Gauhati High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceProperty and Real Estate Law

Whether a sale deed is forged is a question of fact; concurrent findings are not disturbed in second appeal.

Makhanlal Chanda And 2 Ors,v.Smi Shibani Chanda

Whether a sale deed is forged is a question of fact; concurrent findings are not disturbed in second appeal.. Makhanlal Chanda And 2 Ors, vs Smi Shibani Chanda. Gauhati High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the findings of the courts below that Sale Deed Ext. A/1 is a forged document were perverse and illegal, so as to raise a substantial question of law under Section 100 CPC.

The court held

The Court answered the substantial question against the appellants, holding that the concurrent findings that Sale Deed Ext. A/1 (No. 3938 dated 17.12.2011) is forged were not perverse or illegal, and that the question is one of fact not amenable to second appeal review.

It also directed

The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed, and the judgment and decree of the Civil Judge, Hailakandi (08.06.2017 / 17.06.2017) and of the Munsiff No. 1, Hailakandi (29.03.2016 in T.S. 82/2012) are upheld. The trial court records are to be returned.

01Facts

The respondent, Shibani Chanda, is the daughter of late Monindra Chanda and has resided at her matrimonial home since marriage.

¶ 4

Monindra's father, late Mahendra Chanda, had two wives; the appellants, Makhanlal Chanda and his two sons, are the sons of the first wife.

¶ 3

The family separated into separate kitchens after some time.

¶ 5

After her mother's death, the respondent visited the ancestral home to care for her father.

¶ 7

The appellants allegedly pressured Monindra to hand over land, and he sought police help.

¶ 8

Monindra later died.

¶ 8

The appellants told the respondent that Monindra had sold his 5 bighas of land to them for ₹1,00,000.

¶ 9

On obtaining a certified copy of Sale Deed No. 3938 dated 17.12.2011, the respondent found that no identifier of the seller was shown, and that a witness, Motiur Rahman Laskar, was an employee of Makhanlal Chanda.

¶ 9

She pleaded that her literate father signed documents and would not sell such a property for such a small price.

¶ 9

She filed Title Suit No. 82/2012 seeking cancellation of the sale deed.

¶ 10

The Munsiff No. 1, Hailakandi, framed the issue of forgery, held the deed forged, and decreed the suit on 29.03.2016.

¶ 11–12

The Civil Judge, Hailakandi, affirmed on 08.06.2017 in Title Appeal No. 04/2016.

¶ 2, 13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the findings of the courts below that Sale Deed Ext. A/1 is a forged document were perverse and illegal, so as to raise a substantial question of law under Section 100 CPC.

¶ 14

ii.2. Whether the question of forgery is a question of law or fact, and whether the High Court in second appeal may reappreciate evidence.

¶ 17

03Law Applied

The appeal is governed by Section 100 CPC, which permits second appeal only on a substantial question of law.

¶ 2

Concurrent findings of fact may be disturbed in second appeal only where they rest on non-consideration of an important piece of evidence, such as an admission of a party overlooked by both courts; the High Court cannot interfere without sufficient reasons, cannot substitute its own findings contrary to the evidence on record, and cannot reappreciate evidence (G. Mahalingappa v. G.M. Savitha (2005) 6 SCC 441).

¶ 16 · p. 3 · ¶ 17 · pp. 3–4

Whether a document is forged is treated as a question of fact.

¶ 17 · p. 3

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100

04Reasoning

The court first characterised the framed question as one of fact, not law, since it concerned whether Sale Deed No. 3938 was forged, which the trial court decided on evidence adduced by both parties.

¶ 17 · p. 3

The court then examined whether either exception under Mahalingappa applied and found none: there was no admission by any party that the courts overlooked, and the trial court's conclusion rested entirely on the evidence led.

¶ 17 · p. 4

Because the appellate court concurred, the concurrent findings stood. Absent a legal error or an overlooked admission, the court held that it could not reappraise the evidence in second appeal to reach a different view on forgery.

¶ 17–18 · p. 4

The appellants' challenge therefore failed on the substantial question framed.

¶ 14

05Holding

The Court answered the substantial question against the appellants, holding that the concurrent findings that Sale Deed Ext. A/1 (No. 3938 dated 17.12.2011) is forged were not perverse or illegal, and that the question is one of fact not amenable to second appeal review.

¶ 17–18 · p. 4

The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed, and the judgment and decree of the Civil Judge, Hailakandi (08.06.2017 / 17.06.2017) and of the Munsiff No. 1, Hailakandi (29.03.2016 in T.S. 82/2012) are upheld. The trial court records are to be returned.

¶ 2, 18 · p. 4 · ¶ 18 · p. 4
Gauhati High Court

Original Court PDF

Makhanlal Chanda And 2 Ors,vsSmi Shibani Chanda

Gauhati High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment