Madras High CourtAdministrative and Public LawHuman Rights Law

Human Rights Commission Cannot Hear Patta Delays Despite Civil Decree; Madras HC Sets Aside Rs 30,000 Award

Sathyanarayananv.The Tamilnadu State Human Rights Commission,

Human Rights Commission Cannot Hear Patta Delays Despite Civil Decree; Madras HC Sets Aside Rs 30,000 Award. Sathyanarayanan vs The Tamilnadu State Human Rights Commission,. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether a complaint alleging failure of revenue authorities to issue patta in accordance with a civil court decree concerns a "civil dispute such as property rights" that the SHRC must not entertain under Regulation 9(d).

The court held

The SHRC cannot entertain complaints concerning civil property disputes, including non-issuance of patta under a civil decree, and "may" in Regulation 9(d) is mandatory in such cases.

It also directed

Regulation 9(h) independently barred the complaint because the matter was covered by a judicial verdict. Laches was not a ground to dismiss the petition.

The impugned order dated 09.03.2020 in SHRC No. 1344 of 2019, including the Rs. 30,000 compensation award, is set aside. The writ petition is allowed and connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.

01Facts

Murugesan was allotted his share on a partition among brothers, reduced to writing. One brother contested, leading to O.S. No. 128 of 2017, a declaratory suit with consequential injunction, decreed on 20.02.2018 as prayed.

¶ 1 / p.2–3

Murugesan applied to the revenue authorities (the writ petitioners) for separate patta under the partition deed and decree. They did not act.

¶ 1 / p.3

Murugesan complained to the State Human Rights Commission (SHRC No. 1344 of 2019) alleging a human rights violation. The Acting Chairperson held that failure to issue patta per a civil decree violated the decree-holder's human rights, and on 09.03.2020 awarded Rs. 30,000 compensation, to be paid by the State and recovered pro rata from the writ petitioners.

¶ 1 / p.3

The writ petitioners filed WP(MD) No. 29213 of 2026 in August 2026, about six years after the order, challenging it under Article 226.

¶ 2 / p.4

The Court declined to non-suit the writ petitioners for laches because the impugned order was "glaringly illegal".

¶ 2 / p.4

02Issues

i.1. Whether a complaint alleging failure of revenue authorities to issue patta in accordance with a civil court decree concerns a "civil dispute such as property rights" that the SHRC must not entertain under Regulation 9(d).

¶ 3, 4 / p.4–5

ii.2. Whether the word "may" in Regulation 9(d) confers discretion on the SHRC or imposes a mandatory bar.

¶ 3 / p.4

iii.3. Whether the SHRC could entertain the complaint in view of Regulation 9(h), where the matter was already the subject of a judicial verdict.

¶ 6 / p.5–6

iv.4. Whether the writ petition should be dismissed on grounds of laches.

¶ 2 / p.4

03Law Applied

Regulation 9(d) of the State Human Rights Commission (Procedure) Regulations, 1997, which permits dismissal in limine of complaints relating to civil disputes such as property rights and contractual obligations.

¶ 3 / p.4

State of U.P. v. Jogendra Singh (AIR 1963 SC 1618), which holds that where a discretionary power is coupled with a public obligation, "may" is to be read as a command.

¶ 3 / p.4

S. Geetharani v. SHRC, WP(MD) No. 15202 of 2022 (order dated 20.08.2026), holding that failure to issue patta cannot be the subject of an SHRC complaint.

¶ 4 / p.5

A.C. Karthikeyan v. SHRC, WP(MD) Nos. 22673 of 2022 (order dated 27.02.2026), which treated Regulation 9(g) (sub judice) as discretionary and was noted without departure.

¶ 5 / p.5

Regulation 9(h), which concerns matters covered by judicial verdict, under which the remedy for non-compliance with a civil decree lies in execution proceedings or a writ of mandamus compelling performance of a statutory duty.

¶ 6 / p.5–6

04Reasoning

A grievance over non-issuance of patta under a civil decree is a property dispute falling within Regulation 9(d). Because Regulation 9(d) is coupled with a duty to keep such matters out of the Commission's domain, "may" operates as a command, making this a "No-Go Zone" for the SHRC; the Court added this caveat to its earlier view in Karthikeyan.

¶ 3, 5 / p.4–5

Independently, the decree in Murugesan's favour was a judicial verdict under Regulation 9(h). If the revenue authorities disregarded it, the appropriate remedy was execution of the decree or a writ of mandamus, not a complaint to the SHRC. The Acting Chairperson therefore "grievously erred" in entertaining the complaint and in treating it as a rights violation warranting compensation.

¶ 6 / p.5–6

The Court declined to dismiss on laches because the impugned order was patently illegal on its face, and refusing relief on delay would have upheld it.

¶ 2 / p.4

05Holding

The SHRC cannot entertain complaints concerning civil property disputes, including non-issuance of patta under a civil decree, and "may" in Regulation 9(d) is mandatory in such cases.

¶ 3, 4, 5 / p.4–5

Regulation 9(h) independently barred the complaint because the matter was covered by a judicial verdict. Laches was not a ground to dismiss the petition.

¶ 6 / p.5–6 · ¶ 2 / p.4

The impugned order dated 09.03.2020 in SHRC No. 1344 of 2019, including the Rs. 30,000 compensation award, is set aside. The writ petition is allowed and connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.

¶ 7 / p.6
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

SathyanarayananvsThe Tamilnadu State Human Rights Commission,

Madras High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment