01Facts
The parties married on 01.12.2016 according to Hindu rites, and a daughter was born of the marriage.
¶ 3The wife filed M.C. No. 63/2021 under s. 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, alleging that the husband was habitually intoxicated, abused and physically beat her, harassed her for further dowry, was sent to a rehabilitation centre for de-addiction, was a womanizer and gambler, and failed to maintain her and the child.
¶ 3-4The husband admitted the marriage and the daughter but denied the cruelty allegations, asserting that the wife neglected marital duties, insulted his parents, repeatedly left the matrimonial home, and failed to rejoin him after he shifted to Bangalore.
¶ 5The husband separately filed M.C. No. 45/2023 under s. 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act for restitution of conjugal rights, which the wife opposed.
¶ 8The wife produced Exs. P1-P22, including photographs (Exs. P1-P10) and an FIR in Crime No. 30/2020 (Ex. P22), and the husband produced Exs. R1-R9.
¶ 6, 15The Family Court allowed M.C. No. 63/2021, dissolving the marriage, and dismissed M.C. No. 45/2023 by a common judgment dated 22.03.2025.
¶ 7-9The husband appealed both orders.
¶ 1-2In cross-examination, the wife testified that the husband's parents advised her to return to her parental home because the house was unsafe while he was intoxicated.
¶ 16The husband admitted in cross-examination that he had received hospital treatment and had been sent to rehabilitation centres for de-addiction.
¶ 17The wife's allegation that the husband forced her to have sexual intercourse with his friends was pleaded and deposed to but not rebutted.
¶ 19, 2402Issues
i.1. Whether the Family Court's judgment in M.C. No. 63/2021, dissolving the marriage under s. 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 on grounds of cruelty, is perverse or illegal and warrants interference.
¶ 14, 26ii.2. Whether the Family Court's judgment in M.C. No. 45/2023, dismissing the husband's s. 9 Hindu Marriage Act petition for restitution of conjugal rights, is perverse or illegal and warrants interference.
¶ 14, 2503Law Applied
Section 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, under which cruelty and desertion are grounds for dissolution of marriage.
¶ 2, 25Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, on restitution of conjugal rights, which the husband invoked.
¶ 1, 25Samar Ghosh v. Jaya Ghosh, (2007) 4 SCC 511, which holds that mental cruelty has no exhaustive definition, must be judged on the entire matrimonial relationship, and may be shown by sustained abusive, humiliating, or reprehensible conduct, as illustrated in para. 101.
¶ 23Roopa Soni v. Kamalnarayan Soni, (2023) 16 SCC 615, which holds that cruelty requires a liberal and contextual interpretation in a wife's petition, with an element of subjectivity, and that the standard of proof in matrimonial cases is preponderance of probabilities.
¶ 23Appeals lie under s. 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984.
¶ 1-2Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Family Courts Act, 1984 Section 19
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 Section 9Section 13
04Reasoning
The court examined the wife's oral evidence, the photographs (Exs. P1-P10), the FIR (Ex. P22), and the husband's admissions in cross-examination regarding de-addiction treatment and hospitalisation.
¶ 15-17It found that these materials showed the husband's conduct under alcoholic influence and physical assaults on the wife, which the court characterised as a sustained course of abusive and humiliating treatment.
¶ 18, 24The unrebutted allegation of sexual coercion further supported this finding.
¶ 19, 24The court also relied on the Family Court's observations regarding the husband's conduct in court and his medical condition, which it held showed that no conducive atmosphere existed for resumption of cohabitation.
¶ 20-21Applying Samar Ghosh and Roopa Soni, the court held that the cumulative conduct amounted to grave physical and mental cruelty, making it unreasonable to expect the wife to continue the marriage.
¶ 25-26Because cruelty was established, the husband's mere willingness to resume cohabitation could not sustain a decree under s. 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, since the wife had reasonable cause to live apart.
¶ 2505Holding
Both issues are answered in the negative. The Family Court's findings of cruelty under s. 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, and its refusal of restitution under s. 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, were supported by the record and did not warrant interference.
¶ 26, 27Both appeals (MFA Nos. 201771/2025 and 201790/2025) are dismissed. The judgments dated 22.03.2025 in M.C. No. 45/2023 and M.C. No. 63/2021 passed by the Principal Judge, Family Court, Raichur, are confirmed. No order as to costs.
¶ 27Original Court PDF
AKSHAT B HADDANAVARvsSMT SEETHSA H
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
