01Facts
The petitioners, defendants in O.S. No. 3975/2010, a suit for declaration and injunction instituted in 2010, challenged the order dated 22.08.2026 of the VII Addl. City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru, rejecting I.A. Nos. 14 and 15.
¶ 1Those applications sought reopening of the case and further cross-examination of PW.1
¶ 1Earlier, the petitioners' application for the same relief had been rejected.
This Court set that rejection aside in W.P. No. 22236/2021 by order dated 18.12.2025, permitting cross-examination subject to costs
¶ 6That writ petition remained pending for nearly four years, during which the suit proceedings stayed
¶ 6The petitioners submitted that PW.1 was cross-examined, but the cross-examination was adjourned at the Court's instance owing to paucity of time, and that they had otherwise availed the permitted opportunities except on two occasions
¶ 2 · ¶ 2.1The suit was still at the evidence stage after 16 years, with no compelling reason for the delay
¶ 5Adjournments were not recorded as sought by the petitioners, though the possibility of judicial adjournment for want of time could not be discounted
¶ 7The suit had suffered nearly six years of delay at the petitioners' instance, causing hardship to the plaintiff
¶ 802Issues
i.1. Whether the trial court's rejection of I.A. Nos. 14 and 15, seeking further cross-examination of PW.1, warrants interference under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, given the petitioners' partial failure to avail themselves of the earlier permitted opportunities
¶ 6 · ¶ 7 · ¶ 8ii.2. Whether notice to the respondents should be issued, or whether it may be dispensed with to avoid further stay and delay in the suit
¶ 403Law Applied
The order does not cite any specific statutory provision, including any provision of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
The Court relied on its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution to examine the trial court's order
¶ 1It drew on the principle that protracted civil proceedings must be curtailed, and that a stay of the suit pending notice to respondents would cause avoidable further delay, justifying dispensing with notice
¶ 4 · ¶ 5It applied its earlier order in W.P. No. 22236/2021, dated 18.12.2025, which permitted further cross-examination of PW.1 subject to costs
¶ 6It further applied the principle that hardship or inconvenience caused to a witness may be compensated by imposing costs, rather than by denying the opportunity altogether
¶ 804Reasoning
The Court held that the petitioners had not availed themselves of the cross-examination opportunity granted as far back as 2021, and that the delay thereafter was largely attributable to them, as more than two opportunities were not used despite the earlier order
¶ 6 · ¶ 7It accepted that the Trial Court's reasons for rejection were considered, and that the failure to conclude the cross-examination was "partly attributable" to the petitioners
¶ 8However, the Court recognised that the cross-examination remained incomplete and that it was partly due to the Court's own time constraints, which could not be ignored
¶ 7Applying the principle that PW.1's inconvenience can be compensated by costs, the Court entertained the petition and granted a final, limited opportunity
¶ 8To prevent a further stay of the suit, notice to respondents was dispensed with
¶ 4The Court also imposed strict conditions to prevent further delay, including a bar on seeking any further opportunity
¶ 9(V)05Holding
The Court held that the failure to complete cross-examination was partly attributable to the petitioners, but the incomplete cross-examination and the hardship to PW.1 could be addressed by costs. The writ petition is allowed in part
¶ 8 · ¶ 9(I)The order dated 22.08.2026 is set aside, and I.A. Nos. 14 and 15 are allowed
¶ 9(II) · ¶ 9(III)The petitioners may further cross-examine PW.1 on the next date of hearing fixed by the Trial Court. They are not entitled to seek any further opportunity for cross-examination
¶ 9(IV) · ¶ 9(V)Cross-examination must be completed on the same day, without adjournment for any reason, subject to costs of Rs. 25,000 payable to PW.1
¶ 9(VI)Notice to respondents was dispensed with
¶ 4 · cause titleOriginal Court PDF
SRI VENKATA NARAYANAvsSRI M S HARISH @ SRI ANANDDA OJASWIN
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
