01Facts
The applicants applied in 2009 for temporary Constable (Driver) posts in Delhi Police under a recruitment advertisement.
¶ 4Due to administrative delays, the applicants could not join with the first batch on 01.05.2010 and joined only on 02.01.2012.
¶ 4The respondents later issued an Inter-Se Seniority List (12.01.2018) assigning seniority from 01.05.2010, at par with their batchmates, based on 2009 merit.
¶ 4Despite this, the respondents denied notional pay fixation, increments and first MACP benefits.
¶ 4Applicant No. 1's representation dated 22.09.2026 seeking pay re-fixation at par with batchmates was returned on 29.09.2026 with a direction to produce a judgment naming him.
¶ 4The applicants sought quashing of the remarks and directions for deemed appointment from 01.05.2010, MACP from 01.05.2020, NPS contribution for notional service, and arrears with interest.
¶ 3The applicants' counsel relied on O.A. No. 1329/2025 (Anil Kumar v. Commissioner of Police, decided 21.11.2025), which followed O.A. No. 3318/2018 (decided 15.04.2023) and the Delhi High Court's decision in Director of Education v. Smt. Krishna Kumari, WP(C) No. 13987/2009.
¶ 5The respondents' counsel did not dispute that the present OA is identical to O.A. No. 1329/2025.
¶ 602Issues
i.1. Whether the applicants, who were granted seniority from 01.05.2010 on account of administrative delay in joining, are entitled to notional pay fixation, increments, and MACP benefits from that deemed date, with consequential NPS benefits and arrears.
¶ 4 · ¶ 7ii.2. Whether the impugned remarks dated 29.09.2026, which demanded a judgment naming the applicant before processing the representation, are sustainable.
¶ 4 · ¶ 803Law Applied
Once notional seniority is granted from a past date, the fiction must be given full effect, including for pay fixation, so that pay is fixed as if the employee had joined on that date, with increments, wage revisions and Assured Progression benefits.
¶ 5 · ¶ 16 of quoted Anil Kumar orderDirector of Education v. Smt. Krishna Kumari (Delhi HC, WP(C) No. 13987/2009) is the source of the principle that notional seniority carries notional pay fixation.
¶ 5O.A. No. 1329/2025 (Anil Kumar) applied that ratio to direct notional pay fixation, MACP from 01.05.2020 counting notional service, and NPS contribution for the notional period, with consequential benefits limited to actual entitlement from the date of joining.
¶ 5 · ¶ 15–18 of quoted Anil Kumar orderA case identical in facts and issues to a previously decided Tribunal case is disposed of in the same terms.
¶ 7 · ¶ 8Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19
04Reasoning
The Tribunal found that the present case was identical to Anil Kumar: the applicants had taken part in the same 2009 selection, were excluded from the 01.05.2010 batch, joined later, and were given seniority at par with batchmates.
¶ 7 · ¶ 15 of quoted Anil Kumar orderRespondents did not contest this identity.
¶ 6Applying Krishna Kumari, the Tribunal held that the grant of notional seniority from 2010 required pay fixation on the same notional footing, which the respondents had not done.
¶ 5 · ¶ 16 of quoted Anil Kumar orderThe refusal to grant notional pay while recognising seniority from 2010 created the anomaly the applicants complained of.
¶ 4Because the matter was squarely covered by Anil Kumar, the Tribunal saw no reason to take a different view and disposed of the OA on that basis.
¶ 8The Tribunal did not separately analyse the validity of the 29.09.2026 remark beyond the disposal directions.
¶ 805Holding
The applicants' claim for notional pay fixation, increments and MACP from the deemed date of 01.05.2010 stands covered by the ratio of Anil Kumar, and the Tribunal saw no reason to take a different view.
¶ 7 · ¶ 8The OA is disposed of in terms of O.A. No. 1329/2025 (Anil Kumar, decided 21.11.2025), and the respondents are directed to take a decision accordingly.
¶ 8Pending MAs stand disposed of and no order as to costs is made.
¶ 9The present order does not restate the specific relief from Anil Kumar (notional pay re-fixation at par with batchmates, MACP from 01.05.2020, NPS contribution for the notional period, and arrears without interest within 90 days). Those directions are incorporated only by reference, so the operative terms should be checked against the Anil Kumar order itself.
¶ 5, quoting Anil Kumar paras. 18(iii)–(viii)The order cites O.A. No. 3371/2018 and O.A. No. 3318/2018 for the same 15.04.2023 decision, which should be verified before reliance.
¶ 5 · ¶ 17 of quoted Anil Kumar orderOriginal Court PDF
JANMESH KUMARvsCOMMISSIONER OF POLICE
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Delhi Police Drivers Who Joined in 2012 Get Notional Pay Parity With 2010 Batchmates, Tribunal Rules. JANMESH KUMAR vs COMMISSIONER OF POLICE. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/delhi-police-drivers-who-joined-in-2012-get-notional-pay-parity-with-2010-batchmates-tribu-bba0c993052443cb986c0bba6c9044fc.webp)