01Facts
The accused, C. Anand, was convicted under s. 302 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment and a fine of ₹50,000 by the trial court on 02.09.2021.
p. 2The prosecution case is that the deceased, Prakash, had earlier stolen the accused's mobile phone and assaulted him and his mother.
¶ 3On 02.08.2016, after a quarrel at Shubha Bar, Anekal, the accused assaulted the deceased with a chopper on the hand; PWs 5 and 6 intervened.
¶ 3The accused then stayed at Mathura Nagara until 06.08.2016, apprehending danger.
¶ 3On 07.08.2016 at about 7.00 p.m., he allegedly threw chilli powder on the deceased and assaulted him with a long (iron long).
¶ 3The complainant, PW1 (the deceased's brother), was not an eyewitness; his complaint (Ex.P1) states that the accused and four others killed the deceased.
¶ 4–5, 7PW2 (grandmother) is the only eyewitness, and her testimony was relied upon as the sole eyewitness account.
¶ 8–9, 24PW4 turned hostile, and PW7 was also hostile and not an eyewitness.
¶ 10–11The post-mortem (Ex.P13) recorded haemorrhage and shock from multiple injuries.
¶ 12The accused had a deep lacerated palm injury, which the MLC (Ex.P16) records as caused by the deceased with a sickle/chopper.
¶ 20–21Statements of PWs 3, 4 and 5 were recorded on 16.08.2016 and PW2's on 17.08.2016, and they were not recorded during inquest.
¶ 24The deceased had a rowdy sheet and prior murder case involvement.
¶ 2502Issues
i.1. Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt, through the testimony of the sole eyewitness (PW2), that the accused committed the murder of the deceased under s. 302 IPC.
¶ 24, 27ii.2. Whether the discrepancy regarding the weapon (iron long versus iron rod/knife) casts doubt on the prosecution case.
¶ 13–16iii.3. Whether the unexplained grievous injuries to the accused and the delayed recording of witness statements create a reasonable doubt regarding the genesis of the incident.
¶ 17–24, 27iv.4. Whether prior enmity and motive could support the defence plea of false implication, such that the accused is entitled to the benefit of doubt.
¶ 25–2703Law Applied
Section 302 IPC on murder, under which the prosecution must prove the offence beyond reasonable doubt.
¶ 27Aslam alias Imran v. State of Madhya Pradesh (SLP (Crl.) No. 15254/2024), which held that enmity is a "double-edged weapon": while it supplies motive, it also does not exclude false implication, and where such a possibility arises the accused is entitled to the benefit of doubt.
¶ 22–23The principle that unexplained injuries to the accused and inordinate delay in recording witness statements may cast doubt on the genesis of the incident.
¶ 24, 27Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 374
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302
04Reasoning
The weapon discrepancy did not dent the prosecution case on the use of a weapon, since the doctor's opinion (Ex.P15) examined an iron long and the injuries were consistent with such a weapon, and it was not the defence's case that an iron rod was used.
¶ 15–16The court did not rest its decision on the weapon discrepancy. Its main reasoning concerned PW2's credibility. The accused's injuries were grievous and were recorded in Ex.P16 as caused by the deceased with a chopper/sickle, yet PW2 offered a new explanation (that the accused was hurt while the deceased tried to snatch the weapon), which was not in the complaint and was not explained by the police witnesses.
¶ 17–21PWs 3, 4 and 5 and PW2 gave statements belatedly, without reasons, and this, together with the Ex.P16 history, raised a reasonable doubt about the genesis of the incident.
¶ 24, 27On motive, the court accepted that the prior quarrel and the earlier assault by the accused could give the deceased a motive to attack, and that the deceased had a criminal background.
¶ 25Applying Aslam, the court held that enmity cuts both ways and that false implication could not be ruled out.
¶ 23, 27PW2 did not mention the four other persons who allegedly accompanied the accused in the complaint or her chief examination, and the police explanation for this was unsatisfactory.
¶ 2605Holding
PW2's evidence is not trustworthy enough to prove the s. 302 charge beyond reasonable doubt.
¶ 27Because of the delayed recording of witness statements, the unexplained grievous injuries to the accused, and the possibility of false implication arising from enmity, the accused was entitled to the benefit of doubt.
¶ 27The appeal is allowed. The judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 02.09.2021 in S.C. No. 5021/2017 are set aside, and the accused is acquitted of the offence under s. 302 IPC. He is to be released from prison if not required in any other case. The Registry is directed to communicate the order to the trial court and the concerned prison authority.
p. 21Original Court PDF
C. ANANDvsSTATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
