01Facts
The petitioner operates a retail fuel outlet ("Fatima Filling Station") on behalf of Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. (IOCL), having obtained statutory clearances and a National Highway Authority of India (NHAI) access permission dated 25.02.2021 for an approach road from the highway
¶ 2Neighbouring encroachments on NH land obstructed the access road, and the NHAI and IOCL repeatedly sought their removal from the District Administration
¶ 3By communication dated 28.07.2025, NHAI directed IOCL to deposit a penalty of Rs. 2,50,000 for energizing the outlet without final access NOC, and ordered de-energization until final NOC was granted
¶ 1The penalty was based on MoRTH guidelines dated 26.06.2020, para 2.11(v)
¶ 4The petitioner deposited the penalty on 31.07.2025
¶ 9Respondent No. 12, a neighbouring resident, had earlier filed WP(C) No. 1919/2025 challenging the outlet's installation. On 12.08.2025 this Court directed the District Magistrate, Pulwama, to examine all NOCs and permit operation only if they were complete
¶ 7, 14The petitioner did not disclose that order
¶ 8An interim order dated 26.09.2025 in the present petition permitted operation at the sanctioned place, and the Deputy Commissioner's order dated 10.12.2025 was put on hold
¶ 8, 17The NHAI contended that the provisional permission did not authorize energization and that the outlet lacked final NOC and was within 50 metres of R12's residence
¶ 8, 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner's non-disclosure of the earlier order dated 12.08.2025 in WP(C) No. 1919/2025 is a material suppression that bars relief in the present petition.
¶ 13, 16, 17ii.2. Whether the penalty of Rs. 2,50,000 imposed on IOCL under the MoRTH guidelines was legally justified.
¶ 18–20iii.3. Whether a fuel station may be energized on the basis of provisional access permission, or without final access permission, when encroachment prevents construction of access.
¶ 19, 20iv.4. Whether the compliance of the petrol pump with NOC requirements can be adjudicated in this writ petition or must be determined by the District Magistrate.
¶ 21, 22v.5. Whether the encroachments on NH land must be removed, and by which authority and under which statute.
¶ 2303Law Applied
The MoRTH "Guidelines for grant of permission for construction of access to Fuel Stations, etc." dated 26.06.2020, which the Court treated as mandatory, provide: a self-certified access proposal (para. 2.3); a fuel station is to be de-energized where access is not built to norms (para. 2.3); no energization during the period of provisional permission (para. 2.5.2); validity extension of provisional permission by one year (para. 2.6); and a penalty of Rs. 2,50,000 for operating an energized station without final access permission (para. 2.11(v))
¶ 18Suppression of material facts may non-suit a litigant, as drawn from K.D. Sharma v. Steel Authority of India Ltd., (2008) 12 SCC 481, but only where the suppressed fact is material to the relief sought
¶ 13, 16The Supreme Court's directions in Gyan Prakash v. Union of India (WP(C) No. 1272/2019) govern the removal of National Highway encroachments
¶ 23The Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002, Chapter IV, and Sections 26, 27, 36 and 43 vest the District Magistrate with powers to remove encroachments swiftly
¶ 23Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002 Section 26Section 27Section 36Section 43
04Reasoning
The non-disclosure of the earlier writ petition was not material, because the present petition concerns only the NHAI penalty and removal of encroachments, and the earlier order concerns a different subject
¶ 16The petitioner should have disclosed the 12.08.2025 order when seeking the interim order of 26.09.2025. The omission produced two apparently conflicting orders that hampered the District Magistrate, and the situation was remedied by holding the Deputy Commissioner's order in abeyance
¶ 17The petitioner had admittedly not obtained final access permission, and IOCL had energized the outlet without it. The penalty under para 2.11(v) was therefore lawful
¶ 19, 20The failure to construct access was not the petitioner's fault, since encroachments had not been cleared. This could justify only an extension of provisional permission under para 2.6, not energization without access, which the guidelines prohibit "in any circumstances whatsoever"
¶ 20The question whether the petitioner's NOCs were complete falls within the District Magistrate's enquiry under the earlier order, and the Court declined to decide it
¶ 22The enquiry is assigned to the District Magistrate, with an opportunity to cure deficiencies
¶ 21Whoever made the encroachment, the District Magistrate must remove encroachments obstructing access, using the statutory mechanism of the 2002 Act
¶ 2305Holding
The penalty of Rs. 2,50,000 imposed on IOCL by the communication dated 28.07.2025 is valid, and operation without final access permission violates the MoRTH guidelines. Non-disclosure of the earlier order was not fatal to the petition, though it was imprudent
¶ 16, 17, 20The penalty imposed under the 28.07.2025 communication is upheld
¶ 24(I)The District Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner, Pulwama, shall enquire whether the petrol pump was installed at the sanctioned location in compliance with the rules and requisite NOCs
¶ 24(II)If compliance is found, the petitioner shall be allowed to operate, and any encroachment obstructing access shall be removed by the District Magistrate under law
¶ 24(III)Upon construction of access, NHAI shall grant final access permission and permit energization
¶ 24(IV)If deficiencies are found and not cured, the outlet shall be closed or sealed
¶ 24(V)Original Court PDF
ZAHIDA MUSHTAQvsUNION TERRITORY OF J AND K TH.SECRETARY TO GAD AND ORS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
