01Facts
The accused was convicted by the Special Second Additional District and Sessions Judge, Chitradurga, in Spl.C (POCSO) No. 162/2018 under Sections 366 and 376(2)(n) IPC and Sections 4 and 8 POCSO Act, 2012.
¶ 2–5He received life imprisonment with a Rs. 30,000 fine under Section 376(2)(n), 10 years under Section 366, 7 years under Section 4 POCSO, and 5 years under Section 8 POCSO.
¶ 2–5The prosecution case was that the accused, who was in love with the victim, a flower vendor, induced her on 20/21.01.2018 with a promise of marriage, took her to Bengaluru, and repeatedly sexually assaulted her in a rented house at Kaggalipura until she was left at the Chitradurga KSRTC bus stand on 19.03.2018.
¶ 7, 15, 17The mother's complaint (Ex.P7) led to the registration of the case.
¶ 8, 16The prosecution relied on the victim's statements (Ex.P1 and Ex.P6 under Section 164 Cr.P.C.), the medical report (Ex.P12), and PW-1 to PW-12.
¶ 10, 16, 30The prosecution's sole proof of age was a school certificate (Ex.P10) issued by the Headmaster (PW-7), showing date of birth 11.10.2000.
¶ 14, 19, 23The defence argued that Ex.P10 was unreliable and that the victim had voluntarily stayed with the accused for two months and told the doctor she had married him.
¶ 12, 3002Issues
i.1. Whether the prosecution proved, through cogent and acceptable evidence, that the victim was a minor below 18 years on the date of the incident.
¶ 20, 23–28, 32ii.2. Whether the victim's conduct, including her voluntary accompaniment and stay with the accused, displaces the prosecution case of kidnapping, sexual assault, and coercion.
¶ 12, 29, 3203Law Applied
Section 94(2) of the Juvenile Justice Act, as construed in P. Yuvaprakash v. State (2024) 17 SCC 684, holds that age disputes in POCSO cases must be determined in the hierarchy of a school date-of-birth certificate or matriculation certificate, then a municipal or panchayat birth certificate, and only then an ossification or medical age test.
¶ 15–16, 20–21, 24Sunil v. State of Haryana (2010) 1 SCC 742, following Birad Mal Singhvi, holds that a school register entry has no evidentiary value unless the person who made the entry or who furnished the date of birth is examined, and that a school record procured after the arrest is unreliable.
¶ 19, 22Rishipal Singh Solanki v. State of U.P. (2022) 8 SCC 602 gives preference to the date-of-birth certificate from the school first attended.
¶ 25–26Abuzar Hossain v. State of West Bengal places the burden of proving juvenility on the person claiming it.
¶ 27Unexplained delay and conduct inconsistent with coercion weigh against the prosecution's case of force.
¶ 29, 32Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 374Section 164Section 313
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 366Section 376
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 Section 4Section 8
Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015. Section 94
04Reasoning
Ex.P10 was not a reliable proof of age. It did not indicate when the victim first attended school or in which standard she was admitted, the entry-maker (PW-7) did not state that he made the register entry or who supplied the date of birth, and the school register was not produced.
¶ 23–24, 28The victim's mother, PW-2, is illiterate and could not state the date of birth, and the prosecution produced no birth certificate or medical age test.
¶ 24, 28Applying Yuvaprakash, Sunil, and Rishipal Singh Solanki, the court found the statutory hierarchy unmet and the age unproven.
¶ 26, 28The victim left with the accused willingly, lived with him for about two months, did not complain to the house owner or anyone else despite opportunities, and told the doctor she had married the accused.
¶ 29–30Her alleged threat (poison bottle) was absent from her Section 161 statement, and her Section 164 statement described being "in love" with the accused.
¶ 29, 32The owner, Gurappa Reddy, was not examined.
¶ 29The coercion and kidnapping narrative was found unproven.
¶ 3205Holding
The prosecution failed to prove by cogent and acceptable evidence that the victim was a minor on the date of the incident, and the charges were not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
¶ 28, 32The appeal is allowed. The judgment of conviction dated 12.03.2019 and the sentencing order dated 13.03.2019 are set aside, and the accused is acquitted of all charges and directed to be released if not required in any other case. The direction to the District Legal Services Authority, Chitradurga, to consider and award compensation to PW-1 under the trial court's order remains intact.
Order (ii)–(iv)Original Court PDF
THIPPESWAMYvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
