01Facts
The informant lodged an ejahar on 05.03.2024 alleging that the accused enticed his seven-year-old daughter into his house, committed sexual assault, and gagged her when she cried out.
pp. 2–3 · ¶ 3(1)Dhubri P.S. Case No. 68/2024 was registered under s. 376AB IPC r/w s. 6 POCSO Act. The charge-sheet was filed under the same provisions. The accused pleaded not guilty.
p. 3 · ¶ 3(2)–(3)The prosecution examined ten witnesses. The defence led no evidence.
¶ 4PW-2 (victim) stated that the accused "committed a misdeed" with her, took her inside, locked the door and gagged her mouth. She did not know his name.
¶ 5, PW-2PW-3 (mother) stated that the victim was found in a "half-naked condition" in the accused's house after the door was opened.
¶ 5, PW-3PW-7 (cousin) stated that she saw the victim naked on a bed with the accused lying over her and committing rape. In cross-examination, she said she had gone to school that day for an examination.
¶ 5, PW-7 · ¶ 16PW-6 (sister of both parties) was declared hostile and denied the alleged disclosure to police.
¶ 5, PW-6 · ¶ 12–13PW-8 (Medical Officer) found the hymen intact, redness around the vulva, a fresh fourchette tear with slight bleeding, and no spermatozoa. The opinion was no recent sexual intercourse but evidence of recent genital manipulation.
¶ 5, PW-8, paras 6–8PW-9 (doctor who examined the accused) recorded the accused's admission that he undressed the victim and touched her vulva and vagina, while denying penetration. No sexual intercourse evidence was found on the accused.
¶ 5, PW-9, paras 9–10The trial court convicted the appellant under s. 6 POCSO Act. The appellant appealed against that conviction.
p. 2 · ¶ 202Issues
i.1. Whether the evidence sustains conviction for aggravated penetrative sexual assault under s. 6 POCSO Act, given the victim's vague "misdeed" testimony and the absence of conclusive medical proof of penetration.
¶ 15–18, 22–26, 28, 30ii.2. Whether the accused's statement recorded by PW-9 can be used as an extra-judicial confession to corroborate the victim's testimony.
¶ 29iii.3. Whether the plea of false implication due to a land dispute can be sustained.
¶ 30iv.4. Whether the offence made out is aggravated sexual assault under s. 10 POCSO Act rather than aggravated penetrative sexual assault.
¶ 3103Law Applied
Section 6 POCSO Act (aggravated penetrative sexual assault) was the charged and convicted provision.
p. 2 · ¶ 2Section 10 POCSO Act (aggravated sexual assault) was the substituted provision.
¶ 31A conviction under s. 6 requires proof of penetration, which the medical evidence did not conclusively establish; benefit of doubt goes to the accused where injuries could be caused by means other than penetration.
¶ 30A statement of the accused made to a medical officer may be treated as an extra-judicial confession capable of corroborating the victim's evidence, provided the medical officer has no motive to depose falsely.
¶ 29The medical opinion is the basis for determining the nature of the act where the victim's evidence is insufficient.
¶ 28A plea of false implication must be weighed against positive evidence, medical evidence and admissions.
¶ 30The defence submission that a s. 183 BNSS statement is not substantive evidence was noted but not expressly decided.
¶ 15No precedent was cited by the court.
Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 Section 6Section 10
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 376
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 313Section 164
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 183
04Reasoning
The victim's evidence did not establish penetration. Her testimony used only the word "misdeed," and the Section 183 BNSS statement referring to a finger was not repeated in court.
¶ 15, 26–27PW-7's account of the accused lying over a naked victim was held "difficult to accept" because it conflicted with the victim's prior account of penetration by finger. Her presence at the house, however, was credible, as the victim's location inside the locked house and the accused's presence were established by consistent evidence.
¶ 23–26The medical evidence showed genital manipulation and fourchette tear but no intercourse, and the prosecution did not produce medical literature showing that the injuries could only result from penetration.
¶ 28, 30The accused's admission to PW-9 of touching the vulva and vagina without penetration was accepted as corroborative, as PW-9 had no known motive to falsify.
¶ 29Since the victim's evidence and the medical findings did not establish penetration beyond reasonable doubt, the proved conduct fell within aggravated sexual assault.
¶ 30–31The land-dispute plea was rejected because the accused did not raise it in his defence statement, PW-6 gave no supporting evidence, and the positive evidence and admission excluded false implication.
¶ 3005Holding
The prosecution did not prove aggravated penetrative sexual assault under s. 6 POCSO Act. The offence is altered to aggravated sexual assault under s. 10 POCSO Act.
¶ 31The appeal is partly allowed. The conviction under s. 6 is set aside. The appellant is sentenced to 7 years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 15,000, with 2 months' simple imprisonment in default. The fine is to be paid to the victim as compensation, and the period already undergone is set off. The Trial Court record is to be returned.
¶ 31–32Original Court PDF
Safiuddin AlivsThe State Of Assam
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
