Madras High CourtAdministrative and Public LawCriminal Law

Madras HC Grants Life Convict 60 More Days Furlough For Medical Treatment, Asks Govt To Decide Extension Pleas In 15 Days

Darthi Padmakumariv.The State of Tamilnadu represented by

Madras HC Grants Life Convict 60 More Days Furlough For Medical Treatment, Asks Govt To Decide Extension Pleas In 15 Days. Darthi Padmakumari vs The State of Tamilnadu represented by. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the absence of a time limit in Rule 14 of the Tamil Nadu Prisons (Release on Furlough) Rules, 2026 permits the Government to keep a representation for extension of furlough pending without decision.

The court held

The Court held that a representation for extension of furlough cannot be kept pending at will merely because Rule 14 prescribes no time limit. Such representations must be disposed of within 15 days, and a prisoner under medical treatment is entitled to relief where the representation is timely.

It also directed

The writ of mandamus was disposed of by directly granting a further 60-day furlough to Life Convict No. 3312 (PID 16913), Vijayakumar, with surrender before the prison on or before 14.01.2027. No costs were awarded.

01Facts

The petitioner's brother, Vijayakumar (Life Convict No. 3312, PID 16913), was convicted under Section 302 IPC in Crime No. 47 of 1990 and is lodged at Palayamkottai Central Prison.

p. 4, Status Report para. 2

On the petitioner's sister's request, the Director General of Prisons sanctioned 60 days' furlough by order dated 07.08.2026. The prisoner was released on 16.09.2026 after executing a surety bond.

p. 5, Status Report para. 3

Furlough was due to expire on 14.11.2026.

p. 2, Order para. 2

On 13.10.2026 (received 14.10.2026), the petitioner sought a further 60-day extension on medical grounds.

p. 3, Order para. 3

The prisoner had been treated as an inpatient from 02.10.2026 to 06.10.2026, and the treating doctor recommended continuous treatment.

p. 3, Order para. 3 · p. 5, Status Report para. 4

Reports were called from the Probation Officer and Police Inspector, and the proposal reached the Director General on 11.11.2026, where it remained under consideration.

p. 6, Status Report para. 5

No decision had been taken, and the matter was pending before the Government.

p. 7, Court para. 3

The Additional Public Prosecutor stated that Rule 14 fixes no time limit for the Government's decision.

p. 7, Court para. 4

02Issues

i.1. Whether the absence of a time limit in Rule 14 of the Tamil Nadu Prisons (Release on Furlough) Rules, 2026 permits the Government to keep a representation for extension of furlough pending without decision.

p. 7, Court para. 3 · p. 7, Court para. 4 · pp. 7–8, Court para. 6

ii.2. Whether a further 60-day furlough should be granted to the prisoner on medical grounds under Rule 6(ii) of the 2026 Rules and G.O.Ms.No.82 dated 14.02.2026.

pp. 2–3, Order para. 2 · p. 8, Court para. 7 · p. 9, Court para. 8

03Law Applied

Rule 6(ii) of the Tamil Nadu Prisons (Release on Furlough) Rules, 2026 permits the Government to sanction furlough for a further period of up to 60 days, for reasons recorded in writing, where necessary in the interests of rehabilitation.

pp. 2–3, Order para. 2

Rule 14 governs Government sanction of further furlough, requires consideration of the Director General's recommendation, and states that the Government's decision is final, but prescribes no time limit.

pp. 3–4, Order para. 4 · p. 7, Court para. 6

Rules 11 and 12 fix time lines only for initial grant of furlough.

p. 7, Court para. 6

G.O.Ms.No.82, Home (Prison-V) Department, dated 14.02.2026, is the government order under which the representation was made.

p. 2, Order para. 2

Rule 15(2)(i) requires a surety bond on release.

p. 5, Status Report para. 3

The Court relied on its earlier decision in Darthi Padmakumar v. State of Tamil Nadu, which granted a further 60-day furlough in a similar situation.

p. 8, Court para. 7

Such representations must be disposed of within 15 days, and representations should be sent at least 30 days before expiry; this timing principle is stated without citation of any further authority.

pp. 8, Court para. 6–7

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302

04Reasoning

The Court held that Rule 14's silence on timelines does not permit the Government to hold a representation for extension indefinitely. Reading the Rules as a whole, it reasoned that an extension representation must be disposed of "in all fairness" within 15 days, since otherwise the prisoner would be compelled to surrender under the original order, with consequences amounting to abscondance and prejudice to future requests. Here the representation was received on 14.10.2026, the furlough expired on 14.11.2026, and no decision had been taken, although the Government had proceeded through the verification steps.

pp. 7–8, Court para. 6 · pp. 6–7, Court para. 3

On the merits, the Court accepted that the prisoner's medical treatment was undisputed and that the representation was filed about 30 days before the furlough period ended, consistent with the timing principle. Relying on Darthi Padmakumar, the Court held the same relief applicable. Rather than remitting the matter to the Government with a time-bound direction, the Court itself granted the extension under its writ jurisdiction. The order does not expressly explain why the Rule 6(ii) written-reasons requirement was satisfied by the Court's own order.

pp. 8, Court para. 6–7 · p. 8, Court para. 7 · p. 9, Court para. 8

05Holding

The Court held that a representation for extension of furlough cannot be kept pending at will merely because Rule 14 prescribes no time limit. Such representations must be disposed of within 15 days, and a prisoner under medical treatment is entitled to relief where the representation is timely.

pp. 7–8, Court para. 6–7

The writ of mandamus was disposed of by directly granting a further 60-day furlough to Life Convict No. 3312 (PID 16913), Vijayakumar, with surrender before the prison on or before 14.01.2027. No costs were awarded.

pp. 9, Court para. 8–9 · p. 9, Court para. 9
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

Darthi PadmakumarivsThe State of Tamilnadu represented by

Madras High Court · November 13, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment