01Facts
The petitioner, P. Durairaj, challenged an order dated 19.06.2021 of the 4th respondent, the President of the Dharmapuri Electricity Schemes Employees Co-operative Thrift and Credit Society Ltd.
pp. 1–2The petitioner also challenged an enquiry report dated 24.09.2021 of the 5th respondent, the enquiry officer, and show-cause notices dated 27.12.2021 and 05.03.2022 issued by the 4th respondent.
pp. 1–2The petitioner sought quashing of these actions, payment of subsistence allowance from 24.09.2016 with interest, and a de novo enquiry by a fresh officer after furnishing documents relating to the charges.
pp. 1–2The writ had been pending since 2022.
¶ 1At the hearing, the petitioner's counsel sought a final order on the enquiry report, based on the petitioner's further representation.
¶ 1The Additional Government Pleader for R1–R3 submitted that final orders would be passed if reasonable time were granted.
¶ 2R4 and R5 did not appear.
p. 102Issues
i.1. Whether the Court should dispose of the writ by directing the Registrar to pass a final order on the enquiry report, without adjudicating the merits of the challenge.
¶ 3ii.2. Whether the 4th respondent should be directed to pay any outstanding subsistence allowance arrears, and within what period.
¶ 303Law Applied
The writ was invoked under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, which confers writ jurisdiction on the High Court.
p. 1Where the competent authority undertakes to decide a pending matter, the Court may direct it to pass a reasoned final order "according to its own merits and in accordance with law" within a fixed period, without deciding the merits itself.
¶ 3The principle that subsistence allowance is payable during suspension, and its arrears are recoverable, is implicit in the direction to pay arrears, but no source is identified.
¶ 3 · no citationThe order cites no statutory provision, co-operative societies enactment, or precedent.
04Reasoning
The Court accepted the Additional Government Pleader's undertaking that final orders would be passed, and on that basis expressly declined to examine the merits "without going into the merits of the matter."
¶ 3The Court fixed six weeks from receipt of the order for the Registrar (R1) to decide the enquiry report, leaving the authority free to assess the petitioner's further representation.
¶ 3Because the petitioner's principal grievance was the pendency of the enquiry-based decision since 2022 and the non-payment of subsistence allowance, the Court addressed the second by directing R4 to pay any arrears within twelve weeks, conditionally on arrears existing.
¶ 3The order resolves the delay without deciding the validity of the 2021 order, the enquiry report, or the show-cause notices.
¶ 3 · pp. 1–205Holding
The Court disposed of the writ petition without adjudicating its merits.
¶ 3The Court directed R1 to pass final orders on the enquiry report dated 24.09.2021 according to its own merits and in accordance with law, within six weeks of receiving a copy of the order.
¶ 3The Court directed R4 to pay any subsistence allowance arrears within twelve weeks of receiving a copy of the order.
¶ 3No costs were awarded, and the connected WMPs (Nos. 7860, 7862 of 2022 and 9516 of 2023) were closed. The prayers for quashing the 2021 order, the show-cause notices, and a de novo enquiry were not decided.
¶ 3Original Court PDF
P.DurairajvsThe Registrar of Co-Operative societies
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
