01Facts
The petitioner, acting through his father, challenged his preventive detention under the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978, effective from 09.08.2025, and sought release from Central Jail, Jammu, Kot Bhalwal.
¶ 3The detention rested on a dossier submitted by the SSP, Anantnag, on 05.08.2025 to the District Magistrate (DM), Anantnag.
¶ 4The sole concrete antecedent relied upon was the petitioner's involvement in FIR No. 255/2020, PS Qazigund, under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967, from which he was acquitted on 03.07.2025.
¶ 5The grounds also alleged that, on interrogation after acquittal, he admitted contact in 2017 with a terrorist who was his maternal brother and affiliated with LeT/TRF, and that he was radicalising youth and likely to re-engage in terrorism in Bijbehara.
¶ 6–7The grounds also noted that he had been bound down under s. 126 BNSS, 2023.
¶ 8The DM passed Detention Order No. 29/DMA/PSA/DET/2025 on 08.08.2025.
¶ 9The petitioner's representation dated 22.08.2025 was disposed of and notified on 11.10.2025.
¶ 10, 18The petitioner contended that the acquittal was not appealed, that the grounds were baseless and self-serving, and that the dossier and grounds were textually identical, showing non-application of mind.
¶ 12, 14–15The respondents stated that detention was necessitated by the circumstances and that procedure was followed.
¶ 16The detention was approved by Government Order dated 12.08.2025, upheld by the Advisory Board, and confirmed by Government Order dated 26.08.2025.
¶ 1702Issues
i.1. Whether the detention order was founded on a legally sustainable factual basis, given that the only concrete antecedent relied upon was a criminal case resulting in acquittal.
¶ 19–20ii.2. Whether the DM applied independent mind to the grounds of detention or merely borrowed the SSP's dossier, rendering the detention mechanical and illegal.
¶ 15, 2103Law Applied
The court's reasoning rests on the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978, under which the detention was ordered.
¶ 3The court also refers to s. 126 BNSS, 2023, which the grounds cited as a prior bond-down proceeding.
¶ 8Preventive detention must rest on an actual factual basis and the detaining authority must independently apply its mind to the material; a detention founded on a "hollow dossier" borrowed from the sponsoring authority without independent application of mind is an abuse of process and violates the right to personal liberty.
¶ 21–22Reliance on an acquittal, with no other factual basis, is insufficient to justify deprivation of liberty.
¶ 19–20No precedents are cited.
04Reasoning
The court found that the only factual material in the record was FIR No. 255/2020, in which the petitioner had been acquitted.
¶ 19Despite the acquittal, the SSP continued to view the petitioner through that criminal case, which the court characterised as applying the maxim "give a dog a bad name and hang him".
¶ 19The court found no other factual basis on record capable of supporting the conclusion of likely future prejudicial activity, the conclusion resting instead on "self-serving assumptions and the judgment thereupon".
¶ 20On the second issue, the court held that the DM adopted the SSP's dossier without independent application of mind, converting the statutory process into an abuse of law.
¶ 21The textual identity of the dossier and grounds, noted by the petitioner, supports this finding, although the judgment does not expressly analyse that comparison.
¶ 15The court did not separately adjudicate the petitioner's specific procedural-lapse allegations, the Advisory Board process, or the timing of the representation's disposal; its decision rests on the substantive defects identified above.
¶ 13, 17, 1805Holding
Both issues are answered in the affirmative. The court held that the petitioner's detention rested on a "hollow dossier" without factual or legal basis and was borrowed without independent application of mind.
¶ 21–22Detention Order No. 29/DMA/PSA/DET/2025 dated 08.08.2025, together with the approval, confirmation, and extension orders, was quashed as illegal.
¶ 22The court directed the petitioner's immediate release from Central Jail, Kot Bhalwal, Jammu, and disposed of the petition.
¶ 23–24Original Court PDF
ZEESHAN SHAFI SHEIKHvsUNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND ANR. (HOME)
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
