01Facts
On 28.12.2009 at about 12:30 AM, the claimant's husband, Raja Mohan Bora, parked truck No. AS-06-B-7052 on the side of a road at Sukan Pukhuri, Sibsagar, to ease himself.
¶ 4Truck No. AS-23-C-9317, driven from the Dergaon side, rammed the parked truck from behind. The deceased's truck fell on him and he died at the spot.
¶ 4An FIR was registered as Sivasagar PS Case No. 662/2009 under Sections 279/338/304A/427 IPC.
¶ 4The widow filed a claim under Section 166 of the MV Act (MAC Case No. 531/2010).
¶ 5National Insurance Co. Ltd. filed a written statement denying liability. The owner, driver, and United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (insurer of AS-23-C-9317) filed no written statement but cross-examined the claimant's witnesses.
¶ 5, 7The Tribunal awarded Rs. 13,47,500 with 6% interest from the date of filing.
¶ 7National Insurance appealed (MAC 177/2015) against liability and quantum. The claimant appealed (MAC 545/2017) against the Tribunal's rejection of Exhibit-6, an income certificate showing Rs. 15,000 per month.
¶ 3, 2002Issues
i.1. Whether the accident was caused solely by the rash and negligent driving of truck AS-23-C-9317, or whether the deceased's stationary, unlit truck also contributed, so that the insurer's liability should be limited to 50%.
¶ 8, 23–25ii.2. Whether the Tribunal rightly discarded Exhibit-6 and assessed the deceased's income at Rs. 5,000 per month.
¶ 13, 20–22iii.3. Whether the Tribunal erred in computing compensation, including future prospects, personal-expense deduction, and conventional and non-pecuniary heads.
¶ 9–12, 26–3103Law Applied
Section 166 of the MV Act is the statutory basis for the claim.
¶ 5A document's genuineness is proved by examining its author, and any difficulty in securing the author's attendance must be explained.
¶ 21Under the principle of preponderance of probabilities, an uncontroverted charge-sheet may establish the driver's fault.
¶ 25National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680: future prospects of 40% of established income for self-employed or fixed-salary deceased under 40 years.
¶ 27–28National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680: a one-third deduction for personal expenses where there are two or more dependants.
¶ 29National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680: conventional heads fixed at Rs. 15,000 (loss of estate), Rs. 40,000 (consortium), and Rs. 15,000 (funeral), with 10% enhancement every three years.
¶ 30Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 279Section 338Section 427
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 166
04Reasoning
The court found PW-3's testimony unreliable because he contradicted himself on whether the parking lights were on, first in examination-in-chief and then in cross-examination.
¶ 23–24Even without PW-3, the uncontroverted charge-sheet against the driver of AS-23-C-9317 was sufficient to attribute negligence to that driver. The insurer led no evidence to rebut it, so the contributory-negligence plea failed.
¶ 25Exhibit-6 was properly discarded because its author, or anyone from the Dergaon Circle Officer's office, was not examined, and the claimant did not explain this. Although the Tribunal should have given reasons for discarding it, the omission was not a fatal error.
¶ 21The Rs. 5,000 monthly income was upheld because the deceased maintained a truck registered in his wife's name and the insurer led no contrary evidence. The insurer also never pleaded the minimum-wage alternative.
¶ 22The Tribunal erred in applying 50% future prospects instead of 40%, in deducting one-fourth instead of one-third for personal expenses, and in awarding Rs. 1,00,000 per head under non-pecuniary heads, contrary to Pranay Sethi.
¶ 28–30The recomputation yields Rs. 60,000 annual income, less one-third (Rs. 40,000), plus 40% future prospects (Rs. 56,000), multiplied by 15 (Rs. 8,40,000), plus conventional heads totalling Rs. 1,95,000, for a total of Rs. 10,35,000. The funeral and loss of estate figures (Rs. 19,500 each) and the multiplier of 15 are stated without express reasoning.
¶ 3105Holding
The accident was caused by the sole negligence of the driver of AS-23-C-9317. No contributory negligence is attributable to the deceased, and the insurer's 50% limitation plea fails.
¶ 25, 33The Tribunal's rejection of Exhibit-6 and its Rs. 5,000 income finding were upheld.
¶ 21–22MAC Appeal No. 545/2017 is dismissed. MAC Appeal No. 177/2015 is partly allowed. Compensation is reduced from Rs. 13,47,500 to Rs. 10,35,000 under Pranay Sethi guidelines.
¶ 31, 33National Insurance Co. Ltd. is liable to pay Rs. 10,35,000 with 9% interest from the date of filing until payment, less the amount already paid. The mother is to receive Rs. 3,32,000 with accrued interest, and the minor daughter Rs. 3,32,000 with interest, with the balance to the claimant. The insurer must deposit the outstanding dues within four weeks. The records are returned to the Tribunal.
¶ 32, 34, 35Original Court PDF
The National Insurance Company LimitedvsSmti Binita Bora And 3 Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
