01Facts
The petitioners own 07 kanals and 11 marlas at Khasra No. 1517/648, Laripora, Pahalgam, and sought building permission in 2012 to construct tourist huts
¶ 3After NOCs were obtained in 2018–19 and a prior writ petition (WP(C) No. 2553/2022) was disposed of with a direction to decide the application, the BOCA in its 11th meeting directed an inspection by the Executive Engineer, Pahalgam Development Authority, to verify that the angle of repose was maintained
¶ 3–4The inspecting officer reported that, after a 34-foot setback beyond State land, about 82 feet of usable length remained
¶ 5On 26.04.2022, the Chief Town Planner, Kashmir, issued an NOC stating that the land use is agriculture but tourism use is permitted subject to maintaining the angle of repose
¶ 6On 06.10.2022, the BOCA (13th meeting) declined consideration due to "contrary land use"
¶ 6The Court's order dated 16.11.2022 in the earlier writ petition directed a decision because no formal rejection order had been passed
¶ 7Subsequent BOCA proceedings (15th meeting, 01–02.02.2024) referred the matter for legal opinion
¶ 9The Chief Town Planner then issued Corrigendum dated 03.04.2025, treating the NOC dated 26.04.2022 as null and void
¶ 10The Master Plan map and written statement conflict on the land use: the written statement permits tourism use up to 25% slope between Chandanwari Road and Rangward Road, but the approved land use plan does not reflect the Committee's recommended changes
¶ 11, 13The Law Department opined that the written statement prevails over the map and that the Master Plan governs land use
¶ 14The Housing and Urban Development Department opined that the proposed tourism activity is contemplated by the written statement and that the case appears fit for favourable consideration
¶ 1502Issues
i.1. Whether the Chief Town Planner was justified in withdrawing the NOC dated 26.04.2022 through Corrigendum dated 03.04.2025 on the ground of a land-use contradiction between the Master Plan map and its written statement
¶ 10, 16ii.2. Whether the land-use conflict between the approved map and the written statement of the Pahalgam Master Plan 2032 bars the grant of building permission for tourist huts on the petitioners' land
¶ 11, 14–1603Law Applied
Section 11-A of the J&K Development Act, 1970, under which the land use permitted by a Master Plan, once in operation, is governed by that Plan
¶ 14Rule 5(2)(ix) of the J&K Development Authority Rules, 1976, which provides that the written statement prevails over the map where the two are inconsistent
¶ 14The statutory status of the Committee constituted under the Development Act (Order No. 108-TSM of 2014), whose recommendations were incorporated into the Master Plan before its approval
¶ 13The BOCA procedure, under which an inspection report, the Chief Town Planner's NOC, and a BOCA decision are required before permission is granted, is reflected in the Master Plan conditions on angle of repose
¶ 4, 6, 12No judicial precedent is cited
Provisions in the judgment · 1
Jammu and Kashmir Development Act, 1970 Section 11
04Reasoning
The withdrawal of the NOC rested on a contradiction between the map and the written statement, which the Law Department had resolved in favour of the written statement under Rule 5(2)(ix). Because the written statement permits tourism use for this site, subject to the angle-of-repose condition that the inspecting officer had already reported as satisfied, the basis for withdrawing the NOC no longer existed
¶ 5, 14–16The Court held that the Chief Town Planner had no justification to withdraw an NOC issued on the basis of the inspection report, and that the corrigendum had therefore lost its significance. On the second issue, the Housing and Urban Development Department's opinion established that the proposed use is not absolutely prohibited under the planning framework, so no legal impediment remained to a fresh decision on the permission. The Court did not itself grant permission and left the merits of the building application to the competent authority
¶ 15–1605Holding
The Chief Town Planner was not justified in withdrawing the NOC, because the land-use conflict is resolved in favour of the written statement of the Master Plan, and no legal impediment remains to a fresh decision on building permission
¶ 16–17The writ petitions were disposed of with the following directions: (I) Corrigendum dated 03.04.2025 is quashed; (II) BOCA is directed to take a fresh decision on the petitioners' building permission application in light of the Law Department and Housing and Urban Development Department opinions; and (III) BOCA must act most expeditiously, preferably within two months of receiving a copy of the order
¶ 17(I)–(III)Original Court PDF
ROSHAN ARA AND ORS.vsUNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND ORS. (HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT)
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
