01Facts
The petitioner (defendant side) challenged two orders in O.S. No. 238/2020, a suit for declaration and consequential reliefs instituted in 2020, pending before the C/C II Addl. Civil Judge and JMFC, Heggadadevanakote.
PW.1 was examined on 09.01.2023 and documents were marked.
¶ 4, 5Between 09.01.2023 and 16.01.2025, the petitioners were granted several opportunities to cross-examine PW.1. After a further cross-examination application was allowed, they did not avail it, and cross-examination was recorded as nil on 29.03.2025.
¶ 5A second application was allowed; the petitioners partly cross-examined PW.1, sought more time, did not complete the cross-examination, and it was closed. The matter was posted for defendants' evidence on 18.09.2025. The Trial Court recorded that PW.1 was present on the listed dates.
¶ 6The defendants' evidence opportunity remained unutilised until 03.06.2026.
¶ 7Meanwhile, the written statement was amended, and time to lead defendants' evidence was extended to 16.09.2026.
¶ 8An application to further cross-examine PW.1 (filed 14.10.2025) was rejected on 05.11.2025.
¶ 9An application to adduce defendants' evidence (filed 23.09.2026) was rejected on 03.10.2026.
¶ 9The Trial Court noted that the petitioners sought to reopen the case only when the matter was posted for final arguments.
¶ 10The petitioners' sole explanation was counsel's mistake.
¶ 2, 1202Issues
i.1. Whether the Trial Court erred in rejecting the application under Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC r/w Section 151 CPC seeking recall of PW.1 for further cross-examination.
¶ 1, 5, 9ii.2. Whether the Trial Court erred in rejecting the application seeking permission to reopen the case and adduce defendants' evidence.
¶ 1, 9iii.3. Whether the plea of mistake of counsel is a sufficient ground to reopen proceedings after repeated opportunities have been granted and not availed.
¶ 2, 12–15iv.4. Whether the impugned orders warrant interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 1603Law Applied
Article 227 of the Constitution is the source of the High Court's supervisory jurisdiction over the Trial Court's interlocutory orders.
¶ 1, 16Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC permits a court to recall a witness for further examination at any stage, and Section 151 CPC preserves the court's inherent powers.
¶ 1The petitioners also invoked Section 94(e) CPC.
A litigant's repeated failure to avail itself of granted opportunities is not a compelling ground for reopening proceedings, and a plea of counsel's mistake cannot be accepted as a matter of course. Litigants and counsel are expected to exercise due diligence, and blaming predecessor counsel must not be encouraged.
¶ 13–15Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 94Section 151
04Reasoning
The Court examined the procedural record and found that the petitioners were not denied any opportunity. The Trial Court had repeatedly allowed cross-examination and defence evidence, but the petitioners let each opportunity lapse. The Court distinguished this from a case where a party is denied a chance to cross-examine or lead evidence.
¶ 5, 6, 7, 11The only explanation offered, counsel's mistake, was held to be unsupported by any compelling circumstance. Applying the principle that such explanations cannot be accepted automatically, particularly after repeated indulgence, the Court found the belated application at the final-arguments stage to be a continuation of earlier delaying tactics. The Court also noted the succeeding counsel's tendency to shift blame to predecessors and held that such allegations must be made with due diligence.
¶ 10, 11, 12, 13, 1405Holding
The plea of counsel's mistake was held insufficient to reopen proceedings where repeated opportunities had been granted and not availed. The impugned orders rejecting further cross-examination of PW.1 and the reopening for defendants' evidence were found free of error.
¶ 12, 15, 16No case for interference under Article 227 was made out, and the writ petition is dismissed. The Trial Court's orders stand, and the suit's posture as reflected in the record remains unaltered.
¶ 10, 16, 17Original Court PDF
SRI ABDUL RAHAMANvsSRI. M. R. RADHAKRISHNA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
