01Facts
Dunar Foods Limited ("Dunar") claims to have adopted the mark NAWAJISH/NAWAZISH for rice and allied goods in Class 30 and asserts use since 13.10.2007.
¶ 2, 6Dunar holds Registration for NAWAJISH (application filed 17.04.2007, registered 31.03.2009) and a stylised/device mark registered 29.05.2015, with a clerical error ("NAWAGISH") later rectified.
¶ 17Ankit Vats Trading as AVJK Foods LLP ("Ankit Vats") applied for the device mark "NAWAJISH" (with a device letter "N") in Class 30 on 26.06.2017 on a "proposed to be used" basis.
¶ 3, 17Dunar discovered the registration in 2024, issued a cease-and-desist notice, and, on non-compliance, filed a petition under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 ("the Act").
¶ 3Ankit Vats filed a counter-petition seeking cancellation of Dunar's registration.
¶ 4Ankit Vats objected to maintainability, contending that Dunar's conduct under the MPID Act, 1999 and PMLA proceedings (including provisional attachment) bars Dunar from prosecuting the petition without the MPID Special Court's permission.
¶ 7, 1002Issues
i.1. Whether Dunar's petition is maintainable despite the ED attachment orders and the MPID Act proceedings.
¶ 7, 10ii.2. Whether Ankit Vats's registration of NAWAZISH is wrongly entered or wrongly remaining on the Register, warranting cancellation under Section 57.
¶ 11–13iii.3. Whether the rival marks are deceptively similar for identical goods.
¶ 14–15iv.4. Whether Dunar established prior use and whether Ankit Vats's adoption was dishonest.
¶ 16–19v.5. Whether Dunar's prior user rights override Ankit Vats's registration.
¶ 20–2103Law Applied
Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 permits expungement or variation of entries wrongly made or remaining on the Register.
¶ 11Sections 9(2)(a) and 11(3)(a) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 bar marks likely to cause confusion or passing off.
¶ 21Section 18(1) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 governs application by a non-proprietor.
¶ 19Sections 9(1)(a), 11(1), 11(10), and 18(4) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 were pleaded but not specifically applied in the reasoning.
¶ 6Rajiv Chakraborty v. Directorate of Enforcement (2022 SCC OnLine Del 3703) holds that attachment is a fetter on dealing with property, not an extinguishment of rights, so IP enforcement is not barred.
¶ 10Blue Heaven Cosmetics v. Deepak Arora (2022 SCC OnLine Del 1001) holds that a mark registered in violation of absolute or relative grounds is "wrongly entered and wrongly remaining".
¶ 11Russell Corp v. Ashok Mahajan (2023) 4 HCC (Del) 301 holds that adoption of an identical or deceptively similar mark for identical goods without plausible explanation is a dishonest attempt to usurp goodwill.
¶ 12Dorco Co. v. Durga Enterprises (2023 SCC OnLine Del 1484) holds that an applicant without explanation of adoption is not the proprietor under Section 18(1).
¶ 19S. Syed Mohideen v. P. Sulochana Bai (2016) 2 SCC 683 holds that prior user rights under Sections 27, 28 and 34 are superior to registration.
¶ 20Amit Sood v. Union of India (2024 SCC OnLine Del 3226) holds that a mark likely to result in passing off is not registrable under Section 11.
¶ 21Provisions in the judgment · 10 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Trade Marks Act, 1999 Section 9Section 11Section 18Section 27Section 28Section 34Section 57
Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors (in Financial Establishments) Act, 1999 Section 4Section 5Section 10
04Reasoning
The court held that the MPID/PMLA restrictions are limited to dealings with attached property and do not prevent enforcement of IP rights, since no third-party interest was alleged to have been created.
¶ 10On merits, the court found the marks phonetically and visually identical, and held that the device "N" and the substitution of "Z" for "J" do not avoid confusion between goods in the same class.
¶ 14–15The court accepted Dunar's evidence of use since 2007 and its registrations as establishing prior, long-standing goodwill.
¶ 16–17Because Ankit Vats filed on a proposed-to-be-used basis and offered no explanation for adopting an arbitrary, coined term identical to Dunar's mark, the court inferred dishonest adoption.
¶ 18–19Applying Syed Mohideen, Dunar's prior user rights prevailed over the later registration, and use of the identical mark for identical goods was likely to deceive and amount to passing off, rendering the registration barred under Sections 9(2)(a) and 11(3)(a).
¶ 20–21The counter-petition by Ankit Vats failed for the same reasons.
¶ 2305Holding
The court held that Ankit Vats's adoption of NAWAZISH was dishonest and violative of statutory provisions.
¶ 22The petition by Dunar (C.O. 158/2024) is allowed. Registration No. 1741844 for NAWAZISH (Application No. 3578464, Class 30) is cancelled and set aside, and pending applications are disposed of. The counter-petition by Ankit Vats (C.O. 203/2024) is dismissed, with pending applications disposed of. The listing before the Joint Registrar on 22.01.2027 is cancelled.
¶ 22, 23, 24Original Court PDF
Dunar Foods LimitedvsAnkit Vats Trading As Avjk Foods Llp & Anr.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
