1. Whether the judgment dated 09.04.2009 in W.P. No. 14005/2004, as affirmed by the Supreme Court on 06.04.2022, operates in rem so as to oblige the respondents to extend its benefit to all incumbents of the post of Hindi Pradhyapak, or only in personam in favour of the writ petitioners
¶ 12(i)ii.2. Whether the applicants are disentitled to relief on the ground of delay, laches or acquiescence
¶ 12(ii)iii.3. Whether the opinions of the Department of Expenditure and the Department of Legal Affairs, the order dated 12.07.2023 in Contempt Petition No. 1236/2023, or the Cadre Review dated 29.09.2020 justify the impugned order dated 12.02.2024
¶ 12(iii)iv.4. What relief, if any, the applicants are entitled to
¶ 12(iv)03Law Applied
When relief is granted to a set of employees, identically situated persons must ordinarily be treated alike, failing which Article 14 is violated (State of U.P. v. Arvind Kumar Srivastava (2015) 1 SCC 347)
¶ 13, Arvind Kumar, 22.1The rule in Arvind Kumar is subject to exceptions for laches, delay and acquiescence
¶ 13, 22.2The exceptions do not apply where the judgment is in rem, i.e., where the subject matter touches policy or structural matters, in which case the authorities are obliged to extend the benefit to all similarly situated persons
¶ 13, 22.3A "manifest intendment" that the judgment operates in rem is required, such as a direction on cadre structure or regularisation (Manjeet Kumar v. Food Corporation of India, LPA 979/2024 (Del. HC, 07.02.2025))
¶ 14Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution were invoked against classification based solely on party status in litigation
¶ 17A belated representation cannot defer the cause of action (Chief Executive Officer v. S. Lalitha, 2025 INSC 565)
¶ 23–24In continuing wrongs relief may be granted notwithstanding delay, with arrears ordinarily confined to three years before filing (Union of India v. Tarsem Singh (2008) 8 SCC 648)
¶ 23–24Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 21
04Reasoning
The High Court's direction is framed in terms of "the Hindi Pradhyapaks" as a class and "the post of Hindi Pradhyapak," and it re-ordered the cadre hierarchy by fixing Deputy Director as the next promotional post for both feeder and promotional posts
¶ 16A declaration on the pay and promotional placement of a post necessarily concerns every incumbent, and the anomaly was structural, not personal to the petitioners, which brings it within the in rem category in Arvind Kumar
¶ 16The prospective effective date from 09.04.2009 does not indicate a personal intent, and the language manifests an intent to correct the post
¶ 18Because the Supreme Court dismissed the Union's appeals, the High Court's rejection of the "executive domain" plea became final and could not be re-agitated before the Tribunal
¶ 19The internal opinions of the Departments of Expenditure and Legal Affairs cannot narrow a final judicial declaration, and financial implications bear, at most, on the period of arrears
¶ 20The contempt order was limited to compliance for the parties before the court and expressly preserved others' remedies, so it did not construe the judgment as in personam
¶ 21The 2020 Cadre Review is prospective and does not address the period from 09.04.2009
¶ 22On delay, the in rem character displaces the laches exception; the applicants did not sleep over their rights, since the Union itself contested the judgment until 06.04.2022 and the impugned order was challenged within the limitation period under Section 21 of the AT Act
¶ 23The claim is a continuing wrong, so refixation was allowed notionally from 09.04.2009 with arrears limited to three years before filing, given the applicants' inaction between 2009 and 2024
¶ 23–24The Tribunal declined to declare the applicants deemed Assistant Directors, since the High Court only equated the pay scale and did not alter designations; the applicants could not be placed in a better position than the writ petitioners
¶ 2505Holding
The judgment dated 09.04.2009 operates in rem and binds the respondents to extend its benefit to all incumbents of the Hindi Pradhyapak post; the applicants' claim is not defeated by delay or laches
¶ 16–18, 23–24The OA is allowed, and the impugned order dated 12.02.2024 is quashed and set aside to the extent it confines the benefit to the writ petitioners
¶ 26(i)The respondents must grant the applicants the same pay scale, replacement pay band, grade pay and pay level as granted to the writ petitioners, effective from 09.04.2009 or the date of regular appointment as Hindi Pradhyapak, whichever is later, until promotion or placement as Assistant Director (Language) or retirement
¶ 26(ii)Pay is to be notionally refixed with consequential benefits, but actual arrears are restricted to the three years preceding filing of the OA
¶ 26(iii)Pension and retiral dues of retired applicants are to be revised, with arrears subject to the same limitation
¶ 26(iv)The respondents must comply and pass orders within three months of receipt of a certified copy
¶ 26(v)Pending MAs stand disposed of, with no order as to costs
¶ 27Original Court PDF
PRADEEP KUMAR SHARMAvsHOME AFFAIRS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Hindi Pradhyapaks Who Never Sued Win Madras HC Pay Parity With Assistant Directors, Arrears Capped at Three Years. PRADEEP KUMAR SHARMA vs HOME AFFAIRS. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/hindi-pradhyapaks-who-never-sued-win-madras-hc-pay-parity-with-assistant-directors-arrears-56d0bc283de6430f97b4b4dd9b515f78.webp)