Karnataka High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceContract Law

Interest on a non-commercial loan under Section 34 CPC is capped at six percent absent proof of a commercial transaction.

SRI. M. VENKATESHAPPAv.SRI B.D. VENKATESH

Interest on a non-commercial loan under Section 34 CPC is capped at six percent absent proof of a commercial transaction.. SRI. M. VENKATESHAPPA vs SRI B.D. VENKATESH. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Courts below were justified in decreeing the suit on interest at 24% p.a. on Rs.3,25,000/- when the defendant proved receipt of only Rs.3,00,000/- and payment of interest till March 2015.

The court held

The Court answered Substantial Questions 1–3 against the appellant, confirming the finding that Rs.5,92,000/- (recorded in the order as Rs.5,92,900/-) was due and rejecting the counterclaim.

It also directed

The Court answered Substantial Questions 4–6 in the appellant's favour, holding that the enhancement to 12% p.a. was impermissible under Section 34 CPC on these facts.

Orders: (i) the appeal is partly allowed; (ii) the rejection of the counterclaim is confirmed; (iii) the decree for the principal sum is confirmed; (iv) the first appellate court's 12% award is set aside; (v) the trial court's 6% p.a. interest from the date of suit is restored; (vi) because the appellant deposited Rs.4,90,750/- on 22.04.2022, covering interest at 6% to that date, no interest accrues from the date of deposit; (vii) the deposited amount is to be transmitted to the trial court for disbursement to the plaintiff; and (viii) no further amount is payable.

01Facts

The respondent-plaintiff (B.D. Venkatesh) sued the appellant-defendant (M. Venkateshappa) in O.S. No. 285/2015 for Rs.5,92,900/- with 24% p.a. interest, alleging a hand loan of Rs.3,25,000/- advanced on 30.11.2012 and secured by a registered mortgage deed (Ex.P1) over Sy.No.10, Kadirenahalli village.

pp. 2–3

The defendant admitted execution of Ex.P1 and receipt of a loan, but contended that he received only Rs.3,00,000/-, that he paid interest up to March 2015, and that blank cheques and stamp papers given to the plaintiff were misused.

pp. 2, 4–6

The defendant counterclaimed redemption of the mortgage on payment of principal.

p. 3, 7

The trial court found the loan of Rs.3,25,000/- proved, rejected the interest defence for want of documents, and partly decreed the suit for Rs.5,92,900/- with 6% p.a. interest from the date of suit, reasoning that 24% was exorbitant and that the plaintiff held no money-lending licence.

pp. 4–10

The counterclaim was dismissed by the trial court.

pp. 9–10

On cross-appeal, the first appellate court dismissed the defendant's appeal and enhanced interest to 12% p.a. from the date of suit.

pp. 10–11, 27–28

The defendant's second appeal raised six substantial questions of law.

pp. 29–31

During pendency of the second appeal, the defendant deposited Rs.4,90,750/- on 22.04.2022.

pp. 34–35

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Courts below were justified in decreeing the suit on interest at 24% p.a. on Rs.3,25,000/- when the defendant proved receipt of only Rs.3,00,000/- and payment of interest till March 2015.

pp. 29–30, SQ i

ii.2. Whether the trial court was justified in rejecting the defendant's counterclaim for redemption of the mortgage despite his readiness to repay principal.

p. 30, SQ ii

iii.3. Whether the first appellate court was justified in allowing the plaintiff's cross-objections and dismissing the defendant's appeal.

p. 30, SQ iii

iv.4. Whether the first appellate court was justified in enhancing interest from 6% to 12% p.a. when the transaction was not commercial and the plaintiff was not a licensed money-lender.

p. 30, SQ iv · pp. 33–34

v.5. Whether the first appellate court correctly relied on Tahira Rehman v. Manipal Sowbhagya Nidhi Ltd., (2017) 5 Kar.L.J. 378, on the facts of this case.

p. 31, SQ v · p. 33

vi.6. Whether the enhancement of interest to 12% p.a. is contrary to Section 34 CPC.

p. 31, SQ vi · pp. 32–33

03Law Applied

The presumption of correctness attached to a registered document, and the principle that a party admitting execution cannot deny its contents, under which a defendant who blows hot and cold may not take a self-destructive stance.

pp. 14–15, first appellate reasoning adopted at p.31

Section 34 CPC, under which the court has discretion to award interest at a reasonable rate, with the proviso permitting rates above 6% only for commercial transactions and up to the contractual rate.

p. 25 · pp. 32–33

Sections 2(9), 2(10) and 11 of the Karnataka Money Lenders' Act, 1961, under which a money-lender must hold a valid licence to obtain a decree, and "loan" excludes transactions not in substance advances at interest.

pp. 17–21

Sections 3 and 5 of the Interest Act, 1978, under which contractual interest prevails but court discretion under Section 34 CPC is preserved.

pp. 23–25

Tahira Rehman v. Manipal Sowbhagya Nidhi Ltd., (2017) 5 Kar.L.J. 378, which applied enhanced interest on a commercial loan, together with authorities on money-lender licensing, including Kalojitalusappa Gangavathi and Surasaibalini Debi.

pp. 18–23 · pp. 31–33

Provisions in the judgment · 9 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100Section 96Section 34

KARNATAKA MONEY-LENDERS ACT, 1961 Section 11Section 2Section 28Section 29

Interest Act, 1978 Section 3Section 5

04Reasoning

On the principal amount, the registered Ex.P1 recorded Rs.3,25,000/-, the defendant admitted execution and receipt of a loan, and his bare denial of the extra Rs.25,000/- did not rebut the presumption. The attesting witnesses' lack of knowledge of the negotiations did not defeat the plaintiff's case.

p. 31

The interest defence failed for want of any documentary proof.

p. 4, 7

On the counterclaim, redemption depended on payment of the full adjudged sum, which the defendant had not made.

pp. 7–9

On interest, the first appellate court erred. The mortgage deed did not state any commercial purpose, nothing was elicited from the defendant on that point, and the plaintiff admitted he was not a money-lender.

pp. 16–17, 21

Tahira Rehman involved a commercial loan to a contractor and a partnership firm, and the Court held it factually distinguishable.

p. 33

Enhancement to 12% therefore had no basis in the Section 34 CPC framework. The trial court's 6% award, though not explicitly reasoned in the depth the Court would have preferred, was consistent with that framework and was restored.

pp. 32–33

05Holding

The Court answered Substantial Questions 1–3 against the appellant, confirming the finding that Rs.5,92,000/- (recorded in the order as Rs.5,92,900/-) was due and rejecting the counterclaim.

p. 31

The Court answered Substantial Questions 4–6 in the appellant's favour, holding that the enhancement to 12% p.a. was impermissible under Section 34 CPC on these facts.

pp. 32–34

Orders: (i) the appeal is partly allowed; (ii) the rejection of the counterclaim is confirmed; (iii) the decree for the principal sum is confirmed; (iv) the first appellate court's 12% award is set aside; (v) the trial court's 6% p.a. interest from the date of suit is restored; (vi) because the appellant deposited Rs.4,90,750/- on 22.04.2022, covering interest at 6% to that date, no interest accrues from the date of deposit; (vii) the deposited amount is to be transmitted to the trial court for disbursement to the plaintiff; and (viii) no further amount is payable.

pp. 34–36
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SRI. M. VENKATESHAPPAvsSRI B.D. VENKATESH

Karnataka High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment