01Facts
The petitioner, Accused No. 2 in the Pune multiple-murder case, was convicted under IPC ss. 302, 302/120-B, 397/120-B, 449/120-B and 342/34 for the killing of five women, one of them pregnant, and two children.
¶ 3, 6The Trial Court imposed death under s. 302 read with s. 120-B, with concurrent terms for the other offences.
¶ 7The Bombay High Court confirmed the death sentence and dismissed the appeals.
¶ 8The Supreme Court upheld the conviction and sentence on 05.09.2000 and dismissed the review petition on 24.11.2000.
¶ 9–10The petitioner's mercy petition dated 27.06.2001 received no response. A second letter dated 02.11.2004, sent through counsel, was forwarded by the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) to the State Government, which had to consider it under Article 161 first.
¶ 11–14The Governor of Maharashtra rejected the mercy petition on 15.03.2014, but the petitioner learnt of this only through an RTI reply dated 22.11.2016.
¶ 19–20The Union Home Minister recommended rejection on 14/23.07.2015.
¶ 22The Attorney General, on 11.02.2016, opined that there was "huge unexplained delay" and recommended commutation in view of Shatrughan Chauhan.
¶ 24–25The Home Minister disagreed, and both opinions were placed before the President.
¶ 25–26On 18.09.2016, the President commuted the death sentence to life imprisonment, directing that the petitioner "shall remain in prison for the whole of the remainder of his natural life" with no remission by any authority.
¶ 27The order was communicated by the Superintendent, Nagpur Central Jail, on 15.10.2016.
¶ 2, 27The petitioner challenged the no-remission condition under Article 226 read with s. 482 CrPC, seeking commutation to life with remission and quashing of the condition.
¶ 1, 2802Issues
i.1. Whether this Court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain a writ challenging an order of the President under Article 72.
¶ 29, 44–45ii.2. Whether an order of the President under Article 72 is amenable to judicial review under Article 226, and if so, on what limited grounds.
¶ 46–50iii.3. Whether the inordinate delay of about 15 years in deciding the mercy petition warrants commutation or interference with the order.
¶ 32, 51–61iv.4. Whether the condition barring any remission is unconstitutional or illegal.
¶ 37–38, 61v.5. Whether the petitioner's prolonged solitary confinement independently entitles him to unconditional commutation.
¶ 3303Law Applied
Article 72 and Article 161 of the Constitution confer clemency powers on the President and Governor as a constitutional responsibility, construed in the widest terms, and subject only to limited judicial review of the manner of exercise and not the decision itself, citing Epuru Sudhakar and Shatrughan Chauhan.
¶ 47–50Judicial review of clemency is confined to non-application of mind, mala fides, extraneous or irrelevant considerations, omission of relevant material, and arbitrariness, citing Epuru Sudhakar and Pyare Lal.
¶ 58Under Shatrughan Chauhan and Pradeep Yashwant Kokade, undue, unexplained and inordinate delay in deciding mercy petitions is a supervening circumstance under Article 21 that may justify commutation of death, though the length of delay is fact-specific and not mathematical.
¶ 51–56Under Union of India v. V. Sriharan (Constitution Bench), a sentence of imprisonment for the remainder of natural life without remission is valid, and clemency rights under Articles 72 and 161 remain constitutional remedies untouched by statutory remission.
¶ 58–59The executive must process mercy petitions expeditiously.
¶ 51, 56(vii)Provisions in the judgment · 14 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482Section 413Section 414Section 313Section 432Section 433
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302Section 34Section 342Section 397Section 392Section 449Section 53Section 45
04Reasoning
The Court held that jurisdiction lay in Delhi because the President's order was passed there and the cause of action arose there.
¶ 45The Court accepted that the delay of more than 15 years between the 2001 petition and the 2016 decision was inordinate and that the sword of death had hung over the petitioner throughout, and it noted the allegation of solitary confinement.
¶ 60The Court held that delay alone could have justified commutation, but that the President had consciously considered the delay. The President had specifically sought the Attorney General's opinion on the applicability of Shatrughan Chauhan, received a view favouring commutation, and also received the MHA's contrary recommendation before deciding.
¶ 61The Court found that the President had "all the relevant inputs" and "took into consideration all the relevant factors," and held that the power to attach a no-remission condition exists and vests in the President.
¶ 61, 59, 63Applying the limited grounds of review, the Court found no lack of application of mind, mala fides, or irrelevant consideration, and treated the impugned decision as a considered exercise of discretion. The Court emphasised that its role is judicial review, not appeal, so it could not substitute its own view merely because it might have decided differently.
¶ 62–63The Court did not separately adjudicate the solitary-confinement claim or the challenge to the no-remission condition beyond recognising the power's existence. The respondents' reliance on the pending SLP in Sonu Sarda was not made a ground of decision.
¶ 61, 4205Holding
This Court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain the writ petition.
¶ 45Although the delay of over 15 years in deciding the mercy petition was inordinate and could have warranted commutation, the President's order is not liable to be set aside, because the President considered the delay, the conflicting opinions of the Attorney General and the MHA, and all relevant material, and the no-remission condition is within the President's constitutional power under Article 72.
¶ 60–63The writ petition was dismissed, and the application CRL.M.A. 17911/2017 was disposed of as infructuous. The MHA record was ordered to be returned, and no costs were awarded.
¶ 64–66Original Court PDF
Jitendra @ Jitu Niansingh GehlotvsUnion Of India & Anr
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
