Gauhati High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceContract Law

Concurrent findings of fact cannot be disturbed in second appeal absent non-consideration of material evidence.

Sri Ramdayal Thakurv.Sri Rameswar Thakur And 2 Ors

Concurrent findings of fact cannot be disturbed in second appeal absent non-consideration of material evidence.. Sri Ramdayal Thakur vs Sri Rameswar Thakur And 2 Ors. Gauhati High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the findings and conclusions of the courts below on Issue No. 1 (existence of cause of action) are perverse in law.

The court held

The challenge to the findings on Issues 1 and 6 raises questions of fact, not substantial questions of law, and the concurrent findings of the courts below could not be disturbed in second appeal.

It also directed

The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed as devoid of merit. The connected interlocutory applications (I.A. (Civil) No. 4314/2017 and I.A. No. 794/2015) are disposed of, and the trial court records are to be returned.

01Facts

Late Ramdayal Thakur purchased 1 Katha (296/144) of land at Mancotta Khanikar, Dibrugarh, under Sale Deed No. 1000 and Sl. No. 146 of 1978, and built a kutcha house on it.

¶ 3–4

The respondents, sons of his brother and his wife, were allowed to live in three kutcha rooms in his house on the condition that they vacate once they found suitable accommodation elsewhere.

¶ 5–7

Ramdayal alleged that they had altered the structure without consent and sued for a declaration of title and eviction.

¶ 9–10

The respondents counter-claimed that Pannalal Thakur had agreed to buy the plot, had paid ₹1,80,000/-, and sought specific performance and a sale deed.

¶ 11–13

The trial court (Munsiff No. 1, Dibrugarh, Title Suit No. 45/2006, decree dated 29.09.2011) framed eight issues, recorded six witnesses in total, and decreed the suit in Ramdayal's favour, directing him to execute a sale deed in favour of Pannalal Thakur.

¶ 15–17

The appellate court (Civil Judge, Dibrugarh, Title Appeal No. 47/2011, judgment dated 12.09.2014) dismissed the respondents' appeal.

¶ 18

The legal heirs of Ramdayal filed the present Regular Second Appeal (RSA/76/2015).

¶ 19

02Issues

i.1. Whether the findings and conclusions of the courts below on Issue No. 1 (existence of cause of action) are perverse in law.

¶ 15 · ¶ 19

ii.2. Whether the findings of the courts below on Issue No. 6 (whether Ramdayal and defendant no. 2 entered into an agreement to sell and purchase the suit land) are perverse in law.

¶ 15 · ¶ 19

03Law Applied

Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which confines a second appeal to substantial questions of law.

¶ 2

G. Mahalingappa v. G.M. Savitha, (2005) 6 SCC 441, which holds that concurrent findings of fact may be interfered with in second appeal only where they rest on non-consideration of an important piece of evidence, such as a party's admission; that the High Court cannot interfere with concurrent findings without sufficient and just reasons; and that it cannot substitute its own findings contrary to the evidence on record.

¶ 22–23

The questions of whether a cause of action exists and whether an agreement to sell was entered into are questions of fact, not law.

¶ 21 · ¶ 24

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100

04Reasoning

The court first classified both Issue No. 1 (cause of action) and Issue No. 6 (agreement to sell) as issues of fact, which took them outside the scope of a second appeal absent a substantial question of law.

¶ 21

It then found that the "substantial question of law" framed by the appellant was, in substance, a question of fact.

¶ 24

The judgment does not identify any admission or material document that the trial and appellate courts overlooked, which is the only recognised ground for disturbing concurrent findings under Mahalingappa.

¶ 22–23

Since the appellants sought re-evaluation of the evidence on Issues 1 and 6, and a second appellate court may not reappreciate evidence, the court declined to interfere with the concurrent findings.

¶ 24–25

The reasoning is brief and does not separately examine the evidence bearing on either issue.

05Holding

The challenge to the findings on Issues 1 and 6 raises questions of fact, not substantial questions of law, and the concurrent findings of the courts below could not be disturbed in second appeal.

¶ 21–24

The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed as devoid of merit. The connected interlocutory applications (I.A. (Civil) No. 4314/2017 and I.A. No. 794/2015) are disposed of, and the trial court records are to be returned.

¶ 25 · p. 6
Gauhati High Court

Original Court PDF

Sri Ramdayal ThakurvsSri Rameswar Thakur And 2 Ors

Gauhati High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment