Karnataka High CourtHealth and Medical LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Eye doctors get relief as court quashes FIR in blindness case, citing missing independent expert opinion

SHEKAR EYE HOSPITALv.STATE OF KARNATAKA

Eye doctors get relief as court quashes FIR in blindness case, citing missing independent expert opinion. SHEKAR EYE HOSPITAL vs STATE OF KARNATAKA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether a private complaint alleging criminal medical negligence, and the consequent direction for FIR registration and investigation, can proceed where no prior credible opinion of an independent competent medical expert was produced with the complaint or obtained by the Investigating Officer, as required by Jacob Mathew and ASV Narayan Rao.

The court held

The private complaint and the FIR under s. 338 IPC were registered without compliance with the mandatory prior independent expert opinion safeguard laid down in Jacob Mathew and ASV Narayan Rao, and continuing the proceedings would be an abuse of process.

It also directed

The delay and KMC dismissal arguments were not the basis of the decision.

The petition is allowed. The court quashed the order dated 10.07.2019 in PCR No. 8460/2019 passed by the XLIV ACMM, Bengaluru, the private complaint, FIR No. 141/2019 registered by Jayaprakash Nagar Police Station, and all further proceedings under s. 338 IPC.

01Facts

The petitioners (accused nos. 1 to 4: a hospital, its proprietor-ophthalmologist, and two doctors) were accused of negligence in Implantable Contact Lens (ICL) surgery.

The complainant, a 26-year-old, underwent ICL implantation in her left eye on 23.08.2017 and right eye on 26.08.2017, despite complaining of discomfort.

¶ 2–3

Post-operative complications followed, including elevated intraocular pressure, secondary glaucoma, and further procedures such as Epi-LASIK, YAG-PI, ICL explantation and trabeculectomy.

¶ 4–8

She was certified as 100% blind in both eyes in April 2019.

¶ 8

She issued a legal notice on 14.02.2019, filed a complaint before the Karnataka Medical Council (KMC) on 25.04.2019, and approached police and the Deputy Commissioner of Police without result.

¶ 10

She then filed a private complaint under s. 338 IPC and s. 156(3) CrPC. On 10.07.2019 the XLIV ACMM, Bengaluru directed the SHO, Jayaprakash Nagar Police Station to investigate. FIR No. 141/2019 was registered on 06.08.2019.

¶ 11

The petitioners contended that the complaint was delayed by about two years, was filed after the KMC complaint, lacked a prior independent expert opinion, and that the KMC had dismissed the complaint on 03.05.2025.

¶ 12–17

The State opposed the petition, arguing that investigation was at an initial stage and expert opinion could still be obtained.

¶ 18

The complainant was served but unrepresented.

¶ 19

02Issues

i.1. Whether a private complaint alleging criminal medical negligence, and the consequent direction for FIR registration and investigation, can proceed where no prior credible opinion of an independent competent medical expert was produced with the complaint or obtained by the Investigating Officer, as required by Jacob Mathew and ASV Narayan Rao.

¶ 21–26

ii.2. Whether the alleged delay of about two years in filing the complaint, and its filing after the KMC complaint, render the complaint an afterthought amounting to abuse of process.

¶ 12–13, 22, 29

iii.3. Whether the KMC's dismissal of the complaint on 03.05.2025 bars continuation of the criminal proceedings.

¶ 30

03Law Applied

Section 482 CrPC is the source of the court's inherent power to quash proceedings to prevent abuse of process or secure ends of justice.

¶ 31

Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab (2005) 6 SCC 1 bars entertaining a criminal negligence complaint against a medical professional unless it is supported by a credible opinion of a competent doctor, and requires the Investigating Officer to obtain an independent medical opinion, preferably from a Government doctor, before proceeding.

¶ 24

ASV Narayan Rao v. Ratnamala (2013) 10 SCC 741 holds that criminal negligence requires a higher degree of negligence ("gross" or "very high degree") and that the same safeguards apply.

¶ 24

Martin F. D'Souza v. Mohd. Ishfaq (2009) 3 SCC 1 requires referral to a specialist committee before notice is issued to a doctor.

¶ 15

Skoda Auto Volkswagen (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. State of U.P. (2021) 5 SCC 795 and Punit Beriwala v. State (NCT of Delhi) 2025 SCC OnLine SC 983 hold that mere delay does not justify quashing unless it is unexplained and deliberate.

¶ 29

Hardeep Singh Aulakh v. State of Punjab 2018 SCC OnLine P&H 5506 permits expert opinion to be obtained during investigation.

¶ 18, 26

Anukul Singh v. State of U.P. 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2060 sets out the three grounds for s. 482 intervention.

¶ 31

Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482Section 156Section 468

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 338Section 193Section 228

KARNATAKA MEDICAL REGISTRATION ACT, 1961 Section 16Section 17

04Reasoning

The Jacob Mathew safeguards apply even where proceedings begin with a private complaint and a Magistrate's direction under s. 156(3), rather than a police complaint.

¶ 25

The complaint was not accompanied by any independent expert opinion, and the Investigating Officer had not obtained an opinion from a Government doctor. A Magistrate's direction cannot dispense with these safeguards.

¶ 26

Hardeep Singh Aulakh is distinguished, because there the police had already considered the opinion of a PGI expert at the FIR stage, and the court there rejected the quashing petition on that basis.

¶ 26–27

"Independent expert opinion" need not be a full assessment, but the complainant's reference to an opinion from a JSS Hospital ophthalmologist was not appended to the complaint, so the procedural protection was not met.

¶ 28

On delay, the complainant had narrated the treatment chronology in detail and explained her follow-up, so the delay was not shown to be unexplained or deliberate. The offence under s. 338 IPC is within the three-year limitation period under s. 468(2)(c) CrPC.

¶ 29

The KMC had examined the same allegations through a quasi-judicial process, but the ground for quashing rested on the procedural violation, not on the KMC finding.

¶ 30

The case fell within the abuse-of-process category of s. 482 interference.

¶ 31

05Holding

The private complaint and the FIR under s. 338 IPC were registered without compliance with the mandatory prior independent expert opinion safeguard laid down in Jacob Mathew and ASV Narayan Rao, and continuing the proceedings would be an abuse of process.

¶ 26, 28, 31

The delay and KMC dismissal arguments were not the basis of the decision.

¶ 29–30

The petition is allowed. The court quashed the order dated 10.07.2019 in PCR No. 8460/2019 passed by the XLIV ACMM, Bengaluru, the private complaint, FIR No. 141/2019 registered by Jayaprakash Nagar Police Station, and all further proceedings under s. 338 IPC.

¶ 32
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SHEKAR EYE HOSPITALvsSTATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment