01Facts
The complainant, wife of a doctor (the prospective tenant), alleged that the accused, owner of premises at Sri Krishna Nagar, Byrathi Bande, Bengaluru, agreed on 23.01.2020 to lease the property for ten years at ₹1,75,000 per month, and received ₹35,00,000 as advance.
¶ 4Possession was delayed, the COVID-19 pandemic intervened, and further draft agreements followed in 2020 and 2021.
¶ 4 · ¶ 44The lessee's husband sued in O.S. No. 425/2021, which was referred to Lok Adalat. The accused paid ₹11,20,000 and issued cheque No. 000063 dated 17.01.2022 for ₹36,00,000 in the complainant's name.
¶ 4The cheque was dishonoured on 18.01.2022 with the endorsement "drawer's signature differs".
¶ 4 · ¶ 23Notices dated 14.02.2022 and 09.03.2022 were issued on behalf of the husband, not the complainant.
¶ 23 · ¶ 32The complainant's own notice dated 26.04.2022 was returned "unclaimed".
¶ 23The complaint was filed on 27.05.2022.
¶ 23The trial court convicted the accused and imposed a fine of ₹41,75,000, of which ₹41,70,000 was payable as compensation. The appellate court affirmed.
¶ 6 · ¶ 8The accused contended that he never transacted with the complainant, that the signature on the cheque was not his, and that the complainant lacked locus standi, relying on a partnership deed (Ex. P-12) dated 27.01.2020.
¶ 11–12, 40, 43The accused did not lead defence evidence.
¶ 502Issues
i.1. Whether the revision petitioner establishes that the judgments of the trial court and appellate court are perverse, grossly erroneous, glaringly unreasonable, wholly unreliable or untenable, or based on immaterial/no material or non-consideration of relevant material, warranting interference in revision.
¶ 16ii.2. Whether the complainant, who was not a party to the lease transaction, can maintain a prosecution under Section 138 N.I. Act, and whether the complainant established that the cheque bore the accused's signature and was issued for a legally enforceable debt.
¶ 22, 49–5103Law Applied
The Court applied the limited scope of revisional jurisdiction under Section 397 read with Section 401 Cr.P.C., as restated in Kuntegowda v. Thurubaiah (2026 SCC OnLine SC 1485), which relied on State of Maharashtra v. Jagmohan Singh Kuldip Singh Anand and State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri. Interference is permitted only where the lower court's findings are perverse, grossly erroneous, or wholly unreliable, or where relevant material was ignored or discretion was exercised arbitrarily.
¶ 18–19The ingredients of Section 138 N.I. Act are a legally enforceable debt, a cheque drawn on the accused's account, timely presentation, dishonour, statutory demand notice, non-payment, and complaint within time.
¶ 20Sections 118 and 139 N.I. Act raise rebuttable presumptions, but these arise only once the foundational facts (ingredients (iii) to (vii)) are established.
¶ 21, 25M/s Laxmi Dyechem v. State of Gujarat (2012) 13 SCC 375 holds that signature-mismatch dishonour can fall within Section 138 N.I. Act.
¶ 27Ravichandra v. Rosi Line Reena Rani was distinguished on the ground that Laxmi Dyechem was not examined there.
¶ 28K. Damodaran v. M. Shivarama Reddy (AIR Online 2023 Kar 2299) holds that the complainant must first prove the accused's signature.
¶ 35Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar (AIR 2019 SC 2446) addresses the presumption of liability of a signatory.
¶ 46Mrs. Sujan Sawant v. Dr. Kamlakant Shantaram Desai (AIR 2004 Bom 446) addresses the effect of partnership capital contributions.
¶ 41The Supreme Court's suo motu order in M.A. No. 21/2022 (W.P.(C) No. 3/2020) excludes 15.02.2020 to 28.02.2022 from limitation.
¶ 33, 36Provisions in the judgment · 11 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 397Section 401Section 200Section 313
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138Section 139Section 118Section 20Section 87
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 438Section 442
04Reasoning
The trial and appellate courts did not examine the complainant's locus standi or the identity of the signatory. The two earlier notices were issued by the husband, who is a distinct person, so they could not satisfy the demand requirement for the complainant.
¶ 32The complainant's own notice of 26.04.2022 was returned unclaimed, and the notice was not shown to be defective or withdrawn on the record.
¶ 36The signature mismatch was documented by the bank endorsement "drawer's signature differs".
¶ 26, 30Unlike Laxmi Dyechem, where a deliberate change of specimen signature was in issue, the complainant did not allege that the accused deliberately altered his signature to deceive her.
¶ 29–31Because the complainant failed to establish the accused's signature on the cheque, the foundational facts for the Section 139 presumption were not met, and the presumption could not be invoked.
¶ 25, 49No transaction between the complainant and the accused was found. The lease, the joint memos, the civil suit, and the commercial suit were all between the accused and the husband.
¶ 38–40, 50The partnership deed (Ex. P-12) was executed after the lease, did not mention the lease advance or the property, and gave the complainant no authority to claim the husband's dues.
¶ 42–43The complainant admitted in cross-examination that she knew nothing of the transaction.
¶ 45The lower courts' findings were grossly erroneous and failed to appreciate the evidence properly, which justified interference in revision.
¶ 51–5205Holding
The first issue is answered in the affirmative. The concurrent findings of conviction were held grossly erroneous and not supported by proper appreciation of the evidence, which warranted interference in revision.
¶ 17, 52On the second issue, the complainant was not a party to the transaction, did not establish that the accused signed the cheque, and failed to prove a legally enforceable debt owed to her, so Section 138 N.I. Act was not made out.
¶ 51, 43The trial court's judgment dated 18.07.2023 in C.C. No. 53235/2022 and the appellate judgment dated 03.09.2024 in Crl.A. No. 25221/2023 were held liable to be set aside.
¶ 52–53The revision petition was allowed. The accused was acquitted of the offence under Section 138 N.I. Act, and the amount deposited was ordered refunded to him on proper identification.
¶ 53Original Court PDF
SRI BALAJIvsSMT SHAKILA PURUSHOTHAM
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
