01Facts
The informant (PW-2) lodged an ejahar on 30.10.2022 alleging that the appellant, his son-in-law, had physically and mentally tortured his daughter (the deceased) over dowry demands and had strangulated her on the night of 29.10.2022.
¶ 3Lakhipur P.S. Case No. 405/2022 was registered under Sections 302/34 IPC.
¶ 3The investigating officer filed a chargesheet against the appellant alone under Section 302 IPC.
¶ 4The prosecution examined seven witnesses.
¶ 6PW-1, PW-2, PW-3, PW-4 and PW-5 were declared hostile and denied their earlier police statements that the appellant tortured and killed the deceased.
¶ 11, 14, 17, 18, 20PW-2 testified that the appellant phoned him at about 3:00 a.m. to report the death.
¶ 13The medical officer (PW-6) found finger-nail contusions on both sides of the neck and opined that death was due to ante-mortem homicidal asphyxia by strangulation.
¶ 23–24The appellant was in a one-room house with his wife and three children aged 9 years or below.
¶ 12, 31In his Section 313 Cr.P.C. statement he claimed he found the deceased dead due to illness.
¶ 43The Sessions Judge, Goalpara, convicted him under Section 302 IPC, sentenced him to rigorous imprisonment for life and a fine of Rs. 10,000/- (in default, six months' simple imprisonment).
¶ 202Issues
i.1. Whether the conviction can be sustained where all non-official prosecution witnesses turned hostile and their police statements are not substantive evidence.
¶ 26, 29, 36, 46–48ii.2. Whether non-examination of the appellant's three minor children by the Investigating Officer vitiates the prosecution case.
¶ 27, 30, 42(1)iii.3. Whether the chain of circumstances was established so as to shift the burden to the appellant under Section 106 of the Evidence Act / Section 109 BSA, and whether his false explanation can serve as an additional link.
¶ 26, 32, 37–4503Law Applied
The court applied Section 302 IPC on murder.
¶ 2For circumstantial evidence, the court relied on the five-fold test from Sharad Birdhichand Sarda (as quoted in Nagendra Sah), requiring that the circumstances be fully established, consistent only with guilt, conclusive, exclusive of every other hypothesis, and forming a complete chain.
¶ 32, 42(2)Section 106 of the Evidence Act (Section 109 BSA) places the burden on a person to explain facts especially within his knowledge, but it does not shift the prosecution's primary burden; it applies only once the prosecution has established a prima facie case.
¶ 37, 40, 42(3), 45Under Deonandan Mishra and Shankarlal, a false explanation may be an additional link only where the prosecution's chain is satisfactorily proved, points to guilt with reasonable definiteness, and is proximate in time and situation.
¶ 42(2), 44Trimukh Maroti Kirkan and Thakur Singh hold that an unexplained death of a spouse in a shared dwelling is a strong incriminating circumstance.
¶ 38, 40Ganeshlal treats a denial without explanation as inconsistent with innocence.
¶ 39Takhaji Hiraji holds that non-examination of witnesses is material only where it leaves a gap that would have been filled by evidence favourable to the prosecution and where the existing evidence is not overwhelming.
¶ 42(1)Renuka Prasad bars conviction based on hostile witnesses' Section 161 Cr.P.C. statements as substantive evidence.
¶ 42(4)Reena Hazarika holds that the onus shifts under Section 106 only after the prosecution establishes a prima facie case.
¶ 42(6)Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302Section 34
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 351
Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 Section 109
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 313Section 161
04Reasoning
The hostile witnesses' evidence could not be wholly discarded; the parts supporting the prosecution case were used, namely that the deceased was found dead on her bed in the appellant's room.
¶ 36Because the informant's account of the 3:00 a.m. phone call was unchallenged, the death was placed during the night, when the door would have been locked from inside. No intruder was shown to be present, so the appellant, sleeping in the same room, was the only realistic perpetrator.
¶ 35, 31The medical evidence, unchallenged, established homicidal manual strangulation.
¶ 34The children's non-examination was not fatal because they were asleep at the time, were not eyewitnesses, and the defence did not suggest an intruder; Takhaji Hiraji therefore did not assist.
¶ 36, 42(1)The court distinguished Nagendra Sah because there other adult family members were present, whereas here the appellant alone shared the room with the deceased and children.
¶ 43The prima facie threshold was met, so the burden under Section 106 / Section 109 BSA validly shifted to the appellant.
¶ 37, 42(3), 44The appellant's "illness" explanation was contradicted by the medical evidence and therefore operated as a false explanation forming an additional link.
¶ 43–44Sivaji Chintappa Patil was distinguished because the death there was not proved to be homicidal.
42(3)Renuka Prasad was distinguished because the convicting court there relied on hostile witnesses' police statements, whereas here no such reliance was placed.
42(4)Jupudi Suresh was distinguished as a suicide/burning case.
42(5)Reena Hazarika was distinguished because it involved contradictory eyewitness accounts and an exculpatory section 313 statement, while here the evidence was consistent.
4805Holding
The prosecution established a complete chain of circumstances against the appellant, comprising the homicidal strangulation, the death in the appellant's one-room house during the night with no intruder, and his false explanation.
¶ 44–48The burden under Section 106 of the Evidence Act / Section 109 BSA was validly shifted to the appellant, and the non-examination of his minor children did not vitiate the prosecution case.
¶ 44–48The appeal was dismissed, the judgment and sentence of the Sessions Judge, Goalpara (conviction under Section 302 IPC; rigorous imprisonment for life; fine of Rs. 10,000/-) were affirmed, and the Trial Court Record was ordered to be returned.
¶ 49–50Original Court PDF
Sanowar HussainvsThe State Of Assam
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
