01Facts
The parties married on 04.12.1980 at St. Sebastian Church, Bendoor, Mangaluru, and have a daughter (b. 1982) and a son (b. 1992).
¶ 3 · ¶ 27The wife alleged that the husband, who worked abroad (Iraq, then Saudi Arabia), insulted her from the start of the marriage, subjected the daughter to physical ill-treatment in 1984, mixed Harpic in her dosa batter in 2010, disconnected electricity when the daughter's family was staying in the house, pressed a bamboo stick against the son's neck, and sent an abusive message threatening she would never see her son again.
¶ 4–6 · ¶ 28–29 · ¶ 31 · ¶ 33 · ¶ 36–37The husband denied cruelty and desertion, pleaded a long happy marriage, and claimed contribution to the Bondel property, which the wife had sued to protect in O.S. No. 40/2019.
¶ 9–11The husband sought restitution of conjugal rights in M.C. No. 69/2021.
¶ 12The Family Court in M.C. No. 77/2021 found cruelty established, dissolved the marriage on that ground, and awarded Rs. 5,00,000 compensation under s. 22 of the DV Act and Rs. 20,000 costs, but rejected desertion, permanent alimony (s. 36) and the husband's restitution petition.
¶ 15–20The husband appealed under s. 55 of the Indian Divorce Act, 1869.
¶ 1 · ¶ 2102Issues
i.1. Whether the Family Court's finding of cruelty against the husband is supported by the evidence and is free from perversity, misreading or legal infirmity.
¶ 26 · ¶ 45ii.2. Whether the husband's Harpic explanation, raised for the first time in cross-examination, can be accepted, and what adverse inference follows.
¶ 31–32iii.3. Whether the cumulative conduct proved establishes a reasonable apprehension of harm in the wife in continuing to live with him.
¶ 37–38iv.4. Whether the husband's expressed wish to resume cohabitation, and the pending property dispute, outweigh the proved maltreatment.
¶ 39–41v.5. Whether the compensation of Rs. 5,00,000 and costs of Rs. 20,000 are sustainable given the husband's age and finances.
¶ 24 · ¶ 4403Law Applied
The Indian Divorce Act, 1869, under which dissolution was granted on cruelty under s. 10(1)(x).
¶ 44Restitution of conjugal rights is sought under s. 32 of the Indian Divorce Act, 1869.
¶ 12 · ¶ 40Permanent alimony under s. 36 of the Indian Divorce Act, 1869 was considered and refused.
¶ 19 · ¶ 44The appeal lies under s. 55 of the Indian Divorce Act, 1869.
¶ 1Section 22 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, supports the compensation award.
¶ 20 · ¶ 44Section 65B of the Evidence Act governs the admissibility of the electronic message (Ex. P9).
¶ 33Repeated insults, ill-treatment of children and abusive conduct cumulatively may constitute cruelty and create a reasonable apprehension of harm, and must be assessed cumulatively rather than incident by incident.
¶ 37–38 · ¶ 35A defence first raised in cross-examination and not pleaded earlier may support an adverse inference.
¶ 32A restitution request must be weighed against the requesting spouse's conduct.
¶ 41A pending property dispute does not negate proved cruelty.
¶ 40No precedents are cited in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Divorce Act, 1869 Section 10Section 32Section 36Section 55
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 Section 22
04Reasoning
The Family Court's findings were grounded in the consistent testimony of the wife (PW.1) and daughter (PW.2), which survived cross-examination, and in admissions by RW.1 regarding the message and the electricity disconnection.
¶ 30 · ¶ 35–36The husband's new claim that the wife mixed Harpic was rejected because it was not pleaded in his objections, and the court held the probabilities favoured the wife.
¶ 31–32The message's abusive language and threat to the son were held not to be an ordinary domestic reaction.
¶ 35Each incident, though capable of innocent explanation in isolation, formed a course of conduct that created a reasonable apprehension of harm in the wife.
¶ 37–38The pending O.S. No. 40/2019 did not explain or erase these incidents.
¶ 40The husband's restitution petition did not outweigh the proved maltreatment, given that his request had to be judged by his own conduct.
¶ 41The Family Court separated the desertion ground, which failed for want of the two-year statutory period, from the cruelty ground, which succeeded.
¶ 43No perversity or misreading of evidence was found in the award of compensation and costs, and the alimony refusal was not disturbed.
¶ 44–4505Holding
The husband failed to show any ground for interference with the Family Court's judgment dated 17.12.2022 in M.C. No. 77/2021.
¶ 45The findings on cruelty, the dissolution of marriage, the Rs. 5,00,000 DV Act compensation and the Rs. 20,000 costs were affirmed.
¶ 44 · Order, cl. 2The appeal was dismissed, and I.A. No. 1/2024 was disposed of as not surviving.
¶ 45 · Order, cl. 1 · Order, final para.The refusal of desertion, permanent alimony and restitution was not challenged and stands as decided by the Family Court.
¶ 19–20 · ¶ 43Original Court PDF
MR. XAVIER NORONHAvsMRS. ALICE NORONHA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
